Who is really a Gibbor? Who is really a Kadosh?

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Who is really a Gibbor? Who is really a Kadosh?

Viewing 16 posts - 101 through 116 (of 116 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #2516052
    rescue
    Participant

    They were not fallowing common sense they were fallowing extreme ideology, propaganda brainwash and getting cought up in the crowd. Stop making up stories

    #2516288
    yankel berel
    Participant

    @rescue

    the fact is that millions of people when asked , would sincerely answer that they are following ‘common sense’ …

    agree that they were brainwashed

    so were the millions following stalin and mao

    but so were the entire population of feudal europe …

    so how do you know to judge what really is ‘common sense’ ?

    maybe you are also influenced by society around you ??

    .
    .

    #2516608
    rescue
    Participant

    You never asked them so you don’t know and clearly your using extreme examples and missing the point of what common sense is. That’s ok

    #2516632
    rescue
    Participant

    Common sense has a specific definition..so it’s quite easy to figure out whos fallowing common sense and who isn’t. The point is you clearly don’t even know what common sense is. That’s ok

    #2517327
    yankel berel
    Participant

    @rescue

    the only reason you write your comments , is that you simply cannot imagine life in a different society to yours …

    this is the plain reality

    millions considered nazi outlook as ‘common sense’

    that is a fact
    .
    .

    #2517449
    rescue
    Participant

    That’s not a fact lol your making an assumption because your trying to use an extreme example to prove a point that proves you don’t know or use common sense yourself. Honestly. Do you know what common sense is and if you ask the worlds consensus, outside the nazi ideology they would all agree they were fascist and they did great evil. So….what’s your point again?

    #2517501
    Yaakov Yosef A
    Participant

    Yankel Berel and Rescue, Re. ‘Common sense’

    Yankel, you are very right, although it really isn’t even necessary to go as far as the Nazis ימח שמם. Just look at how clueless the US government is when dealing with other cultures and mentalities. ‘Common sense’ means one thing in the US, but something very different in Russia, China, Saudi Arabia, or Iran [each one in their own distinct way.] Putin isn’t a raving lunatic, and neither is Khamenei. Xi was never even accused of being one. That doesn’t stop them from making decisions that baffle the Western mind, and appear to Americans to be divorced from ‘common sense’. Their actions make perfect sense to themselves and to those who share their mentality and values. Even within the US, a Progressive Liberal’s idea of “common sense” is radically different from that of a “MAGA” guy. Not so long ago [like 20 years or less] there was nothing more “self understood” using “common sense” than the fact that men are men and women are women, etc… [Something the Mishnah uses as an example of a שבועת שווא because it is assur to swear for or against something self evident.] Now, saying that in the wrong place could get you “cancelled”, or even arrested [in the UK.]

    What we like to call “common sense” actually contains a large scooping of “preconceived notions” and “cultural norms”, served in a “comfort zone cone” and sprinkled liberally with “confirmation bias”. Understanding this reality is the essential first step in any program of Mussar or self-awareness. By the way ‘Rescue’, the desire of most people to “be like the herd” and the desire of some people to “rebel against the herd”, are BOTH perfectly capable of tilting ones perception of reality and “common sense”.

    #2517862
    rescue
    Participant

    Common sense means known fact or obvious fact about something that _should_ be self understood
    Like do not murder
    Do not steal
    Treat people properly.
    Like why are you guys missing the forest for the trees. My goodness. Typical yeshiva brainwashing can’t have a normal conversation about basic abc cuz you guys lose the basics for the complex. Wakeup hello we aren’t talking about anything so deep. Stop taking this so far

    #2517863
    rescue
    Participant

    For example a Democrat and a Republican. Why do Republicans see the truth and Democrats do not because Democrats have been brainwashed and sheltered from reality their whole lives and they can’t or don’t want to admit the truth or they don’t see the truth. That doesn’t make “their” common sense, “common sense” it means they are brainwashed and cannot see “common sense” for what it is. Common sense isn’t based off whims it’s called self understood principles that should be plainly obvious and self understood by everyone. And if you don’t understand basic abc that doesn’t mean you have your own “common sense” it means you simply don’t understand basic abc ok?

    #2517926
    DaMoshe
    Participant

    rescue: so how do you know that your idea of “common sense” is the correct one? Maybe you’ve been brainwashed too?
    At the end of the day, we follow the Torah.
    Why would you think that something like don’t kill is common sense? Look at nature. It’s survival of the fittest. The strong prey on the weak. Wouldn’t common sense tell us that we should be the same? Maybe the only reason why it’s so accepted that murder is wrong is because the Torah tells us so? It goes back to Kayin and Hevel, when Hashem told Kayin that killing his brother was wrong.

    #2518016
    rescue
    Participant

    I disagree wholly in survival of the fittest, another brainwash mechanism of the elite….survival of the most moral especially in human relationships wins. Animals are not humans even tho we do mirror certain qualities in certain scenarios….but survival of the most moral is how humans servive. The Torah doesn’t tell us that things are wrong and therefore they are wrong. The Torah writes down reality as it _is_ so we don’t go astray and destroy ourselves.
    The Torah doesn’t make it wrong, reality does and the Torah is there to make sure we don’t forget it.

    #2518412
    rescue
    Participant

    Are you also one of those that think right and wrong is dependant on beliefs and culture rather then set standards that exist? Cuz sounds like your coming from that camp

    #2518649
    DaMoshe
    Participant

    rescue: the Torah is the blueprint for the world. So yes, right and wrong exist because the Torah defines them.

    #2519005
    rescue
    Participant

    No demoshe right and wrong exist and the Torah reiterates it so you don’t forget it. Right and wrong are concrete concepts that exist. That means if the Torah didn’t exist right and wrong would still exist they are living breathing concepts that are hardwired into the fabric of creation. They are concepts that exist irregardless of words written on a page, ideologies, or belief systems
    That means no matter what a person reads or believes in his head he can use real world discernment to understand what the truth is irregardless of written word

    #2519006
    rescue
    Participant

    Your basicly using sheeple mentality to say right and wrong exist. Do you know what right and wrong _is_? I don’t think so same way you can’t agree that common sense is a real life concept

    #2519007
    rescue
    Participant

    The Torah and reality live together you saying that right and wrong only exist cuz the Torah states it and the Torah states what reality _is_. The reason I’m saying this is because somebody anybody can come and misintprst reality or the Torah and say something the Torah says that the Torah doesn’t say and the way to see that is to know what reality says as well. The only way to know truth is to know it in real life as well cuz the truth and reality mirror what is written. And what is taken out of context and added will not mirror reality at all hence would be considered false. Because existance mirrors the word exactly. If it doesn’t that means it was taken out of context and therefore not true

Viewing 16 posts - 101 through 116 (of 116 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.