- This topic has 28 replies, 16 voices, and was last updated 11 years, 6 months ago by .
-
Posts
-
Have you ever tried leining v’zos habracha during the week with regular trop? It’s impossible.
I’ve tried, not that easy. Same with the Yud Gimel Midos of laining on a taanis.
My Shul’s Minhag is that you only use the Yomim Nora’im Trop for Chassan Torah and Chassan B’reishis, so I shouldn’t really have a problem but I still do. It’s hard. Same with Shevi’i of Vayeira (I don’t have a problem with the previous two Aliyos for some reason).
I hate this title. sorry, PBA, but there are NO BAD PARSHAS in the Torah, the title just made me cringe, just like the other thread you started a couple weeks earlier ” Worst Parsha Ever” for Nitzovim VaYeilech! If you have trouble leining, just practice like everyone else!!
Why start a thread with such a nasty sounding connotation, so negative, about a Parsha?! Sorry I’m usually not grumpy or angered easily, but this thread title…..I mean ..really!!
i was wondering the same thing
but i figured id let you ask.
ooooh, it’s one of those mornings..my bad..(hic)..sorry..
L’Chaim, L’Chaim.
try concentrating on the sof pasuk and esnachta and the rest may fall into place. if that doesnt do it, try the zakef katon.
I have been laining on ???? ???? for the last number of years. Just this morning, there was nobody in shul to lain so I did it. I found that by going slowly I was able to stay on tune (I slipped once but fixed myself right away). This is especially in contrast to ???? ???? where it is customarily lained super-quick.
its EASY, stop over-thinking and just lain it like anything else. its actually more fun than laining many other pasrhiyos!
PBA: unfortunately, the title in the address bar gives it away…
http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/topic/second-worst-parsha-ever
Never found it that hard, you have to concentrate on the opening Reviei, and all flows well from there. I actually find the hardest part to lein at a normal pace, I am so used to going fast on Simchas Torah to speed everything along on the 8th, 9th, 10th time around.
yungerman1 – You remind me of a funny story, when I was a kid I once heard a baal korei mistakenly do the Taanis yud gimmel midos on Shabbos Chol HaMoed! You would be shocked how many people followed and said the yud gimmel middos out loud!
Love you too, popa!
I figure I have till sober to YomKippur up 🙂
Don’t mean to go off topic slightly, but which parshios do you all think is the hardest to lein in terms of preparation? I have always found the following difficult to lein:
Vayetzei, Vaera, Tazria. Any others?
Honestly, I find Vayeilech terrible to prepare. But the hardest by far is Vayikra, and it’s not even close.
Have you ever tried leining v’zos habracha during the week with regular trop? It’s impossible.
It’s not difficult at all.
But then again, I have about 25 years of experience doing it.
The Wolf
Whatever it is, it’s not nearly as hard as practicing megillas esther/rus/eichah etc, for a while and then trying to switch to reg. trop
For me, personally, the hardest portions are those that have multiple iterations, but each iteration is slightly different. For example, the last aliya of Pinchas, where the mussafim for each of the days of Succos is ever-so-slightly different (not in the number of animals brought, but in prefixes and suffixes added to/subtracted from words), is challenging to me.
(Although, oddly, the nesi’im, which is similar, doesn’t give me trouble.)
The Wolf
Sam2: Vayikra was my bar mitzvah parsha and I leined it then and it’s still harder for me than most other parshiot
Never lained in my life, but as a former gabbai I found VaYakhel hard because of the “Es” and he “Eis”.
Never lained in my life, but as a former gabbai I found VaYakhel hard because of the “Es” and he “Eis”.
Yes, but that’s only an issue in the first aliya.
Easy way to remember:
Es is always attached to another word. Eis has its own trup.
The Wolf
Someone asked me to lain at mincha last Shabbos and I refused because I get confused with the tune, turns out the guy who ended up laining had the same issue.
In terms of hard parshios to lain: tazria-metzora and vayikra.
Wolf: C’mon, you should know the difference. The nesi’im are exactly the same as each other. But the mussafim are just a bit different each day!
Hardest parshiyos in order:
-Matos & Maasei
-Tazria & Metzora
-Vayikra
-V’yakel & Pekudei
-Naso
-Chukas & Balak
-Ki Sisa
I think va’era is very difficult. So many sections begin with the same words but different trop. Many times it says Emor el Aharon, or Netei es matecha, or several other common phrases, each of which has different trop.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.