YWN previously reported on the baseless lawsuit brought by Columbia University Professor Michael Rebell making unfounded claims about yeshiva education and asking a court to strike down the substantial equivalency legislation enacted last May in the State budget. Now YWN can exclusively report that PEARLS and Torah Umesorah have filed a brief with the court seeking to have the complaint dismissed.
They reminded the court that this past June, New York’s highest court, the Court of Appeals, ruled that “nothing in these provisions requires that parents ‘unenroll’ their children from a nonpublic school deemed not to provide substantially equivalent instruction. Nor do the regulations authorize school closures. The provisions merely state that the nonpublic school does not provide substantially equivalent instruction …. The parent or custodian must determine how then to ensure their compliance with the Education Law.”
Relying on the Court of Appeal decision, Albany Supreme Court subsequently “annulled” SED’s determination that the yeshivas previously deemed non-equivalent could not benefit from the 2025 Amendments and ordered that “upon electing to utilize the new assessment pathways,” the yeshivas “immediately satisfy the applicable substantial equivalence criteria.” It was those successes, and the enactment of the budget bill that protects yeshivas from the State Education Department’s improper intrusion into yeshiva education, that prompted the Columbia Professor’s lawsuit.
A copy of the brief submitted by PEARLS and Torah Umesorah is HERE. May they continue to have siyata dishmaya in protecting our mosdos hatorah from its enemies.
(YWN World Headquarters – NYC)
Join the official YWN WhatsApp status
3 Responses
“Baseless” 🙄. We all know there are some yeshivas that illegally do not teach secular studies. You know it, I know it, every politician knows it.
Rebell obviously doesnt care about the children, he just hates Jews. If he would care about the children, he would sue the Department of “Education ” for brainwashing students to mutilate themselves to “change their gender” and for failing to provide students with sufficient education because the majority of public school kids are failing.
Next time force every parent to vote. You can force parents not to have cell phones,shave mothers hair and not allow mothers to drive so why not register to vote.