Where are the Jews of Saudi Arabia? Did they migrate? No. They were killed. Read up.
You are bringing up a specific large event of which you don’t know of an Arabian counterpart. Also, you are bringing up events from long ago.
This is not a contest of who is more capable of inflicting harm. The idea is that you are saying it would be just fine living under Arab rule. The problems with that statement are:
Arabs themselves don’t live peacefully under Arab rule.
Arabs have consistantly mistreated Jews.
Arab mistreatment was more fatal. The pogroms usually did not wipe out a whole town.
In the recent history until the Holocaust, which the Arabs backed, there was more aggression under the Arabs.
The trend of recent history is what counts, since that is that is the time that we are living in. The holocaust didn’t happen every ten years, but Arab mistreatment was consistent.
And finally, I don’t care if it was worse under the Christians. I’m not advocating living under Christian rule. Aren’t we talking about Jewish rule?