b1l

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 0 posts
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Abandonment of Nussach #631184
    b1l
    Participant

    Dear cantoresq:

    To your question, I read an enlightening article about chazzonus a few weeks ago in – I believe – a Hamodia magazine.

    I think it was Bentzion Miller (I’m not 100% certain) who said that the decline and fall of

    adherence to nusach, appreciation of chazzonus, etc. *began* back in the 20s and 30s when

    the Young Israel organization was appealing to young Jews who would have otherwise been lost to Judaism

    and – with the best and noblest of intentions – made the

    tefillo more … I’ll say “accessible” or “hands-on” by organizing smaller minyonim without the

    pomp and formality of choirs and – yes – chazzonim. I am not making any judgments about this – just stating what I came across.

    I find this quite convincing, but I was not around then.

    (Notice I emphasize “began”. Where we are today vis-a-vis nusach ignorance has other causes, I’m sure.

    One being the churban Europa hanora and the ensuing breakage of the mesorah.)

    BTW – I also bemoan the state of nusach-adherence these days. I am musically ignorant,

    but I grew up hearing European chazzonim and knowledgeable baalei tefillo. There was chein and taam.

    However, I do admit that I am not a big fan of prolonged virtuosic demonstrations.

    Just “dovor be-ito mah tov.”

    Best regards.

    in reply to: Black and White #622678
    b1l
    Participant

    Jews – rabbis included – used to wear colorful garb.

    Anti-Jewish decrees in Middle Ages forced Jews to adopt drab colors (gray, black). Ever since then, Jews have – as they often have done – taken what was meant to be derogatory and turned it into a badge of pride.

    I heard this on a history tape from Rabbi Wein.

    And hence the black suits.

    Cheers.

Viewing 0 posts