Health:
Me: “If I am rude to you personally does that give me the right to take you away and send you to prison until you pay me money?”
You: “It’s like a father hitting a son or a Rebbe hitting a student.”
It’s like a father hitting a son or a Rebbe hitting a student? Excuse me? You can’t see how a father hitting a child is different than a judge sentencing a girl to 30 days in a prison cell with strangers for being rude is different than a father hitting a student?
You: “If I had that right to, why not? The Judge had that right -whether you gave him permission or not.”
No Health I am sorry but you are wrong. People do have have the right to do whatever they want. The United States legal system was founded by breaking the laws of the Native Americans and founded their own laws by force. Why on earth do you think that if the United States Constitution or State Constitution says it is legal that makes it morally acceptable? The entire thread in the fist place is about what is morally acceptable or not.
Me: “If her being rude to the judge has nothing to do with being rude to the system and is only a “personal matter” than why does she deserve anything he threw at her? (i.e. a month in a jail cell with total (possibly dangerous) strangers”
You: “She deserved it – like I just explained.”
I don’t really think you explained it in any logical manner.
You: “And posters who say they don’t have the time to answer is usually due to the fact that they don’t have any logical answers.”
Me (now): No I really just don’t want to talk to you anymore.
I think that about sums it up. So can we stop talking and let other people have a say? You are wrong, just admit it and have some rachmanus for other people.