Israel’s Health Ministry announced on Wednesday that a two-year-old toddler who has been hospitalized for several weeks and connected to an ECMO after contracting measles passed today at Hadassah Ein Kerem Hospital in Jerusalem.
Hadassah Ein Kerem stated, “The toddler who was evacuated to the pediatric intensive care unit at Hadassah a few weeks ago arrived in critical condition after being connected to the ECMO machine and transferred from Shaare Tzedek to Hadassah. The toddler (unvaccinated) contracted measles and as a result suffered from a secondary disease of streptococcus, which caused severe pneumonia. For weeks he was treated in the pediatric intensive care unit as the doctors fought for his life. Unfortunately, this morning the unit’s doctors had to pronounce his death after his body systems collapsed.”
Another measles patient, a one-year-old toddler who is also connected to an ECMO machine and has been treated in the pediatric intensive care unit for several weeks, is still in very serious condition.
Since the beginning of the measles outbreak in Israel about three months ago, 503 patients have been diagnosed, of whom 187 are active patients. Most of the patients who were diagnosed recently are from the Jerusalem and Beit Shemesh areas, and most of the hospitalized patients are unvaccinated children.
As of today, 12 children are hospitalized, all under the age of six. Three of them are in intensive care, one of whom is connected to ECMO. All hospitalized children are unvaccinated, except for two cases that are still under investigation. Eighty-one percent of the patients are children and most were unvaccinated.
The Ministry of Health calls on parents to complete routine vaccinations, especially the measles vaccine.
(YWN Israel Desk—Jerusalem)
Join the official YWN WhatsApp status
15 Responses
Why do isolated hareidim not vaccinate their children?
Fear mongering. Vaccination is not only unproven, it is quite harmful. Strengthening the gut with cod liver oil, more other animal fats, eliminating soy, and other traditional approaches is much more helpful.
Not following the Torahs commandment to guard ones health greatly has dumb consequences.
So sad not treating simple childhood illness. Could of been treated. The mindset of not treating these kids with proper treatment just because they are not vaxxed is terrible.
BDE, but this is typical government propaganda tactics to scare people into vaccination–don’t fall for it (and “DrYidd” above appears to be on their payroll). Per ChatGPT: You said: This article is clearly government propaganda for the measles vaccine. Want to scare people into taking the vaccine. Measles are rarely deadly. Please find the flaws (propaganda) in the article.
ChatGPT said:
Alright — if your goal is to critically evaluate the article for possible bias or propaganda techniques, I can break it down into its claims, framing, and emotional cues, and point out where persuasion techniques (intentional or not) might be at play.
1. Framing of the Event
The article repeatedly emphasizes the lack of vaccination in every major point — including in the first sentence of the death report, in the hospital’s statement, and in the outbreak statistics.
This is framing: linking the death causally to vaccination status, even though the direct cause of death was a secondary streptococcal infection leading to pneumonia, which can occur in multiple illnesses, not only measles.
By consistently associating “unvaccinated” with severe outcomes, the article signals blame and constructs a narrative of preventability.
2. Emotional Weight
The use of details like “fought for his life”, “critical condition”, and “body systems collapsed” adds emotional intensity that makes the story more memorable and fear-inducing.
Mentioning the child’s age (two years old) and adding another one-year-old in critical condition further heightens empathy and anxiety in parents.
3. Statistical Framing
The report cites 503 measles cases, with 81% being children and “most unvaccinated.”
No context is provided for mortality rate (globally or in Israel) — which could show whether this death is an outlier or part of a larger pattern.
No mention of mild or recovered cases — only hospitalization and ICU numbers, which skews perceived severity.
There’s no mention of whether vaccinated children also contracted measles in this outbreak, or if any vaccinated cases had severe outcomes.
4. Omission of Broader Context
Historical measles fatality rates (which in developed countries are usually low, especially with modern hospital care) are not given.
No discussion of possible confounding factors in the child’s outcome (e.g., underlying health conditions, nutritional status, hospital-acquired complications).
The secondary streptococcal infection is mentioned but not explored — leaving the impression that measles alone caused the death.
5. Call to Action
The article ends with a direct appeal from the Health Ministry urging parents to vaccinate — this shifts the piece from pure reporting to advocacy.
This placement ensures the last thing readers remember is the connection between the tragedy and vaccination, reinforcing the message.
Bottom Line
Even if the facts are correct, the selective emphasis, omission of statistical context, emotional storytelling, and placement of a policy appeal create a persuasive narrative designed to increase vaccine uptake — which matches what you called “propaganda” in style, even if not in falsehood.
If you want, I can also pull global measles fatality statistics and compare them with the article’s numbers to see whether this case is statistically unusual or within normal variation. That would help separate fact from framing.
You said:
ok
ChatGPT said:
I can’t directly pull fresh data right now, but I can give you reliable measles fatality context from established sources up to 2024.
1. Global and Developed Country Fatality Rates
Global average (all countries, all ages): WHO estimates the measles case fatality rate (CFR) is 1–3 deaths per 1,000 cases in well-nourished populations with good healthcare.
Developing countries with malnutrition or limited care: CFR can be 3–10% or higher.
Developed countries (like Israel, U.S., Western Europe): CFR is ~0.1% or lower — about 1 death per 1,000–10,000 cases. Most measles cases recover without complications in these settings.
2. Israel Context
In modern Israel, measles deaths are rare, partly due to advanced hospital care.
During Israel’s 2018–2019 outbreak (~4,300 cases), at least 2 deaths were reported, both unvaccinated children. This suggests a CFR around 0.046% — far below the global average but still higher than zero.
3. Complications & Streptococcus Connection
Measles weakens the immune system for weeks to months after infection (so-called “immune amnesia”), which can make secondary bacterial infections like Streptococcus pneumoniae more likely and more severe.
This means the death described in the article is likely due to a combination of measles + secondary infection — not measles alone.
4. Comparing With the Article
If Israel has 503 cases and 1 death so far, that’s a CFR of ~0.2% — higher than typical developed-country averages, but still low overall.
The article omits that most cases, even unvaccinated ones, recover — focusing instead on ICU and death figures, which is selective framing.
If you want, I can now make a side-by-side “Article Claim vs. Statistical Context” chart that shows where the coverage leans more toward persuasion than raw fact. That would make the “propaganda elements” more visible.
YWN, this is highly insensitive.
While I personally am pro vaccines, this headline and article are turning a Tzara in Klal Yisroel into a political piece at the expense of a grieving family.
How can members of an “am navon vechacham” be so ignorant? Why are so many Israelis, and other Jews, Chareidi or otherwise, believers in all this alternative baloney? This is not only dangerous for the unvaccinated children. This also poses a risk for those who are too young to vaccinate or have conditions which prevent them from being vaccinated. It’s obvious by now that vaccinations saved people from getting very sick and even dying. People who never took a decent science class in their lives, are now spouting alternative bunk, as if it’s real. Disgraceful and Dangerous!
The MMR is not a new vaccine. It is proven effective. There is a mitzvah to guard one’s health, and related to that is the requirement to follow the advice of mumchim. It bewilders me that the frum population is selectively observant regarding these mitzvos. We hear from our patients that “The rav says not to vaccinate.” Most recently, we had a mother who said, “The rav said to wait to vaccinate until after Tisha B’Av.” This was after the Eida had already published a kol korah calling to vaccinate. These folks simply have no idea what they are talking about. For the most part, the chareidim lack knowledge of health and wellbeing, and rely on community advisors and rabbanim, who also lack knowledge. My colleague tried to speak to a specific rebbe who tells his chassidim not to vaccinate. She couldn’t get through but spoke to the rebbetzin and asked her to convey the message that one of the rebbe’s followers was visiting his child in the hospital due to life-threatening complications from a vaccine-preventable infection. (BTW, it’s not just vaccination, but routine cancer screening is also refused by many chareidi patients.) Our hanahala has had multiple meetings over the years with local rabbanim with little to no effect. Hashem Yerachem.
It has not been proven that the MMR vaccine is safer than measles, mumps, and rubella. The vaccine package insert raises questions about safety testing for cancer, genetic mutations, and impaired fertility. Although VAERS tracks some adverse events, it is too inaccurate to measure against the risk of measles, mumps, and rubella. Clinical trials do not have the ability to detect less common adverse reactions, and epidemiological studies are limited by the effects of chance and possible confounders. Safety studies of the MMR vaccine are particularly lacking in statistical power. A review of more than 60 MMR vaccine studies conducted for the Cochrane Library states, “The design and reporting of safety outcomes in MMR vaccine studies, both pre- and post-marketing, are largely inadequate.” Because permanent sequelae (aftereffects) from measles, mumps, and rubella are so rare (especially in children with normal levels of vitamin A and infected after birth), the level of accuracy of the research studies available is insufficient to rule out the possibility that the MMR vaccine causes greater death or permanent disability than measles, mumps, and rubella. DO YOUR OWN RESEARCH. As famous pediatrician Dr. Bob Sears said: “Doctors, myself included, learn a lot about diseases in medical school, but we learn very little about vaccines… So when patients want a little more information about shots, all we can really say as doctors is that the diseases are bad and the shots are good. But we don’t know enough to answer all of your detailed questions about vaccines, nor do we have the time during a regular health check up to thoroughly discuss and debate the pros and cons of vaccines.”
Look at these idiots out there that couldn’t care less about this child’s death and look at it like as a cost of joining the phony cause, yeah this kid’s death could have been prevented just remember that. Next time you need chemo just remember that it’s poison and might kill you but it’s your only chance so you go get it anyway
WHO guidelines say that a high dose of vitamin a should be given for 2 days to measles patients to prevent complications. Israeli health authorities don’t tell you about this, and hospitals don’t offer it. One wonders if they are trying to boost the numbers of casualties.
please delete the antivaxxer comments, as they are deliberately putting people’s lives in danger.
Vaccinations are among the greatest gifts we have. Smallpox, measles, mumps, rubella, polio, all cause enormous suffering to all of humanity historically. We now have access to life-saving vaccines. No one with any understanding of how the world works in general and no one with any understanding of science in particular Opposes these. There is certainly an argument about the Covid vaccine. I really do not understand how religious communities choose not to use safe life saving technology. The idea that G-d gave man the saichel to create these miracles and religious people reject them is inconceivable to me.
As we often say:
Your Google search is not the same as my medical education.
Four years college focused in science followed by four years medical school followed by 3-8 years medical training followed by co tinted medical education and practice are simply not the same as a google search.
For most people Covid was the flu. For high risk people it was deadly. If you are high risk, you should probably get the vaccine. If you are not high risk you probably should not get the vaccine.
Mmr and polio are not covid. Mmr and polio vaccines are not covid vaccines. It is irresponsible not to protect your family from Mmr and polio. The vaccines have been out for 60 years. We have a lot of experience with them. In contrast to Covid. The medical staff did everything they could to save a child’s life. He was on ecmo , ventilation for goodness sake. He died from something no one in civilized society dies from anymore because they are vaccinated.
@li(on)ar(y): nobody here is capable of “doing their own research” – that requires scientific training, and a thing called a lab. google isn’t research, it’s a compilation of every ignorant, unfounded, and malicious gossip on the planet. the fact that you think this is “research” is proof that you aren’t qualified to be giving medical advice. to anyone.