IRS Israel Turns to Rabbonim, Mohalim & Mekubalim for Payment

8

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

cash3.jpgMas Hachnasa, Israel’s Internal Revenue Service, is moving against rabbonim, mohalim, and Mekubalim, seeking revue payment, demanding they submit income tax returns.

According to a Yediot Achronot report, “tens” of well-known rabbonim and Mekubalim along with “hundreds” of rabbonim, mohalim and mesadrei kedushin (rabbis performing weddings) are instructed to submit income tax returns.

Those targeted by tax authorities were given a two-month deadline to submit a comprehensive accounting of their income and assets in Israel and abroad within two months. They are instructed to go back seven years in their report. Yediot states that the IRS move is resulting in allegations of “persecution from the chareidi community.

The report quotes a “senior IRS official” who states NIS millions are earned annually and no one is paying tax as required by law.

At present, 40 requests were sent for a comprehensive accounting of the last seven years were sent to rabbonim and Mekubalim in addition to hundreds to mohalim, misadrei kedushin and others, who might perform a pidyon ha’ben or one of many other religious ceremonies.

Tax officials suspect in some cases, sizable donations made to mekubalim are deposited in their private accounts and the funds are not given to a yeshiva or institution.

Yehuda Nisardishai, who heads the Tax Authority, plans to build a framework for all the admorim, rabbonim and mekubalim in Eretz Yisrael to create a structured tax environment and eliminate today’s realities.

While donations are in many cases tax exempt, Nisardishai is concerned that some funds may be used to pay salaries, not tax exempt, or alternatively, the funds may be used to purchase items that demand 15.5% value added tax payment.

Authorities estimated the amount of money that has evaded tax authorities may be in the NIS hundreds of millions.

In some cases, tax agents visited mekubalim, requesting a bracha, after which they left a donation to verify there is no receipt or recording of the funds. Tax officials feel that in many cases, funds are not used officially to pay salaries, but rather to “assist the needy”, especially for shabbos. Officials explain this is no different than a factory giving an employee shopping vouchers to buy items instead of a salary to avoid tax on the salary.

Nisardishai stressed that many rabbonim checked are indeed in compliance with the law, and they record donations as required, seeking to dispel accusations that his authority is persecuting chareidim. He adds other sectors were recently targeted in special operations as well, including taxis in Tel Aviv and the food industry, explaining this is the tax authority’s method of apprehending tax evaders. He rejects any attempt to label his actions are directed against the chareidi community more so than any other sector of society is targeted by tax officials.

No mention was made in the article if similar steps are being taken against clergy of many other religions which maintain institutions in Eretz Yisrael.

(Yechiel Spira – YWN Israel)


8 COMMENTS

  1. One can argue that none of these services involve a required payment, but rather an “honorarium” and are therefore non-taxable gifts. If the person receiving the “service” had no money they would not be expected to pay anything, and if they were filthy rich they would be expected to make a substantial gift.

    The real issue is the continuation of services by non-zionist Jews and the desire for the zionists to control all aspects of halachic life, As the American courts have said, the power to tax is the power to destroy, and the zionists desire to destroy the life of the Torah community. Those who colaborate with the zionists should be seen as traitors to Jewish people.

  2. yeah like they’re ever gonna get money from rabbanim

    also you see this is diametracly opposed to yosef hatzaddik’s gov’t where the clergy didn’t pay tax

  3. Hello #1
    What about all the zionistic rabbis who are mohelim, mesader kidushim and mekubalim?

    At times you are beginning to sound like a broken senile record.

  4. My mekubal accepts all major credit cards, so everything is above board, plus I get a full refund if things don’t work out. Additionally, Amex doubles his guaranty.

  5. #1: I always appreciate your astute comments Kuperma, but this time you are off base. Since when are honoraria non-taxable. Do the millions of dollars Bill Clinton earns yearly constitute taxable income? Of course it does. Even if it is a gift, the donor has to file gift tax returns if the amount is over $13,000/year. You know that as well as I do.

  6. rabbonim are required to file tax returns in the USA and income from speeches.levayos,chassunas,etc must be reported.Their seforim libraries are assets that they can depreciates just as a factory does with its equipment. Seforim stores are also not exempt from sales and income tax,although many unscrupulous people deal in cash and report no income.