- This topic has 101 replies, 10 voices, and was last updated 8 hours, 40 minutes ago by .
-
Posts
-
I am also confused
why are hazals definitions of galut not good ‘working definitions’ ?
I did not post “random musings” …
I posted hazal’s definitions of galut
why are hazal’s definitions not ‘commonly agreed foundations’ ?
I am not disagreeing perse with anything you wrote
just that it is hollow ,incomplete and therefore misleading , to define a concept by only one characteristic …
all explanations by hazal are relevant …
.
.
or not ?
.
.maybe i am just having issue parsing your words. please make a concrete statement like “Gulis is ….”, so we will (hopefully) have a baseline agreement of what we are talking about.
[btw, i mean the thing we formally call “gulis” since chorbon bayis rishon, and perhaps since shibid mitzroyim. I don’t mean the nonspecific generalized word that could mean “gulis from my fathers house” or “personal gulis from myself”, etc. It is valuable you brought this up and the exact reason I want to clarify this word now.]
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.