- This topic has 21 replies, 11 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 11 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Oh,no. Long rant listing terrible effects of such an occurrence.
they like jewish music.
If non Jews listen to Jewish music, they’ll like it and adopt it as their own. Meanwhile, Jews are busy adopting non Jewish music as their own, so the result would be that people will think that non Jewish music is really Jewish music.
scared driver delight – not that MANY non jews listen to jewish music only my cleaning lady.
I WAS ONCE IN THE HOSPITAL AND MY NEIGHBOR, AN OLD NON JEW, ITALIAN, HAD UNCLE MOISHE ON HIS TV. HAD NO IDEA WHAT WAS GOING ON
youtube is filled with clips of non jews singing jewish music. some of it is very comical.
reb yid – i think the prof wasnt yelling he was just on caps lock by accident?
There used to be a guy who would drive around my neighborhood on Shabbos with Jewish music playing in his car. Dunno if he was a goy.
apushatayid, you mean like Perry Como or Johnny Mathis singing Kol Nidre?
no clue maybe someone otd who still liked jewish music?
what is ‘jewish’ music? music is part of reality. ever seen a jewish tree?
Things that are part of reality can’t be Jewish?
matisyahu had a significant non-jewish following
ZD, I think you’ve gone off topic.
DaasYochid:
(Burn! )
Only using the popular definition of “Jewish music” –
namely, “music created by and for Orthodox Jews.”
Even using that definition, did he not intend his music for a wider audience?
On topic, we once had a non Jewish worker in the house who liked Regesh, and even went to a Judaics store to buy a CD.
Weren’t you saying ZD was off-topic,
implying that Matisyahu wasn’t Jewish music?
Yes.
Does that not fit only with that definition?
when the song “Ban mir bist du sheyn” came out:
1) It was sung by a non- jewish group (Andrew Sisters)
2) Every Italian brick layer in NYC could be heard singing it as he worked
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.