Reply To: Makeup on Shabbos

Home Forums Shabbos! Makeup on Shabbos Reply To: Makeup on Shabbos

#956382
nitpicker
Participant

to daas yochid:

I clearly demonstrated the contradiction twice.

rav moshe wrote a tshuva saying that many things were assur.

it is not a complex or long thsuva with chidushei torah. He merely restates the issur of tsvia and memachk. as I remember it since I last read it, there is not a word of heter in it except for the last line where he permits white face powder. Some, including the aformentioned and apparently you, said, “Aha! then the cases that are a little less stringent than the cases given must be mutter!”, thus claiming some makeup as mutter according to rav moshe. (but still forbidden according to others}

but some, and apparently you yourself, think this is a misinterpretation of the thsuva and the makeup is assur according to rav moshe!

you are on both sides of the argument as to what rav moshe meant.

that’s 3 times. the contradiction in your words is there, even If I am not remembering the tshuva exactly.

I not trying to be harsh, just logical.

sidenote:

my unusual burst of activity in CR since just before pesach once again is a response to period of extreme pressure at work.

It is time for me to go back to simmer.