mischief – I’ve never tried it, so I don’t know.
But seriously, depends what you mean by ‘a lot’. I generally like the makeup look, and rarely notice there being too much. If it looks good, I like it. But this is one of those preference things – every guy likes something different (I’ve discovered that with my friend who keeps trying to set me up with people I’m not attracted to). And some guys don’t like makeup at all.