Reply To: Discuss the (soon to be expiring) Tal Law Here

Home Forums Politics Discuss the (soon to be expiring) Tal Law Here Reply To: Discuss the (soon to be expiring) Tal Law Here

#874420
ymb
Member

As I said, I am not interested in re-opening the Kastner debate, “shmoel”. But allow me to answer your (seemingly) provocative question- that it was Eichmann who saved the jews by allowing this train to go through.

Eichmann was caught in 1960 and executed in 1962. So he lived for another 17 years after the war. WHY? If you believe, as you constantly write, that everything is ‘min hashomaym”, why did HKBH allow him to live (pretty well ,I may say) for fiteen years after his dastardly and evil deeds?

Maybe, just maybe, it was the “sechar’ (reward) for having let 1700 Jews live. I’d like to hear your answer on that.

so what was he according to you???a tsaddik(???)??so why did the israelis kill him??

a rasha(and he only merited to live that long cuz rasha vetov lo to punish him better in the next world)??then why is kastner any different???