qwerty.613

Litvishe fellow’s chiming was misguided and inappropriate. By saying: “I don’t think people should be embarrassed by [exposing their] name publicly. I also don’t think that people should embarrass others publicly”, he tactfully agrees that qwerty613 can deride others, even denigrating Gedolei Yisroel by name, BUT no one should embarrass qwerty613. After all, HIS honor must be protected, as he tramples on the honor of our Gedolim. This is so illogical and misguided. But then Litvish fellow adds, “We have a Torah, and we must live by its ideals!”, as he tries to anchor his words in Torah. As someone who makes the bald, unsubstantiated claim of “a Musmach from many great Rabbonim”, one would expect him to know basic halacha, that if someone is talking in shul, one may publicly embarrass the offender to silence him. How much more so, when someone is constantly publishing comments that deride, slander and ridicule Gedolie Hador, there is an OBLIGATION to publicly silence the offender who is being mechalel shem shamaaayim and being mevazeh Gedolim. I write this simply to show that the misguided comment of Litvishe fellow actually raised a doubt about his claim of being “”a Musmach from many great Rabbonim”, in fact, adarabah, it points to “am haratzus”, ignorance of halacha, and Torah values and ideals.

therealchaidy – My take on this was that qwerty613 was motzi shem ra on various Gedolim, gornit pointed out the obscene comments and put a stop to it. Kol hakovod to him.

Litvishe Fellow – we all know that במקום חילול ה’ אין חולקין כבוד, qwerty613 was blatantly being mevazeh talmidei chaochomim, behind their back (I don’t expect that the Gedolim should respond to attacks, like a response from R’ Malkiel Kotler. likewise. those that are in Olom HaEmes like R’ Avigdor Miller z”l and the Lubavitcher Rebbe z”l and others). A person posting such vile trash against Gedolim is far worse than any michalel shabbos. As far as your bald claim of being a “musmach from many Rabbonim”, so were the supporters of Korach, they were roshei sanhedrin, and spoke out against Gedolei Hador, Moshe v’Aharon.