Why did “Inspiring Non-Jewish Music” get closed?
Could we continue it on condition no one uses specific names of Goyish’e songs?
it was prob my 2nd post.. sry.. they cud keep it open bt not allow my post thru!!
Probably because there are about a dozen older threads of the exact same discussion.
Revive one of the older threads.
Went to old threads. Couldn’t find the exact question. Does anyone have an answer? am I wrong?
David Guetta doesn’t sing Titanium; Sia does.
I think there’s a difference between types of music. Inherently, some types of music are harmful, and some types are inspiring. I think this is true for much of what goes by the name “Jewish” music as well, even songs composed by frum people.
Are any songs I mentioned in the post harmful?
Talmud, I don’t remember which ones you mentioned; I don’t think I recognized them.
Here are links to other threads on the topic.
http://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/topic/jewish-music-vs-not-so-jewish-music#post-270103
etc.
The very idea of Jews being inspired by goyish music, r”l. The mechaber had the right idea about music. Our mikdosh lies in ruins.
loyaljew-
if u x realize alredy its kinda tuff 4 us in this gen…
