Search
Close this search box.

Greenfield Wants Federal Monitors To Ensure Ballot Secrecy In November Election


Brooklyn — Councilman David Greenfield has requested that the Federal government dispatch monitors to random polling sites to oversee the November 2nd general election in New York to ensure the preservation of New Yorkers’ rights to a secret ballot.

In a letter to the U.S. Department of Justice’s Assistant Attorney General Tom Perez, Councilman Greenfield said, “I am calling on you to urgently address the serious privacy violations that took place during Tuesday’s New York primary elections. As you are aware, this was New York’s first election with new electronic voting machines and the outcome was catastrophic with respect to voter privacy.”

On primary day, Councilman Greenfield received numerous complaints from constituents and experienced first-hand how New Yorkers’ rights to a secret ballot were impeded by improperly trained poll workers. The grievances begin with the fact that poll workers failed to distribute the necessary privacy sleeves that were to accompany all ballots, which Councilman Greenfield, who had to demand a privacy sleeve, experienced when he voted on Tuesday. Without the privacy sleeve, voters were unable to hide their ballot selections while carrying the paper ballots from voting booths to the optical scanners.

Additionally, at various polling locations, including Councilman Greenfield’s, the new voting booths were incorrectly positioned toward the public, instead of a wall, leaving anyone behind the person voting able to view their ballot. Councilman Greenfield, like many voters, had to huddle over his ballot to ensure his vote remained private.

Finally, in numerous circumstances, poll workers—all of whom are appointed by district leaders, who themselves are running for election —would refuse to allow voters to enter their paper ballot into the optical scanner and instead demand that they – the poll worker – enter the paper ballot, with a voter’s ballot selections in full view. Sadly, this too happened to Greenfield who had to argue with a poll inspector to allow him to enter the ballot on his own.

“These allegations would have been shocking had I not personally experienced a complete breakdown of voter privacy in Tuesday’s elections,” Greenfield explained. “The secret ballot has been a fundamental right dating back to the Roman era. If our elections are to be fair, we must ensure the secrecy of our ballots and make sure that voters do not feel intimidated at their polling sites.”

(YWN Desk – NYC)



6 Responses

  1. Actually, the secret ballot is a new invention in the US – and was only introduced in the late 19th century. There is no “federal” right to a secret ballot, and in theory the states could switch back to a non-secret system.

    Since this isn’t a civil rights issue, legally the Federal government shouldn’t be involved. Of course, spending money for Federal agents to make an extra trip is no problem – since they can always print the money. OR maybe give the part time election clerks time to learn the new system.

  2. Akuperma, Actually Greenfield got it right on this one: The concept of a secret ballot stems from ancient Greece. The method we us today, secret with no way to link it to the voter, is an Australian invention adopted in the US in the 1880’s.

    You are right that secret ballots isn’t necessary according to the constitution. You can credit the pro-union democrats for that. However, I believe that it is in the state constitution and that might bind the feds to assist.

    Finally we have a representative that does the right things. I was horrified to see that my poll wouldn’t be in secret. As described, my ballot was in the open for everyone to see, and I was shocked when the poll worker took it from me thereby seeing my vote. David knows how important privacy is. Secret ballots were made due to intimidation at the post-slavery era. If our ballots would be public knowledge, voters would do things different. E.g. We wouldn’t have the councilman that would care for it… Big brother would make sure.

  3. akuperma is wrong and the Councilman is right. Everything having to do with elections is a civil rights issue. The poll worker looked at my filled out ballot before scanning it; I was quite unhappy about that.

Leave a Reply


Popular Posts