White Former Officer on Trial for Killing Black Motorist

This undated photo provided by Philadelphia Police Department shows former Philadelphia police Officer Eric Ruch Jr., charged with first-degree murder, Oct. 9, 2020 in the 2017 shooting of a Black man after a high-speed car chase. Ruch Jr. became "distraught� when he learned that the Black motorist he fatally shot did not have a gun in his pocket, his lawyer said as the ex-officer�s third-degree murder trial began Tuesday, Sept. 13, 2022. (Philadelphia Police Department via AP)

A white Philadelphia police officer became distraught when he learned that a Black motorist he fatally shot after a high-speed chase was unarmed, his lawyer said as the ex-officer�s third-degree murder trial began Tuesday.

Prosecutors said that former Officer Eric Ruch Jr. shot and killed Dennis Plowden Jr. less than six seconds after arriving on the scene � even as other officers held their fire. A grand jury investigation found that Plowden, 25, was dazed after crashing the car and had his left hand raised as he tried to follow commands on a city sidewalk.

However, defense lawyer David Mischak told jurors that Plowden�s right hand remained hidden near a pocket. Only later, he said, did Ruch learn what was inside.

�As soon as my client discovered it was heroin and not a gun, he was upset. He was distraught,� Mischak said.

He urged jurors to consider not just what happened in the six seconds at the scene, but the two-minute chase beforehand. Police thought the car was linked to a recent homicide. Plowden, who had borrowed the car and was not involved in that case, drove at high speed for several blocks through a city neighborhood before crashing.

�It was a tragedy,� Mischak said of Plowden�s death. �To call my client a criminal really compounds that tragedy.�

Ruch is one of three city police officers facing murder charges filed by Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner over their on-duty actions. In his case, the jury will also weigh voluntary manslaughter and a weapons charge.

The bullet from Ruch�s gun went through Plowden�s raised left hand before hitting him in the head. He died at a hospital the following day, according to testimony from his widow, Tania Bond, who briefly took the stand. She won a $1.2 million wrongful death settlement from the city.

Krasner brought dozens of lawsuits against police as a civil rights lawyer and has battled with city police since taking office in 2018.

Ruch was fired about 10 months after the Plowden shooting.

In a key pretrial ruling, Philadelphia Common Pleas Judge Barbara McDermott barred prosecutors from telling jurors about a series of complaints filed against him during his 10-year police career because he was mostly cleared of wrongdoing by internal affairs, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported.

And she limited Bond�s testimony to a few basic facts on Tuesday. However, in an interview with The Associated Press after the charges were filed in 2020, the widow wondered whether Ruch felt any remorse.

�I just want to know, has Ruch ever thought about my family?� she asked.

(AP)

One Response

Leave a Reply

Popular Posts