“It’s Not About Judicial Reform, It’s About Your Fear Of Chareidim”

Israeli police officer argues with a demonstrator as others block a main road to protest against plans by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's new government to overhaul the judicial system, in Tel Aviv, Israel, Wednesday, March 1, 2023. (AP Photo/Oded Balilty)

An opinion article published on Ynet claimed that the protests against the government’s judicial reform plan “is not about judicial reform but about secular-liberal Israelis’ fear of Charedim.”

“It is not about the government’s proposal to reform the judicial system and not the criminal trial of Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu,” the article, written by Alon Goldstein, begins. “It is not about the occupation or the high cost of living. It is not even about the alleged social inequality and racial injustice.”

“It is about anxiety and deep-rooted fear. Large swaths of Israel’s secular-liberal society are in the throes of a historic process of mourning.

“The truth is that the Chareidi population is growing at an unprecedented rate in Israel. Its annual growth stands at 4.9% – compared to the 2.5% growth of the secular population.
The number of Chareidi Israelis doubles every 15 years, which will make that sector one-third of Israel’s population within three or four decades, provided the trajectory is not reversed.

“Israelis have been living with those figures for years. They have been known and recorded by the Central Bureau of Statistics (CBS), the Education Ministry and the IDF. But the secular public has been in denial. The results of the recent elections and the legislative blitz that ensued, have pushed those who have been denying the numbers to the next phase: outrage.

“Hundreds of thousands of Israelis are now in the midst of an existential crisis, with a right-wing and religious coalition set to implement their campaign platform. They rightly understood that Israel was changing and will continue to change in the foreseeable future.
Dire prophecies of a future mirroring Afghanistan or Tehran were thrown up in the air, causing a rush to immigrate, remove funds to overseas’ accounts and fall into total despair.
The panic was fueled by politicians who – on one side of the political divide – childishly and stupidly perpetuate the prophecies of doom, while on the other, irresponsible and incomprehensible legislation was being advanced along with threatening rhetoric and glee over the dread of opponents.

“The vast majority of opponents of the government are patriotic Zionists, who view all Chareidim as one entity, a bunch of draft dodgers, primitive people, parasites whose lives are paid for by the secular tax-paying Israelis. Those protesters believe the Chareidi sector aims to turn Israel into a religious theocracy where women would be silenced, and adulterers stoned to death. That is the source of their dread – not the judicial system overhaul.

“I know this because I have been on both sides of the divide. I remember myself as a young student shouting anti-Chareidi slogans at demonstrations. I, at the time, did not personally know any Chareidi people, but believed that I was right and feared a growing Chareidi population would overrun the country.

“Many years later, that anxious student realized the prophecies had not materialized. The Chareidi population had grown considerably, but there was no religious coercion and Israel continued to thrive. In time, I learned to see the different nuances in the Chareidi community. I sought out and befriended people there, and understood that apart from our daily routines and practices, we are all the same.

“We all hope to live in a free society, support our families and provide our children with education and a safe environment. I recently met an American entrepreneur who invests in start-up companies in Israel and around the world. ‘Do you know why I mostly believe in the start-up companies established in Bnei Brak?’ he asked. ‘Because they work harder and are more motivated. They never sleep. They come with an open mind to the world and have a fresh and naïve perspective. They see what others miss and I tell you if given the chance, they would be Israel’s greatest economic engine with more potential than anywhere else in the world and not a burden on the economy.'”

“According to CBS data, the rate of employment among Chareidi women reached historic highs of 85% in 2021, equaling figures for non-Chareidi Jewish women in high-tech and other technology fields.

“If the anti-government protesters would realize that they were not lamenting the legislation, but a growing Chareidi population, we could all begin to think clearly, have real empathy toward each other and more importantly, work together for a better future. Israel, which may be more Chareidi in its demographics, would know how to make the best use of its citizens to improve the lives of all.”

(YWN Israel Desk – Jerusalem)


  1. “The number of Chareidi Israelis doubles every 15 years, which will make that sector one-third of Israel’s population within three or four decades, provided the trajectory is not reversed.“

    Hopefully moshiach will come soon and it will be 100% of Israel’s population

  2. OF course the secular fanatics are going to panic. The whole idea of zionism was to enable Jews to live free from the yoke of Torah, to be an “Am Hofshi be-artseinu”. That is the zionist dream. Since Israel became a democracy (a hot issue in 1948, there was significant support for a regime similar to that in the Soviet Union), and the original zionists have lost control due to immigration of unwanted Jews (religious Jews of all types, not to mention Sefardim whether religious or not), the zionists are about to lose their homeland. While it is hard not to want to say “good riddance” to them, it is also hard not to feel sorry for a group whose dreams of the last 150 years are going up in smoke.

  3. Hello!
    Why Eretz Yisrael?! They behave worse than the lowest. Of course they shouldnt be a growing society. They actually do belong in this atheist country called Israel but too bad. The Real People that have not forsaken G d are Baruch Hashem going to outnumber them in millions. Face it.
    Time for all of these so called Jews to “found” a new country that hosts all their crappy Judaism with all their parades and charades. The So called freedoms. Free of Hashem they will never be. Its the sin way.
    We need MOSHIACH now!

  4. @YinonMagal tweeted Mar 6 ’23:

    Leftist and Kumi Israel activist saw a Haredi. This is what came out of their mouths (why didn’t Hi…r finish…):

  5. I know this is an older article, and no one may see this comment, yet I must say it anyway, The commenters above that denigrated the JEWISH who are secular, are also causing Moshiach not to come, Self righteousness is not what HaShem wants. He wants mamash a real Achdus. With strong comments like those above against the 4/5ths, HaShem will reveal Moshiach as promised, but in a way that will make everyone regret any negative word they ever said about a Jewish person. Any kind. Our mission is to try an show them the beauty of yiddishkeit, not hate. Hate begets hate. r”l