- This topic has 807 replies, 38 voices, and was last updated 13 hours, 10 minutes ago by .
-
Posts
-
To Sechel
I googled your question and received the following answer, “There is no explicit statement in the Gemara that Nevuah will not return until Moshiach comes however it is universally accepted that this is true.” Of course Chabad isn’t part of the universe since it’s on planet Yechida which is in a different solar system. Please provide your quote from Rambam. I’m certain that it’s another distortion. Checkmate.
To Sechel
You state “No one in chabad says moshiach already came.” There are thousands of posters throughout NYC which state that Messiah (Moshiach) is here. Unless you think that these were posted by non-Lubavichers clearly someone in Chabad thinks the Rebbe is already Moshiach.sechel, as I’ve pointed out a number of times in different threads, you have absolutely no right to say that if Mashiach comes from the dead then it is the L rebbe, as the gemoro says that if Mashiach comes from the dead, then it will be Daniel Ish Chamudos.
That is according to one pshat in Rashi. According to the other pshat, the gemoro is saying that if we want to find someone who is dead to whom a LIVE Mashiach will be similar, then it is Daniel.
There is thus NO room for someone to suggest another candidate who is dead. And, by the way, there is no other pshat given in the gemoro other than those two pshotim given by Rashi.
To Sechel
You believe in Pirkei Avos and in Manis Friedman. So Manis said that because of the long and bitter Golus Hashem no longer punishes sinners. According to Manis when did G-d stop punishing sinners and how did he determine that date? You believe in Rambam but you reject his criteria for establishing Moshiach. That’s like Trump saying that he respects the Constitution but he’s suspending it because there are parts he doesn’t like. You accept everything Rambam said except what he said about Moshiach because it proves that the Rebbe isn’t Moshiach
Qwerty so you had 2 gemaras
1) 1 in 300000 will be redeemed, I quoted THE same amud a different opinion
2) is not a gemara, you just trust Google
And for that you call us kofrim?!?!
This is checkmate (unless you don’t know how to play chess)
Anyway here is the rambam igeres taiman (for the whole thing look up yourself)
ולפי ההקש הזה והפירוש הזה תחזור הנבואה לישראל בשנת ארבעה אלפים תתקע”ו ליצירה ואין ספק שחזרת הנבואה היא הקדמת משיחMore about nevuah after the time of neviim achronim
1) גיטין פח,א תוס ד”ה ודלמה – מיהו אמר ה”ר עזרא הנביא
2) the לשון in סנהדרין דף יא, יומא דף ט, סוטא דף מח is הסתלקה רוח הקודש מישראל and never the less we see פרקי גילוים there were many who had רוח הקודש, see also שערי קדושה.
Are you saying no one since נביאים אחרונים had רוח הקודש?? Or someone who says so is rejecting a gemara and is a kofer??!!
For more on this topic see לקו”ש חלק יד page 72its in sefer smag where he speaks about the mitzvot asseh
one of gdolei harishonim
clearly there – the last nevi’im were the trei asar.
after them there will be no nevu’a.
.
Sechel,
A common misconception is that רוח הקודש is נבואה, really it is a step below it
The Gemara says that kids and שוטים have רוח הקודש so we see that never left
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.