Reply To: The Mechalel Shabbos Troll

Apy, the halacha is the a mechalel shabbos is not a yid halachicly. there are heteirim for a tinok shenishba, which don’t apply if the person in question has contact with frum Jews. You don’t need any great lomdus here. Someone who knows from Orthodoxy and decides “no” is a mechalel shabbos.

There is a second nafka mina, that one is not allowed the be mechalel shabbos to save the life of a mechalel shabbos. So if anyone know who it is, they must inform hatzalah not to be mechalel shabbos for him.