Reply To: Eruv in Brooklyn

Home Forums Shabbos! Eruv in Brooklyn Reply To: Eruv in Brooklyn


Rav Hirsch continues:

Page 7 comment 25:

Page 7 comment 26:

Page 8 comment 27:

Page 8 comment 28-30:

Has already been discussed in comment 24-26.

Page 8 comment 31:

Page 9 comment 32:

Page 9 comment 33:

Has already been discussed in comment 15.

Page 9 comment 34:

[that Rav Moshe agrees that there is almost no true reshus harabbim today] [using a cane on Shabbos]

Page 9 comment 35:

[Regarding the Manhattan eruv, Rav Moshe agreed that the rabbanan can do as they please (Igros Moshe, O.C. 4:89 and HaPardes, 33rd year, vol. 9) but then signed on the 1962 takanah against an eruv. However, Rav Moshe stated (Igros Moshe, O.C. 4:86 and Addendum to O.C. 4:89) that he had signed against the Manhattan eruv because Rav Aharon Kotler zt”l and other members of the Agudas HaRabbonim had enacted a takanah against establishing an eruv in Manhattan.]

Page 9 comment 36:

Page 9 comment 37:

Page 10 comment 38:

Page 10 comment 39:

Page 10 comment 40: