Melacha Sh’einah Tzricha L’gufa

Home Forums Yom Tov Melacha Sh’einah Tzricha L’gufa

Viewing 16 posts - 201 through 216 (of 216 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #650900

    cherrybim
    Participant

    I can only try:

    ????? ?????? ?? ???? ???”? ?? ???? ?????

    ?????, ???? ???? ??? ??? ????? ???? ???????

    ??? ?”? ???? ??? ???? ????? ??? ???? ???? ????

    #650901

    cherrybim
    Participant

    Rav PM wonders why Rav Simcha Bunim Cohen, a talmud of Rav Moshe ZT”L, who has written seforim on Hilchos Shabbos and YT, makes no mention of Rav Moshe’s ZT”L shita?

    #650902

    Bemused
    Participant

    cherrybim,

    More?! Do you know PM from real life, and have some sort of grudge against him?! Enough with the sarcasm! Is it worth it to lose all dignity to pursue this one-sided “fight”?

    #650904

    cherrybim-

    I have the same issue on my work PC, but on my home PC the Hebrew cuts-and-pastes OK.

    #650905

    cherrybim
    Participant
    #650906

    cherrybim-

    #650907

    oomis
    Participant

    cherrybim: If the reason for Reb Moshe’s heter is “extinguishing without a wick is not kibuyi”, would it be permitted to turn off a gas burner or electric light on Shabbos as well??? If there is no melacha of kibuyi involved, why not? “

    Probably because the melacha of cooking is ONLY permissible on Yom Tov (and is therefore referred to not as melacha, but as meleches avoda, and that is the only reason the use of the stove is permitted. It’s totally and unquestionably assur to use a fire for cooking on Shabbos, so the inyan of kibui is irrelevant also. If the cooking is the issue at hand, then the kibui is secondary to that. If cooking were not one of the L”T melachos, it takeh might be a different idea.

    #650908

    cherrybim
    Participant

    I can only try: Last night I was in the Bais Medrish and was exhausted and I wrote down the quote from Rabbi Ribiat’s saifer and rewrote in the post when I got home.

    “If the flame of a gas range blows out on Shabbos, one is permitted to shut of the gas to prevent it from escaping.

    #650909

    cherrybim
    Participant

    oomis1105: You make some very good and interesting points and have a very keen understanding of the issues. Perhaps some of the more knowledgeable CRers will be able to give us a more thorough answer in terms of the other melachos and muktze issues involved on Shabbos when shutting off a gas flame.

    #650910

    cherrybim-

    Thank you for filling that in.

    So basically you’re saying that according to Rabbi Ribiat, a psik raisha delo nicha lai (which is what the sparking ignitor when shutting a burner is) is not a problem, and therefore even if one couldn’t shut the gas quickly enough to avoid activating the ignitor, it would not be a problem in itself (putting aside any issues of lowering/snuffing the flame itself on Yom Tov).

    That sounds like a logical deduction, based on his psik raisha explanation of the gas control on Shabbos.

    #650911

    PM
    Member

    oomis: Thank you very much for reading my posts and responding to the points I bring. Certainly it is true that one may not cook an a fire on Shabbos, but one could leave say a pot of chulent on the blech. According to cherrybim that there is no kibuyi w/o a wick, why couldn’t one turn off the gas fire after serving the chulent? The issue of bishul is irrelevant, it is only an issur of kibuyi. Also, according to his position, why not turn off electric lights or heaters, as they also have no wick? Of course the obvious answer is that kibuyi is 100% relevant even w/o a wick, however it may be derabannan because of melacha sheina tzricha l’gufa.

    Your point about muktza is excellent. Reb Moshe actually writes that one may not adjust the pins on a Shabbos clock because of muktza, and presumably the same may apply to the knobs of a stove. Since YT is even stricter then Shabbos regarding muktza, this would be an additional reason why it is forbidden to turn off the stove on YT when not for ochel nefesh purposes.

    #650912

    SJSinNYC
    Member

    PM, in what ways is muktza stricter on YT?

    #650913

    oomis
    Participant

    PM,both bishul and any of its related actions are assur on Shabbos, whether kibui, stirring the food on the blech, adding cold to hot food while on the blech, putting raw food that was not cooked before Shabbos ont he blech, etc. All of that is muttar however, on Yom Tov, because they are actions needed for cooking, a meleches avoda which is 100% muttar to do on YT, though not on Shabbos. Also, turning the fire on and off is only muttar on YT when it relates to the cooking. You can’t do it to heat up the room on a cold Sukkos day. Therefore, it would make no sense to say that kibui which is permitted on yt would be permitted likewise on Shabbos, since the permission for kibui on YT ONLY pertains to the cooking which is a permissible action. Since cooking is assur on Shabbos, any related action such as kibui would also have to be assur.

    That is my understanding of this, and while it is true I did not learn gemarah and mishneh berura, etc., I grew up in a frum home, and learned from my mother and both grandmothers, just as she learned from hers before her, and my dad’s sisters learned from their mother. If you think about it, all of the family kashrus is really for the most part dependent upon the eidus of the woman who run the household. We did not initially learn it from a sefer, we were taught by hands on mesorah what to do and how to properly do it, as well as what not to do.

    #650914

    cherrybim
    Participant

    Bemused: Where are you when Rav PM is being obnoxious? Do YOU have some sort of grudge against me?

    #650915

    PM
    Member

    oomis: “Therefore, it would make no sense to say that kibui which is permitted on yt would be permitted likewise on Shabbos”

    You are 100% correct, but according to cherrybim turning off a gas fire IS NOT KIBUYI since it has no wick.

    #650916

    rabbiofberlin
    Participant

    oomis writes: ‘you cannot do it to heat up the room on a cold sukkos day”. Don’t bet on it. Iif you hold that “mitoch’ allows you to do the melochos on yom tov even without oichel nefesh, as is the halocho, then heating up the room on a cold sukkos day would be allowed. It is “zorehc kzas’ for sure and actually, we are all “sick’ when it comes to cold. (hakol cholim eitzel tsinah) So your statement in this context is wrong.

Viewing 16 posts - 201 through 216 (of 216 total)
  • The topic ‘Melacha Sh’einah Tzricha L’gufa’ is closed to new replies.


Trending