Question:
I live on the cul de sac (Dead End) street within the “Eruv” boundries. A few of the home owners use the Flatbush Eruv, other don’t. Because the area is enclosed on three sides, it was fairly easy to string a line from a home on side of the street to the other, and behold, we have an Eruv for the entire street.
Now, according to the “No Eruv in Flatbush/Brooklyn group”, is our Eruv muter if it was approved for meeting all other criteria for eruvin?
If the answer is yes, then why not make eruvin in Flatbush which would exclude the disputed areas?