Avi K: “Zichmich, you are the one who is haughty and arogant. An army cannot have a different pesak for each Jewish soldier.”
That is correct. So in order to accomadate the chareidim the army should follow the view of their rabbonim.
“Their is an Army Rabbinate and they have the status of mara d’atra.”
That is your personal opinion. The chareidim [myself included] disagree with your assesment of what does or does’nt consitute “mara d’atra.
“Unless someone is (really) learning, disabled, etc.he has an absolute Tora obligation to serve.”
As I mentioned before, the chareidim don’t agree with your “Torah.” In OUR torah, according to our Rabbonim there is no such obligation.
BTW Do you disagree that the army is lax in certain mitzvas and justifying because you believe it’s a mitzva to serve in the army, or do you believe that the IDF’s yiddishkeit is the best there is?