- This topic has 58 replies, 17 voices, and was last updated 1 hour, 4 minutes ago by .
-
Posts
-
clear from the steiplers letter that he is referring to edah hacharedit , and
not to participants in holocaust denying conferences , nor to participants in PLO demonstrations in the 1970’s
.
.
.@ SR
“And that is how UJM and HaKatan win debates”Which debates do you think they won? Who conceded?
@ SJ
” your baseless claims against a group of apparently kosher yidden is not only dishonest, but motzi shem ra. It is possibly also masis imadiach”YB has been doing an excellent job of both (1) eloquently presenting the mainstream chareidi position on the issues under discussion and (2) laying bare your mistakes. At the same time, nowhere has he promoted Zionism. So, how exactly is he, even l’daatcha a masis u’madiach?
ujm- Yaakov: You can read for yourself what the Steipler Gaon said in high praise of the Neteurei Karta, as written in קריינא דאיגרתא, and directly quoted above in the Opening Post of this thread.
I read it, as did Yankel Berel and everyone else…
The first thing I wrote on this thread seems to have slipped under your radar, so I will repeat it here:
There is a teshuva in Teshuvos HaRashba that says that the butcher store located at a certain address in Barcelona is certainly Kosher. If you happen to be in Barcelona, you know where you can go to pick up Kosher meat with the Hechsher of no less than the Rashba himself…
Now, try and think about the connection between the letter of the Rashba and the letter of the Steipler… And why it is ridiculous to take letters of Gedolim from generations ago and cut-paste to different people in different times doing different things, even if they happen to go by the same name.
ujm – Let me ask you a question. What do the contemporary ממשיכים of the Steipler, i.e. Reb Chaim zt”l and his family, and the living Takmidim of the Steipler and Reb Chaim, have to say about the contemporary Neturei Karta? You know the answer, you are just playing games with cutting and pasting old letters out of context. There are many people alive who knew the Steipler and know exactly what he held. Go ask them…
Yaakov Yosef A said this to UJM:
“What do the contemporary ממשיכים of the Steipler,
i.e. Reb Chaim zt”l and his family, and the living Talmidim
of the Steipler and Reb Chaim, have to say about the
contemporary Neturei Karta?You know the answer, you are just playing games
with cutting and pasting old letters out of context.There are many people alive who knew the Steipler
and know exactly what he held. Go ask them…”__________________________________________
MY RESPONSE:This illustrates why UJM has been repeatedly accused
of being a BIG TROLL, right here in the YWN Coffee Room.@yakov yosef
bet you that ujm will not answer ….
.
.ujm – I could ask you for the date of the letter you repeatedly quote, which for some reason is missing… But it isn’t necessary to even go there. Just go ask the living talmidim of the Steipler what he held about demonstrating with the PLO… For that matter, go ask the living talmidim of the Divrei Yoel what HE held about demonstrating with Palestinians… What is the point of your games?
I’m still waiting to hear from SJ why, according to him, YB is a massis u’medeich.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.