whattosay

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Mitzvos wen don’t keep anymore #1498915
    whattosay
    Participant

    Joseph: AFAIK the minhag among afar Din is not to do yibum. Rav Ovadia says Beis Din should push a guy to if he is lshem shamayim. Still, AFAIK the last yibum(at least in Israel) was in the 50’s

    in reply to: Crazy Purim idea??? Crazy yeshiva bachurim??? #1475265
    whattosay
    Participant

    Disgusting. Should not be tolerated, even for a joke. Kol hamevaze…

    in reply to: @Chabad Shluchah Please Explain Why Davening To/Betten a Rebbe is Okay #1471632
    whattosay
    Participant

    @SY
    I believe you are correct that there is an element of “anti-chabad”. If I may, I’d like to explain why this element exists.
    I am not chabad, but I have been connected to chabad and have chabad family and friends.
    One thing that upsets people, is the feeling of “primacy” of chabad. You will hear people(mostly baalabatim) saying things like “everyone is chabad, they just don’t know it yet”, and “everyone wants to be chabad and are jealous of us”. Obviously, this upsets people out of chabad, making us feel like our drachim are being put down and rejected our of hand. And yes, this does exist by many other groups. However, when this combines with the other issues (that I hope to lay out) it gives people an automatic negative association of chabad.
    The Moshiach thing is obviously another issue. Most non-chabad will believe that thinking the Rebbe ztz’l is Moshiach is at best stupid, and at worst kfira. Leading many people to suspect the average member of chabad of being a kofer(obviously, that is wrong.)
    Another problem is the rabid members. The tzfatim, the lunatics who eat on fasts. While these are a minority of a minority, they get a lot of airtime and attention. And yes, almost every groups has it’s madmen, but the chabad madmen are twisting legitimate chabad philosophy into actual kfira(I once was told by an earnest flag-pin wearing tzfasnik, that as soon as we show the Rebbe we want it he will send Moshiach.)
    And the final, and hardest to pin down point. At many of the tfillin donning stations, there are signs saying things like “the Rebbe said to put on tfillin”. Leading many of us to wonder -didn’t God say to put on tfillin? Isn’t that why we do it?
    Now, everyone is mechanics in such a way, we tell children if they make a brocha their parents will be proud, when we should Ben focusing on God’s pride. But with Chabad, there isn’t already a vocal group that focuses more on the Rebbe than on God. This adds to the suspicion that all chabad thinks about is the Rebbe.

    It isn’t a combination of these points(I believe) that leads people to automatically distrust Chabad with regards to religious matter. Add to that our different drochim, Andy people come across as hating you.

    I hope this hasn’t at least helped to clear up for you the background from which many of the people attacking your theology are coming from.

    in reply to: @Chabad Shluchah Please Explain Why Davening To/Betten a Rebbe is Okay #1471633
    whattosay
    Participant

    @SY
    I believe you are correct that there is an element of “anti-chabad”. If I may, I’d like to explain why this element exists.
    I am not chabad, but I have been connected to chabad and have chabad family and friends.
    One thing that upsets people, is the feeling of “primacy” of chabad. You will hear people(mostly baalabatim) saying things like “everyone is chabad, they just don’t know it yet”, and “everyone wants to be chabad and are jealous of us”. Obviously, this upsets people out of chabad, making us feel like our drachim are being put down and rejected our of hand. And yes, this does exist by many other groups. However, when this combines with the other issues (that I hope to lay out) it gives people an automatic negative association of chabad.
    The Moshiach thing is obviously another issue. Most non-chabad will believe that thinking the Rebbe ztz’l is Moshiach is at best stupid, and at worst kfira. Leading many people to suspect the average member of chabad of being a kofer(obviously, that is wrong.)
    Another problem is the rabid members. The tzfatim, the lunatics who eat on fasts. While these are a minority of a minority, they get a lot of airtime and attention. And yes, almost every groups has it’s madmen, but the chabad madmen are twisting legitimate chabad philosophy into actual kfira(I once was told by an earnest flag-pin wearing tzfasnik, that as soon as we show the Rebbe we want it he will send Moshiach.)
    And the final, and hardest to pin down point. At many of the tfillin donning stations, there are signs saying things like “the Rebbe said to put on tfillin”. Leading many of us to wonder -didn’t God say to put on tfillin? Isn’t that why we do it?
    Now, everyone is mechanics in such a way, we tell children if they make a brocha their parents will be proud, when we should Ben focusing on God’s pride. But with Chabad, there isn’t already a vocal group that focuses more on the Rebbe than on God. This adds to the suspicion that all chabad thinks about is the Rebbe.

    It isn’t a combination of these points(I believe) that leads people to automatically distrust Chabad with regards to religious matter. Add to that our different drochim, Andy people come across as hating you.

    I hope this has at least helped to clear up for you the background from which many of the people attacking your theology are coming from.

    in reply to: Where is Tevel? #1448528
    whattosay
    Participant

    The Zohar this weeks parsha makes a drasha that all lands other than eretz yisroel are called Tevel. Perhaps that’s pshat in the midrash. Ashmedai brought a man from the other side of the world (hence, sun shining etc) and couldn’t put him back because of מעלין בקודש ואין מורידים

    in reply to: Where is Tevel? #1448529
    whattosay
    Participant

    http://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=42422&st=&pgnum=42
    See the last three lines or so

    This also makes sense with the midrash, which does not say mefurash that they live in the centre of the earth

    in reply to: Is recreational cannabis muttar? #1447705
    whattosay
    Participant

    DY—Why is weed worse than alcohol or tobacco? Too much alcohol can kill, destroy the liver,kidneys, brain.
    Too much weed cannot kill you. It is impossible to overdose on marijuana. Physical addiction does not occur with pure marijuana(but, like I said earlier, a ridiculous amount of street weed is laced with fat heavier drugs)
    I believe weed is most definitely Assur, but it is no worse than drinking to excess.

    in reply to: Is recreational cannabis muttar? #1447437
    whattosay
    Participant

    Another few points that are often ignored with regards to weed: The health benefits of it are many, however no doctors recommend smoking it. Smoking anything can cause severe lung damage as well as cancer. Medicinal marijuana is usually consumed in the form of edibles, oils and pills.
    Additionally, medicinal marijuana is generally strains that have higher concentrations of the healthy chemicals, and lower concentrations of the high-causing chemicals. There are plenty of people on medicinal marijuana who function 100% normal, and whose quality of life has improved tremendously due to taking it. I’m contrast, street or recreational marijuana, is usually(not always, there are strains that don’t obey this “rule”), grown for higher concentrations of the high causing chemicals. As a further matter of fact, many times street weed is cut with other, far far heavier drugs. In some countries, up to 50% of street weed contained either PCP or crystal meth.

    in reply to: Is recreational cannabis muttar? #1447436
    whattosay
    Participant

    Galus—there is more than one type of marijuana. The differences between Sativa, Indica and hybrids are enormous. Pure Sativa would help in learning, as it energizes and enhances. However, the hybrids generally focus on keeping the “energy” of Sativa and mixing it with the “head high” of Indica. Certain hybrids can even cause hallucinations!!!(Even though weed generally does not). Besides for that, the general culture around Marijuana use is not at all conducive for learning.(i was part of that culture for three years ignored my teens את חטאתי אני מזכיר היום).
    Gadolhadora—Many poskim would in fact say that tobacco is Assur. I don’t know of anyone who allows casual “heavy” (enough to get one drunk) drinking. Even Chabad, which is known to drink much—it is meant to be 4 shots of vodka at a tish—correct me if I’m wrong chabadshlucha and seichel.

    whattosay
    Participant

    Yossii—You are not mechuyav to die rather than embarrass someone. The Loshon of the gemara is “נוח לו לאדם”-it is appropriate for a person etc
    The Rambam on embarrassing another (דעות, ו, ח) (translation from chabad.org)
    “At first, a person who admonishes a colleague should not speak to him harshly until he becomes embarrassed as [Leviticus 19:17] states: “[You should]… not bear a sin because of him.” This is what our Sages said: Should you rebuke him to the point that his face changes [color]? The Torah states: “[You should]… not bear a sin because of him.”

    From this, [we learn that] it is forbidden for a person to embarrass a [fellow] Jew. How much more so [is it forbidden to embarrass him] in public. Even though a person who embarrasses a colleague is not [liable for] lashes on account of him, it is a great sin. Our Sages said: “A person who embarrasses a colleague in public does not have a share in the world to come.”

    whattosay
    Participant

    I have personall witnessed a soldier being shouted at. He was frum.
    A friend of mine was in the army. When he went to a shtiebl in beis yisroel (not his brightest decision) he was spat on, shouted at and forcibly removed. Before Rosh Hashona the ringleader of the teens who were involved called him crying, asking for mechila.
    A different, close friend of mine(who, strangely enough was chozer bitshuva im the army) told me how he almost threw away everything he had gained (in frumkeit)since one of the first times he went out in public with a kippa on, he was in uniform and a chassidishe child shouted at him from a balcony, calling him a nazi

    in reply to: The requirement for everyone to give Tochachah #1446651
    whattosay
    Participant

    One of my Rabbeinu told me, the best way to give tochecha in halachic matters, is by offering to learn those halachos with the person.

    in reply to: Where is Tevel? #1446644
    whattosay
    Participant

    The source is a Midrash brought in the Eisenstein Oitzer Midrashim. Tosfos in Menachos brings this story as well.
    http://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=2585&st=&pgnum=261
    The story starts halfway down the left column

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)