- This topic has 27 replies, 13 voices, and was last updated 13 years, 4 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Are there any benefits or risks in having or obtaining dual citizenship from another country?
depends which country 🙂
Hungary is EU. That means that you can travel/live/work anywhere in the EU without any restrictions. No downside.
The benefit of Dual citizenship, is that you can renounce your
US citizenship, any you can work in Europe, and not be double
taxed by the IRS. (US is the only country in the world that taxes
foreign earned income).
A negative of dual citizenship is that you can be subject to obligations such as military service and jury duty in either country.
“US is the only country in the world that taxes
foreign earned income”
True, but most of us don’t make enough money to be taxed by the US.
A negative of dual citizenship is that you can be subject to obligations such as military service and jury duty in either country.
You may actually be a dual citizen already without you having done anything or even knowing about it. Many countries automatically consider the children of citizens to automatically be a citizen at birth, regardless where they are born. So if your great-grandfather was (say) a Hungarian citizen but moved to the U.S. in the 1920’s, and your grandfather, father and yourself were all born in the U.S. (and never even visited Hungary), you, your father and grandfather would still all be citizens of Hungary.
What, if any, obligations that technically entails you to as a Hungarian citizen (i.e. military) I don’t know. But I don’t believe they have a military draft currently in any event. (Although, like anything, that may change in the future.)
From the Wikipedia article on Hungarian nationality law:
“The existing Hungarian nationality law dates from 1993. Prior to this date, rules for acquisition and loss of Hungarian citizenship may have been different. With the new Hungarian nationality law, by January 2011, every person who was a Hungarian citizen or is a descendant of a people who was a Hungarian citizen before 1920, and speaks Hungarian may apply to become a Hungarian citizen even if he or she does not live in Hungary.”
“The 2011 Hungarian Citizenship law allows all ethnic Hungarians to apply for simplified naturalisation if they are able to prove knowledge of the Hungarian Language and provide evidence that he or she does indeed have Hungarian ancestry.”
That new law it is referring to applies to non-citizens wishing to naturalize as a Hungarian citizen. In 2011 they liberalized it to allow anyone who descends from pre-1920 areas that used to be in Hungary (i.e. “ethinic Hungarians”) even if they do not live in the modern borders of Hungary to apply for citizenship.
Nevertheless, my previous comment on those who descend from someone who was a Hungarian citizen any time from 1920 on (when its modern day borders came into existence after the first world war) are citizens automatically (and therefore need not naturalize) still stands.
Many other countries (especially in Europe) have similar “jus sanguinis” citizenship laws.
“Nevertheless, my previous comment on those who descend from someone who was a Hungarian citizen any time from 1920 on (when its modern day borders came into existence after the first world war) are citizens automatically (and therefore need not naturalize) still stands.”
I wasn’t arguing.
‘Many other countries (especially in Europe) have similar “jus sanguinis” citizenship laws.’
In fact most of the Eastern Hemisphere has “jus sanguinis”. However, “jus soli” — citizenship by virtue of being born in the country — is the rule in almost every Western Hemisphere country.
The US has both — jus soli is in the US Constitution, and jus sanguinis is established by Act of Congress. Canada and Mexico have almost identical laws. (Jus sanguinis is why Barack Obama would have been a US Citizen by birth even had he been born in Kenya.)
I a citizen of 3 countries, (USA, UK, Israel). It has some benefits. Mostly that I can choose to live in a wide number of places. In theory it does have some level of obligation as well but not so onerous.
If you think you could be eligible for Hungarian citizenship call their embassy in your country, that is what it is there for!
you are not allowed to enter the usa on 2 passports fyi! my european expired i just never renewed but i have citizenship wether its benificial or not im not sure but check out the laws about having 2 different passports at one point it was not allowed
Most of us don’t make enough money to be taxed by the US?
Good percentage of people in Europe are making over $90,000/year,
especially now with the very low dollar. e.g. Who in Switzerland
makes less then 72,000 CHF a year?
Im an american and canadian- just causes me issues when i go to canada
“Good percentage of people in Europe are making over $90,000/year,
especially now with the very low dollar. e.g. Who in Switzerland
makes less then 72,000 CHF a year?”
In that case, you can take the foreign tax credit or the foreign tax deduction.
Foreign tax credit doesn’t help much, e.g. for a person living in
Switzerland. Average position pays over 120,000 CHF/year, and income
tax here is only about 10-15% depending on where you reside.
The US has no problem with people having 2 passports but they ask you to use your US passport when leaving/arriving the US. The other country might have a similar requirement, so if you go from the US to the other country and back, you have to travel with both passports and show each country it’s passport.
It is of benefit to all us Yidden to have dual citizenship. During WW11, many who had dual passports were able to escape from the inferno.
How can an American (living in the U.S.) obtain a second citizenship?
“Average position pays over 120,000 CHF/year, and income
tax here is only about 10-15% depending on where you reside.”
So you just pay US income tax. What is the problem?
(And so much for the canard that taxes in Europe are astronomical.)
Why would he be exempt from Swiss taxes?
Also, I doubt Switzerland is a good representation of taxes generally in Europe.
Switzerland is not part of the European Union. Majority of the
EU countries, do have larger taxes, but the gov’t covers numerous social benefits for all residents, e.g. universal medical coverage, childcare, unemployment insurance, and free university education.
In the US, the cost of medical insurance is astronomical,
and it does not cover pre-existing conditions. In Europe, for people that work, the quality of life is better, e.g. all companies must give at least 5 weeks vacation, and working overtime and on Sunday is strictly regulated.
Adorable- me as well.. but never have any problems..
How can an American (living in the U.S.) obtain a second citizenship?
There are a few ways
1) Be defended from someone who is from a country where you can get citizenship
2) Move to a different country and become a citizen (rules will vary by country)
3) Make Aliyah to Israel.
tracht & adorable: How are you Canadian citizens? Were you born there or did you get it through your parents?
Be defended from someone who is from a country where you can get citizenship
What does that mean?
Born in canada and my dad is from the usa so it was very easy for me to become an american..
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.