What’s the point in “real” jewelry?

Home Forums Controversial Topics What’s the point in “real” jewelry?

Viewing 50 posts - 1 through 50 (of 53 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1289597
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    There are stories of people fooled by fakes. But what is the point of real jewelry if you can be fooled by fakes? The entire purpose of jewelry is to look pretty. If a fake looks good enough to fool you, it does the job just as well. (It is not fake jewelry, it’s just cheaper jewelry mistaken for more expensive.)

    #1289607
    agutyar
    Participant

    Real stones, i.e., diamonds, rubies, etc., have certain powers in ruchnious. You simply feel better with the real thing. Also gold. And don’t forget, diamonds are a girl’s best friend. Stop this business of giving a kallah a zakor!

    #1289631
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    But white sapphires are as real as rubies, but instead of being considered real sapphires, they are considered fake diamonds.

    #1289645
    ☕ DaasYochid ☕
    Participant

    What is a zakor?

    #1289683
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    The idea that crystals and stones have spiritual powers is a pagan thing.

    #1289708
    agutyar
    Participant

    A zakor is these glass stones they put in rings to look like diamonds. In English it’s a (zorkanda or something like that.)

    Perhaps the word “powers” is wrong, but the Cohen Gadol wore certain stones for those reasons. And a pearl can cause a baby to be born sooner and many women (after they are safely in bed in the hospital) will swallow down a tiny seed pearl ( at a certain point in the labor and not sooner) and the baby will usually be born within half and hour.
    Furthermore, women wear a ruby against their skin to prevent miscarriages, if I’m not mistaken, and these thing have their source in Gemorrah and are NOT pagan.

    Check out the stones of the Cohen Gadol and see that each has a deep meaning.

    #1289716
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    Those meanings are only valid in context.

    #1289769

    (It’s “zircon” [which, unlike cubic zirconia, is found in nature].)

    [A] pearl can cause a baby to be born sooner… women wear a ruby
    against their skin to prevent miscarriages, if I’m not mistaken, and these
    things have their source in Gemorrah and are NOT pagan.

    I’d like a source for that pearl business – Google isn’t showing me anything
    like that (not that that’s conclusive evidence). The even tekumah is
    in the Gemara. It seems to be identified by different sources as ruby, carnelian,
    and aetite (also known as eaglestone).
    I don’t think the concept of stones having powers is a pagan one.

    #1289770

    You end up with stuff like this, though:
    The pregnancy amulet is a unique kit with a ruby stone, carnelian, ‘even tekuma’ and a magnet that draws and strengthens the pregnancy. It hangs on a silver chain because silver is kabalistically associated with mercy, in contrast to gold which signifies judgment.

    #1289784
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    Pagans seem to think it’s a pagan thing.

    #1289791

    I suppose pagans think animal sacrifices are a pagan thing, too.

    #1289797
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    Most pagans are against animal sacrifice and carry protection crystals to keep animal-sacrificing people away.

    #1289800
    mw13
    Participant

    Makes people feel important.

    Why else would anybody drop a couple of grand on a rock?

    #1289820
    Lightbrite
    Participant

    Thanks to globalization and technological inventions, such as plastics, today we have access to beautiful inexpensive fake jewelry.

    #1289822
    Ex-CTLawyer
    Participant

    Real Jewelry…diamonds, high karat gold, precious stones (Emeralds, Sapphires and Rubies) are high value, low weight, easily transportable, hidden wealth that may be concealed, used to buy one’s way to freedom, greasing the palm of a border or prison guard or visa granting official.

    My family may have arrived in the USA back in the late 1860s and early 1870s, but until my parents bought their first house in 1951 always rented and kept gold and jewels on hand should an instant flight be necessary as was too often the case in Europe. My generation all own real estate, but all keep ready gold, gems and cash in easy reach should the need arise.

    #1289825
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    But if you wear a ring that cost a fortune, for example, you’re basically asking to drop your fortune down the sink drain by accident.

    #1289864
    Joseph
    Participant

    The OP is correct. “Fake” jewelry is just as good as “real” jewelry if you could hardly tell the difference.

    Don’t waste yiddishe gelt on “real” jewelry.

    Furthermore, diamond rings for engagements is not a Jewish minhag; it comes directly from the diamond industry and is of relatively very recent vintage.

    Don’t give diamond engagement rings.

    #1289873
    Ex-CTLawyer
    Participant

    @Joseph
    The diamond engagement ring has been en vogue since the diamond strikes in South Africa circa 1866 which made diamonds plentiful and more affordable to the emerging middle class in western society.

    Your suggestion to not buy diamond engagement rings could hurt the economic livelihood of many frum yidden in the diamond trade…from importers to cutters,setters and retailers.

    #1289876
    agutyar
    Participant

    PLEASE dear friends. Just because someone made a mistake and thought it was pagan doesn’t mean that he’s pagan. Let’s be careful how we speak and we may see Moshiach any day this week.

    #1289884
    ☕ DaasYochid ☕
    Participant

    Your suggestion to not buy diamond engagement rings could hurt the economic livelihood of many frum yidden in the diamond trade…from importers to cutters,setters and retailers.

    Yes, and suggesting that people curb their chasunah expenses hurts the livelihood of caterers, florists, musicians, and photographers, and suggesting people eat healthy and exercise hurts doctors and undertakers.

    #1289908
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    Most crystal healing and stuff is pagan. And bless your heart, agutyar, but a cheaper stone is just as much a gemstone.

    #1289917
    Ex-CTLawyer
    Participant

    DY………..
    There is a Huge difference between suggesting people curb wedding expenses. which merely reduces the amount spent, than stating not to buy a product that eliminates all money spent.

    OOT. the chances are much greater that the florist, photographer and union musicians are not frum yidden or even Jews at all.

    I married off one daughter last year and another will be wed I”H this August at our home. The caterer is a frum yid coming from NY. The florist, photographer, table and chair rental company are all local businesses, not frum. They do business with me and Mrs. CTL and we in turn do business with them. There is no local frum alternative and no reason to import these items or people. The chosan and his parents are providing the band. I have no information yet as to the name of the band, only know that it will be 6 men.
    I know that the engagement and wedding jewelry are coming from frum craftsmen, but this is a purchase I am not involved in.

    #1289964
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    Engagement rings are a problem because they cost a fortune and are worn a on afinger. It’s not a good idea to wear something on your finger all day if you’d be devastated if you lost it.
    They are different from other kallah jewelry because other jewelry does not have to be removed for hand washing.

    Some jewels, such as star sapphire, look very different from other stones and can’t be replaced with something else for a similar look. But an emerald in an affordable range is flawed and fragile, so you should probably “fake” it with a tsavorite (often not cheaper, but still considered a fake), or chrome diopside.

    #1289966
    ☕ DaasYochid ☕
    Participant

    First, mazel tov.

    Please be aware that your financial situation and locale are likely very different than the vast majority of the CR readership.

    Curbing wedding expenses in the in town yeshiva community often does eliminate jobs – a one man band means no drummer, bass, guitar, or horn players.

    A cheaper photographer means fewer assistants.

    Plastic gemach flowers means no florist.

    Simpler cuisine means less profit for the caterer, and fewer workers.

    You also didn’t answer my point that good health tips cuts income from undertaker’s.

    Mainly, though, you missed the point I’m making, which is that you don’t advise people to spend money they likely don’t have because someone else will lose out. Unfortunately, because of societal pressure, people spend more money than they can afford on simchas.

    B”H, a lot of progress has been made on the cost of the actual affair, with “takana packages” and the like a way for people to save. Jewelry, however, has not had the same success. Although in some communities, attempts have been made to keep costs down, overall it hasn’t worked.

    Halevai that Joseph’s suggestion would become reality.

    #1289977
    mentsch1
    Participant

    RY23
    The RAMBAN by the choshen in shemos has a long piece that goes through the stones in the choshen and ascribes “powers” to them
    For example, the ruby is reuvens stone and connects to the story of reuven bringing his mother mandrakes, which apparently have fertility powers (and that is why he was bringing them to Laya) so the ruby stone apparently has fertility powers.
    Hence the extremely popular minhag for pregnant women to wear rubies.
    Our religion also ascribes “powers” to zodiac signs. You can argue as to whether it still applies. But the concept is well documented

    #1289984
    mentsch1
    Participant

    As for the OP
    I’m reasonably sure this will split among male/female lines
    Few women want or treasure a “fake” diamond (unless they are worried about conflict diamonds, hence Hollywood actresses pushing stones like Moissanite which are supposedly even more pretty than real diamonds)
    When I tried to convince my (very low maintenance) wife to get Moissanite instead of real, it didn’t fly.
    So the answer to the question is
    “because it makes your wife happy!”

    #1289995
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    The stones of the choshen include inexpensive semiprecious stones.

    #1290020
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    But why get a diamond or a fake diamond when you can get a nice other stone like sapphire or topaz?

    #1290041
    mentsch1
    Participant

    RY23
    Listen
    I’m not arguing the point
    As a guy, I find these things baffling. But don’t you find most things about women baffling? And I’m sure they feel the same way.

    #1290068
    Joseph
    Participant

    mentch1, the menfolk are supposed to bring the intellectual side of things, which should take precedence over the emotional side of things.

    #1290066
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    Humans in general are weird.

    #1290081
    Avram in MD
    Participant

    RebYidd23,

    Humans in general are weird.

    Indeed. Yet Hashem still loves us.

    #1290080
    Avram in MD
    Participant

    RebYidd23,

    There are stories of people fooled by fakes. But what is the point of real jewelry if you can be fooled by fakes? The entire purpose of jewelry is to look pretty.

    I think the primary purpose of giving jewelry is to bring joy to the recipient. Cultural norms are not always “rational”, and “real” gold and “real” diamonds are usually treasured more than “fake” varieties, even if they visually appear the same. Additionally, part of the intended statement when giving expensive jewelry is that the recipient is valuable to the giver, and therefore the giver is willing to invest his resources for the recipient’s pleasure. That said, I agree 100% with Joseph and DaasYochid that one should not spend beyond his means on jewelry.

    #1290096
    mentsch1
    Participant

    Joseph
    Next time your wife wants something I would like to suggest the following
    “Honey, I know it’s our 25th Anniversary, but intellectually there is nothing different about today vs yesterday. So I bought you a vacuum”
    Let me know how it goes
    I guarantee results.

    #1290100
    the true emes
    Participant

    Jewelry can be used as part of the kesubah gelt.

    #1290106
    Ex-CTLawyer
    Participant

    DY…………
    I have repeatedly said on this forum that people should only buy what they can afford.

    If you can’t afford a diamond, don’t buy one.
    This is different than an opinion expressed that no one should buy a diamond engagement ring.

    BTW…your ‘good health tips cuts income from undertakers’ FAILS the ‘post hoc ergo propter hoc’ logic test. After this, therefore because of this.

    Being healthy delays death, it doesn’t eliminate it. If there are 100 people they ALL die eventually and become business for the undertaker. A longer, healthier life does not equal immortality.

    #1290113
    agutyar
    Participant

    to Joseph
    There are times when you need emotions and not intellect, like when giving a diamond engagement ring. But for sure don’t spend too much. Also, she has to look at the ring every once in a while to make sure that the little “teeth” holding it in place have not become thin and weak and make sure that the diamond is not loose. If she takes it off for netilas yadayim (not everyone does) be careful! Don’t leave it on the side of the sink and not in your mouth!

    #1290130
    👑RebYidd23
    Participant

    But that’s the problem. A ring is another piece of stress, a thing you have to be careful with. An expensive thing that you have to keep forever because De Beers decided that it symbolizes your marriage.

    #1290147
    Avram in MD
    Participant

    agutyar,

    and not in your mouth!

    Certainly! Because it’s hard to make a bracha with a ring in your mouth 🙂

    #1290141
    Avram in MD
    Participant

    RebYidd23,

    A ring is another piece of stress, a thing you have to be careful with.

    I don’t think it has to be stressful. Making some precautions habitual can greatly reduce the potential for loss. And valuable jewelry doesn’t have a monopoly on things with sentimental value that can be lost. About the saddest I have ever seen my wife over losing a thing was when a pipe-cleaner flower that my daughter made for her got destroyed.

    #1290608
    agutyar
    Participant

    To Avram, in MD
    That was SO funny! You’re right about the bracha, but I was thinking of her swallowing it. And by the way, there are daos that if you wear the ring even when you knead dough, then you can keep it on when you wash.

    to C4ndom3x: you’re right, it’s zircon, not zakor. Thank you for the correction.

    It’s true, wedding expenses should be kept down so the parents don’t go broke, and so there will be money left for the next in line, and so you can help them more with rent or buying, and also we shouldn’t make other people feel that they have to keep up or be embarrassed. But I would cut back on something else, and not the diamond ring, unless in the States it’s out of control already. One of my daughters just brought her daughter-in-law a beautiful diamond ring for $700 and the girl is glowing from happiness. Maybe it’s different here in Israel.

    Thank G-d we have married off all our children and are seeing our grandchildren getting married and are great-grandchildren being born. And I wish all of you naches and bracha and hatzlacha.rabah.

    #1290648
    agutyar
    Participant

    P.S.
    to Avram in MD

    Your wife sounds like a very special person and a devoted and sensitive mother.

    #1290635
    ☕ DaasYochid ☕
    Participant

    One of my daughters just brought her daughter-in-law a beautiful diamond ring for $700 and the girl is glowing from happiness. Maybe it’s different here in Israel.

    In the U.S., unfortunately, that would be a rare story. Or the daughter in law would be faking it.

    #1291031
    yehudayona
    Participant

    The subject of engagement rings has been discussed in other threads, where I’ve mentioned that my wife and I decided against an engagement ring because when we got engaged, in the days of apartheid in South Africa, all diamonds were tainted. Years later, she asked for a CZ solitaire, and picked one out on eBay.

    The whole idea of the need for a diamond engagement ring was created by the diamond cartel. Edward Jay Epstein wrote an article in The Atlantic magazine in 1982 entitled “Have You Ever Tried to Sell a Diamond?” in which he reveals the history of a remarkably successful marketing campaign.

    Diamonds aren’t forever — the one in my mother’s engagement ring became worthless when it developed internal fractures as the result of a blow.

    #1291042
    Lightbrite
    Participant

    There is an amazing true story a rabbi shared in a shiur!!!

    Husband and wife got married.
    Shortly after wedding they took a walk on the beach.
    They come back.
    The wife couldn’t find her ring! It wasn’t on her finger.
    Where was the ring?
    Shhh don’t tell family, we’ll find it.
    Went back to the beach. Looked everywhere.
    Told family. Both sides went searching.
    No avail! No ring! Husband’s family so angry!
    After that, every time husband and wife were with husband’s family, they put her down. “Oh I want to give you ….. but I know you’ll lose it, so I’m giving it to your husband so he makes sure that it doesn’t disappear” snark snark
    Wife felt so bad. Year after year. So ashamed.
    Many years many many years later, husband and wife go somewhere and husband wears same tux jacket from wedding night
    Husband finds wedding ring! Wife must have asked him to keep it safe before they walked on the beach! Was there safe all along! Wow!!!
    Wife vindicated!
    From that point wife makes fun of husband. Finds ways to put him down about being so forgetful. All this time she was the responsible one! Husband takes it without a word.
    Years later. Years years many years later! Husband and wife were in a financial bind. Wife wanted to sell the ring. Make the sacrifice for them.
    She takes the ring to a jeweler for an appraisal.
    She tells the jeweler it’s approximate value.
    Jeweler says no. No way. Sorry lady.
    Wife goes home and searches all around for the ring’s papers. She finds a receipt. The purchase of the ring was made right before she and husband went to that event where he wore the tux jacket!
    Confronts husband. Husband confesses. He felt so horrible at how ashamed she felt and how his family treated her that he saved up year after year to finally but her a new diamond ring.
    This ring was worth more than the first one!
    Wife said, “All these years I was so mean to you, and you said nothing when all along you knew the truth and kept it secret?!”
    Yes.

    #1291102
    Avram in MD
    Participant

    He felt so horrible at how ashamed she felt and how his family treated her that he saved up year after year to finally but her a new diamond ring.

    He should have told her that she was more important to him than all of the diamond rings in the world. And then he should have told his family to back off, and that any scorn directed towards his wife was no different than scorn directed towards him.

    #1291731

    That story can be found in one of Chaim Walder’s People Speak books.

    #1291890
    agutyar
    Participant

    When in-laws become out-laws our lives can collapse. As a daughter-in-law and also a mother-in-law I can tell you that the best thing is to remain close and loving to your daughters/sons- in- law. Believe me, you will only gain by being close. And lose by starting up and interfering. If it’s not life threatening, keep quiet. I have a sister-in-law who refused to name any of her daughters after her paternal grandmother because of the aggravation she caused her mother (the daughter-in-law). So what did that women gain?

    #1302118
    Ex-CTLawyer
    Participant

    Agutyar….

    My late mother A”H, had the BEST advice for being a good mother in law:
    KEEP YOUR MOUTH SHUT AND YOUR REFRIGERATOR OPEN.

    When she died 2 years ago she had lived to see all of her children reach at least 40 years of marriage. Her daughters and sons in law adored her, she never interfered or offered an unasked for opinion. She was always there when she was needed, but never intrusive in our lives.

    #1302116
    MRS PLONY
    Participant
Viewing 50 posts - 1 through 50 (of 53 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.