Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
To Neville Chaim Berlin
You stated that the BT movement came out of the Yeshiva world. Would you be so kind as to elucidate? I was in a Young Israel some years back that was headed by a Chabad Rabbi. He said the following, “The Rebbe invented Kiruv. When he started all the Rosh Yeshivos attacked him saying it was Bitul Torah. But when they saw he was successful they tried to copy him.”
To Menachem Shmei
“I’ve personally never had an honest discussion with the more extreme Lubavichers since they’re all Israelis and many don’t have much of a head on their shoulders etc.”
If I understand you correctly it’s the Israeli Lubavichers who are extremists, while the American branch is normal. This said, you claim that the American Lubavichers who “see” the Rebbe in 770 also visit the Ohel? Please explain that inconsistency, and elucidate what makes Israeli Lubavichers crazy, at least in your opinion.To Seichel 83
“My opinion is I have my Rebbe and I accept him 100%.” So in other words, you have no opinion of your own. That would explain why Lubavichers can’t come to a consensus on some rather basic questions for example is the Rebbe alive or dead? Obviously, reading the Igros doesn’t provide all the answers.