Health “Her lack of respect also showed a lack of respect to the Judge as person, not just to him as a member of our Gov.!”
Tell me, if I am rude to you as a person does that give me the right to take you away from your family and loved ones and make you give all the money you make for an entire year back to the system I represent?
“Her being rude to the system is Ok. This is shown by demonstrating in front of State legislators or in front of Congress. Her being Rude to this Judge has nothing to do with the System. Being Rude over here -just makes her a Muchutzav! She deserved anything he threw at her.”
If her being rude to the judge has nothing to do with being rude to the system and is only a “personal matter” than why does she deserve anything he threw at her?
“DR: But you then agreed with apushatayid who said: “The judge is not responsible to teach the girl respect.”
Respectfully, please realize your logical inaccuracy.
“but afterwards the State steps in.” You: “I agreed with him that in the first place it isn’t the Judge’s responsibility, but only after she broke laws. Btw, this is what I think he meant.””
No he was saying that the judge was not trying to teach her respect but rather he was upholding the decorum of the court and had nothing to do with teaching her anything.
He clearly said: “The judge is not responsible to teach the girl respect. Her parents are. His job is to preserve the dignity and decorum of the courtroom. He did.”
He might take back what he said but that is clearly what he had said originally.
To be honest, I think your thinking is convoluted and other people will be able to see that though I do not have the time to respond to your other posts. PS: Just because I agree with someone else and not with you does not make us the same person.