HaLeiVi -“Health, you asked earlier who’s whim it should be up to.(!) It shouldn’t be up to anyone’s whim. If they want to have an article about an Hashkafic topic, it should be penned by an Adam Gadol.”
Do you think Gedolim have time to write articles? When you start your mag -I’d like to see how many Gedolim you get to write for it.
“Hashkafa, especially something from the Ikrei Emuna, is not to based on someone’s musings.”
Who said that this was what he based his article on? He based it on the way he was taught acc. to those Shittos who hold like him.
When you make your mag, you will include every Shittah possible.
“If an author would give some psychological advice I think the tables would turn.”
I doubt that, even if every shrink in the world disagreed with the author. He is entitled to his opinion. But in this case, he doesn’t have everyone arguing with him – he has plenty on his side!