Study: Kibbutz Kids Far More Likely to be on Ritalin

2

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

ritalinA study conducted in Israel involving 120,000 children and teenagers seeks to determine the use of Ritalin in different populations. The study reveals that the children living on kibbutzim lead the nation in Ritalin use, more than in the Arab and chareidi sectors too.

The study appears in the Journal of Attention Disorders, citing 18.9 percent of children in kibbutzim take Ritalin or similar medication. For children living in moshavim the rate was 12.4%, in Jewish cities 9.6%, Arab cities 2.5% and in yishuvim 10.5%.

7.1% of youths 6-18-years-old in the Sharon and Shomron regions take Ritalin. About 8-12% of children and youths are diagnosed with ADD (Attention Deficit Disorder) and ADHD (Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder).

Ritalin Use by City (% of children prescribed Ritalin)

Hod HaSharon (14%)

Kiryat Ono (9%)

Bnei Brak (4%)

Elad (3.8%)

Kfar Bara (6%)

Kfar Kassem (1.8%)

Interestingly it shows the poorer areas, chareidi and Arab, have the lowest numbers while the far more affluent Hod HaSharon leads the nation.

The study was headed by Dr. Lotfi Jabr, the head of children’s health center in Taibeh.

According to Jabr, the disparity in percentages between certain groups and cities is likely linked to numerous factors including;

(1) the price of the medication and

(2) earlier access to diagnosis for people in higher socio-economic groups.

Dr. Jabr said it should be examined whether the rise in Ritalin use is a result of higher awareness or pressure to perform better in school.

(YWN – Israel Desk, Jerusalem)


2 COMMENTS

  1. Sometimes teachers are quick to suggest ritalin because they don’t want to deal with active kids.

    ——–

    Maybe making children with kedusha and tahara makes a difference here.

  2. If it is true, as many believe, that ritalin is overprescribed, there might be several explanations since this involves frum Jews and Arabs (most of whom are religious).

    One theory is that “normal” boy behavior is being medicated, and that since religious kids tend to be better behaved, they are being drugged less. Another factor is that religious people tend to have intact families headed by a mother and a father, whereas seculars have many other sorts of families.

    Another could be that Hareidim and Arabs tend to be oursiders using a health care system dominated by hiloni Jews, and are therefore highly skeptical of what they are told, unlike hilonim who trust their doctors. It is well known that the medical profession frequently regards members of minorities as fit subjects for experimentation or dubious treatments, and that minorities therefore distrust majority-group doctors.