Dayeinu

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Cigarettes vs E-Cigs — Let’s Debate It #1656559

    Dayeinu
    Participant

    UK Ministry of Health website:
    “So far, there is no evidence that vaping causes harm to other people around you. The available evidence indicates that any risk of harm is extremely low, especially when compared with secondhand tobacco smoke.”

    in reply to: Cigarettes vs E-Cigs — Let’s Debate It #1656557

    Dayeinu
    Participant

    Nicotine doesn’t cause cancer!

    To quote the American Cancer Society:
    “It is the smoke from combustible tobacco products — not nicotine — that injures and kills millions of smokers.”

    Of course vaping nicotine, glycerin and some flavors is far safer than smoking tar, carbon monoxide and 7,000+ chemicals from tobacco smoke.

    in reply to: New Techeiles Movie #1602246

    Dayeinu
    Participant

    Neville wrote: “You can’t just claim that every posek who doesn’t jive with you shittah didn’t properly learn the sugya.”

    >I don’t claim every posek who doesn’t hold of techeiles didn’t properly learn the sugya, but of those who did many or most support techeiles,

    Neville wrote: “You’re actually outright claiming to be smarter that Rav Eliyashiv on this topic.”

    Many lesser poskim have some technical knowledge on Techeiles which Rav Elyashiv didn’t profess to have. Rav Elyashiv’s Teshuva doesn’t conclude that techeilies today is impossible, only that the evidence presented in the question is insufficient.

    in reply to: New Techeiles Movie #1601364

    Dayeinu
    Participant

    Neville, again this is not a sugya that was addressed head-on by the Gedolei Haposkim. The crux of Rav Elyashiv’s teshuva relates to the general question of נאמנות החוקרים, not the powerful evidence raised by talmidei chachamim today.

    Importantly, Rav Elyashiv never rules out this is Techeiles. On נגנז he cites ישועות מלכו, who himself doesn’t consider his interpretation of נגנז conclusive (Chacham’s comment above and ישועות מלבו סי’ ג).

    Rav Gershon Meltzer, when discussing Techeiles in his sefer Living Halacha on Hilchos Tzitzis, cites Rav Moshe Halbershtam who says someone who didn’t go through a Sugya doesn’t have a din of חכם שהורה.

    in reply to: New Techeiles Movie #1600904

    Dayeinu
    Participant

    NO major American Kashrus organization follows Rav Elyashiv’s psak regarding worms in the fish, mainly because they contend that the metziyus was not presented to Rav Elyashiv properly.

    Techeiles requires far more detailed technical knowledge than the question of anisakis in fish.

    When taking about “most poskim”, it’s important to the refer to most poskim who went through the Sugya.

    in reply to: New Techeiles Movie #1600307

    Dayeinu
    Participant

    On Rav Elyashiv’s Teshuva…

    Rav Elyashiv’s Teshuva is NOT in relation to EVIDENCE for murex. The question posed is:
    (1) חוקרים claim this is the Chilazon and (2) there’s nothing to lose — therefore should we wear this dye?
    No evidence for or against murex is presented!

    Indeed, the response relates to the question of נאמנות החוקרים where past theories were refuted (and some other צרופים).

    It’s very well known Rav Elyashiv spent his time on Shas and Poskim and was generally not the kind of posek who researched the technical aspects the Shailos — that is something Poskim the like Rav Belsky do. Instead, Rav Elyashiv’s approach was to respond precisely to the question how it was asked.

    The cogent evidence for the murex, especially as has been developed lately, is a highly technical question never posed to Rav Elyashiv.

    Regarding Rav Chaim Kanievski, in a lengthier Teshuva in a footnote in Da’as Noteh, he states that his position is based on his Rabeim who didn’t wear this Techeiles. Presumably he is referring to those who lived after the murex was a question, ie Rav Elyashiv.

    IMHO this is a very, very technical shaila, and people should be relying on the likes of Rav Belsky.

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)


Trending