Lawsuit Claims Hebrew National Hot Dogs Are Not Kosher

9

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

A lawsuit filed in May alleges that Hebrew National, the famous manufacturer of hot dogs and other products throughout the United States, is not living up to its self-proclaimed standard of kosher “as defined by the most stringent Jews who follow Orthodox Jewish Law.”

Hebrew National products are certified kosher by Triangle K, and a firm called AER provides the kosher slaughtering services at facilities in the Midwest, according to a class action complaint filed last month in the Dakota County district court of Minnesota.

The lawsuit filed against ConAgra Foods, doing business as Hebrew National, a Delaware corporation, alleges that employees of AER complained to their bosses that they witnessed procedures at slaughterhouses that “rendered the meat being processed not kosher.”

AER leased space from American Foods Group, LLC, which brought cattle to its facilities — including the Dakota Premium Foods plant in South St. Paul — “to be slaughtered, inspected and certified.”

READ MORE: TWIN CITIES DAILY


9 COMMENTS

  1. Shouldn’t they be complaining to Rabbi Ralbag? Shouldn’t a Jewish news source carrying such an article ask the Triangle-K for their opinion? Your article doesn’t even say who is suing (a disgruntled employee, a rival hacksher, etc.). Also as a matter of law, a third party would have no standing to sue in the American courts since the only contract is between Triangle-K and the corporation whose food production is being supervised.

  2. I always wondered about how strong a hechsher is the triangle K?
    Most people I know have serious doubts about it.
    If I am wrong I apologize in advance.

  3. As a matter of fact you are wrong. Consumers have standing to bring suit, and are the likely plaintiff in this case. Note it is a class action, which are rarely brought for breach of contract.

  4. there is kosher and there is treif, mehedrian does not negate kosher, it means more stringent.

    The question is Hebrew National kosher by some standard or not.

  5. #3- All that the manufacturer is warranting is that Triangle-K gave a hecksher, which it did. If there is a problem with the kashruth, Triangle-K should be a plaintiff. Otherwise, it is Triangle-K that is being charged with fraud. That the article didn’t mention names of plaintiffs, suggests that perhaps the issue is being brought by someone who is using the courts to hurt a business rival. If it was someone frum behind the whole matter, they would be taking Triangle-K to Beis Din, and the article would say which Beis Din authorized a suit in the goyim’s court.

  6. If you click the link you will see this frivolous lawsuit was brought by some disgruntled employees.

    As for Triangle K on Hebrew National:

    There is NO claim whatsoever that the product is Glatt Kosher so that takes care of a major point of their suit.

    When the Ralbags took over the hashgocha they were m’saken a number of issues in order to raise standards however the products are STILL non-Glatt.

  7. #1
    The plaintiffs are: Melvin Wallace, Shirley Hardt, Lewis Simpson, William Cobb, Erica Davis-Holder, Rotem Cohen , Julian Wagner, Rose Wagner, Erin Stilwell, Maria Eugenia Saenz Valiente and Adam Burnham (note that only one plaintiff appears to be Jewish).

    What I would like to know is who/what is REALLY behind this suit and what the REAL agenda is.

  8. Standing issues aside, if that lawyer seriously believes that he will get a judge to declare that one denomination or another of Judaism is authentic and that others are not (which the decision sought would be tantamount to), he or she is off their bloody rocker.

  9. Here is Rabbi Ralbag’s statement , as reported by the UK Jewish Chronicle:
    (Editor’s note: The following is a prepared statement by Rabbi Ayeh Ralbag, rabbinical coordinator of the Brooklyn-based Triangle-K kosher certification authority, which oversees Hebrew National products, responding to a May 18 class-action lawsuit filed in Minnesota against the ConAgra Foods — the owners of Hebrew National — accusing them of consumer fraud.)

    Outrageously false and defamatory allegations have been made by anonymous disgruntled individuals against Triangle-K’s strict rabbinical supervision of Hebrew National products in a complaint filed in court against the company that owns Hebrew National. Those who make the false allegations know full well that because their identities are concealed and their false statements are made in a court pleading, Triangle-K and its principals cannot sue them for defamation. The court complaint is filed on behalf of 11 consumers, none of whom claims to keep kosher, and all allege that they buy Hebrew National products only because they are represented to be “a higher quality product.”

    If any person making such an allegation against Triangle-K has the integrity to do so in a manner that subjects him to a defamation lawsuit, Triangle-K and its principals will promptly institute proceedings against that person in a rabbinic court (“Beit Din”) and, if authorized by the rabbinic court, will file a defamation lawsuit against the person, company, or organization responsible for such slander and libel.

    The fact is that, contrary to the defamatory allegations, Triangle-K has substantially increased and improved the kashrut supervision on Hebrew National products since it began its supervision in 2004.

    1. Kashrut of the slaughtering operation. – Triangle-K instituted a process under which slaughtering is now done with a team of two or three shochtim constantly in the kill box (depending on each specific plant). Each shochet on the team slaughters not more than a prescribed quota of cattle, and the knife used for the shechitah is examined before and after every slaughter for possible nicks by the shochet or by another member of the team. The team continuously slaughters in rotation. This ensures that no shochet becomes weary and careless and that the knives are always free of nicks. In addition each shochet is required to have numerous knives ready to slaughter with. Contrary to the false anonymous allegation in the court complaint, Hebrew National products are consistently slaughtered in the prescribed manner required to be considered kosher.

    2. Examination of cattle before and after shechitah. – Only cattle that are free from physical defects and clean enough are slaughtered for kosher consumption. Triangle- K requires an examination of all cattle to insure that the clean cut necessary for kosher slaughter can be made and that the cattle can, after examination, be qualified for kosher consumption. In addition to prescribing a team of shochtim, Triangle-K instituted the requirement that there be two examiners (“bodkim”). One is a bodek pnim, who examines each animal’s lung while it is still in the animal. The other is a bodek chutz, who examines the animal’s lung after it has been removed and who inflates it. In some plants two bodkei pnim and two bodkei chutz are constantly on the line. Triangle-K represents that Hebrew National’s product is stam kosher, not glatt kosher. Its goal in providing the supervision to Hebrew National products is to make 100% stam kosher meat available to general consumers throughout the United States. Triangle-K also places numerous mashgichim at various points on the production line who make specific markings and simanim to ensure the correct labeling on the kosher-approved cattle.

    3. Examination of knives. – Because of the “team” requirement instituted by Triangle- K, the knives used in the slaughtering process are constantly inspected to ensure that they have no nicks. Knives are checked after each shechitah, and if a nick is found the animal is marked non-kosher. Each evening, all Rabbis and shochtim are also required to present their knives to the Rosh-Tsevet (Crew manager) for inspection to make sure the knives do not have any nicks. In addition, cattle are not certified as kosher if an air compressor gun was used on the animal prior to shechitah.

    4. Post-slaughter inspection. – All slaughtered cattle are carefully examined by a bodek pnim and by a bodek chutz. It is totally false and defamatory to say, as the court complaint declares anonymously, that the organs of animals used in Hebrew National products are “not consistently inspected after the slaughter.”

    5. Removal of blood. – Triangle-K drains all slaughtered cattles’ blood and washes it in accordance with the strictest standards of Jewish Law. Allegations that the soaking, salting and washing are inadequate are totally false. Allegations that the carcass is halachically cooked before it is salted are totally false.

    6. Disciplining of shochtim. – Triangle-K has required the dismissal of shochtim and bodkim who failed to comply with the high standards instituted by Triangle-K. It has never reprimanded or subjected to retaliatory measures any employee who objected to the “slaughter of dirty cows.” Nor has the Triangle-K asked any employee “to look the other way” if he saw a violation of kosher laws. Each plant’s head shochet and bodek reports to the Triangle-K on a weekly basis. The shochtim and bodkim are constantly tested and checked in surprise visits by Triangle-K for their knowledge of the halachic material and for their skills. Some shochtim and bodkim whose employment was terminated because of their failure to adhere to Triangle-K’s high standards may have initiated the false allegations on which the court complaint was based.

    We strongly re-affirm that the Triangle-K Kashrus symbol on Hebrew National products guarantees that the product is 100% strictly Kosher.

    The Triangle K Rabbinic team is always available to answer specific questions about any part of the process of the shechitha. We base our our strict kosher certification on the writings and decisions of the greatest scholars and poskim of the last few hundred years of Rabbinic Jewish law and literature.

    Read more: The Jewish Chronicle – Hebrew National lawsuit ‘outrageously false’