Home › Forums › Decaffeinated Coffee › What's the argument against having a Madina? › Reply To: What's the argument against having a Madina?
rabbiofberlin -“In their “wisdom”, the moderators routinely omit to print my contributions.”
B’H -they do their job!!!
“So be it- but I have to be “moiche” (in the language of some of the posters) on this “alilas dam” (for the unitiated, it means blood libel) at what some posters routinely decry the fact that more jews have been killed in Eretz Yisroel than elsewhere in the world. Conveniently, they start the clock after the medinah was founded- conveniently omitting the Holocaust, the Russian pogroms under the czars and the Communists, the many persecutions in all countries-including the Arab nations, for centuries.”
The reason why they “Conveniently start the clock after the medinah was founded”, is because you didn’t even read what the point of argument is. You are so brainwashed by your ideals that you can’t even begin to understand s/o else’s point! The point is that the Medina’s claim to existance -of that we are protecting Jews, is Not the least bit realistic right now. Maybe before ’48 -a Jewish run country would protect Jews -maybe in the possible future if Countries turn against Jews -a Jewish run country would be good, but not right now. The most likely country that Jews will be killed by terror, in the here & now -is Israel!
So why not give Israel to the Goyim, like Turkey, with guarantees from the nations of the world that all terror will stop?!?!?