Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Rabban Gamliel might have held you can use schnapps. Or held like Rabbeinu Ephraim.
Not a raya, because we don’t know how he understood the implied exclusion of ??? ?? ????.
Rabban Gamliel wasn’t sure that it works
Maybe Achashveirosh argued.
But you can only use ??? if you have no ???.
Not necessarily true. Regardless, it’s at best a raya that wine is better than whiskey, but not that you’re not yotzei.
My point was that he is against looking at pictures of women. And he’s referring to where there’s no problem with how they’re dressed.
As I recall, R’ Hoffman is writing about looking at a picture for shidduch pictures. ???? ???? ???? ??? ?? ??????, so in that context, there is a unique heter to look, so no ??????, probably.
No. It’s based on a couple of false assumptions. There’s a reason why R’ Moshe, R’ Ovadiah, and those R’ Ovadiah quotes don’t find any reason to be meikil; quite the contrary.
I’m not ????? to the ???? from ???”?. You can be ???? ????? with ??? also. ??? ???, if the ??? doesn’t include ??? ?? ????, than if ????? you used ??? for ????? (or ?????) it’s considered ??? ?? ????.
Do you remember where you heard that?
From a shikur last night. Nice pshat, though.
To defend the ???”?: the ????? ?????? is not in any way clearly against ????? (e.g. see ???),
so the ??”? should have been more clear.
I suspect that there are some folks who are attempting to rationalize getting drunk
I don’t need to rationalize doing a mitzvah. I was with dozens of people who drink precisely once a year, on Purim, and all of us, if not for the mitzvah, would never get drunk.
PAA, shkoyach.
How davka do we need to imitate the nes? How old was the wine? Was it white or red? Dry or sweet? Which grape variety?
Interesting p’shatim. (I still don’t see a raya from the lashon of the rishonim.)
I heard a third p’shat, that Achasveirosh used ????? ???? and it failed, b’derech nes, with Esther.
Anyhow, I know of big people who used whiskey or gave it out for the mitzvah, but I guess there is a hiddur in using wine.
The OP is one of the minority of Mordechai’s brethren Rashi mentions in his commentary to the last verse of the Megillah.
How so? That Rashi, referring to the gemara in Megillah on 16b, says it was because he didn’t learn as much.
The OP, as I pointed out, is just paraphrasing the Michtav Me’Eliyahu.
Two ????? at the end of ‘??? in :??????? ?”?. The ???? ?????? (quoting ?’ ???? ????; it can be found in ??? ? on page 76) is apparently going according to the ???? ????’s understanding of the second ???.
As I recall, meforshim also say it wasn’t actual A”Z. I will try bl”n to look it up.
He uses the word ???, but there’s little or no reason to think it’s davka.
I haven’t found or been shown one mekor which specifies wine as opposed to whiskey.
BTW, I drink wine.
Cherrybim, which shittah holds it must be wine?
Advil, Advil, lo yoda, Advil, Advil lo Yoda…
I’m sue it wasn’t actual Az. He could of found a heter.
Is tour pisk drunk? Mine isn’t.
I said you don’t haftoo!!
What time is Maariz?
When is maaariv?
I don’t drive in simxgas Torah.
Where were tgey?
Why so long for the post to send? Mosd?
Why so long for the post to send? Mosd?
Why so long for the post to send? Mosd?
Why so long for the post to send? Mosd?
Why so long for the post to send? Mosd?
Why didn’t you drink that nuch last year chicjenibg out? Wat about this year pops!?
Why didn’t you drink that nuch last year chicjenibg out? Wat about this year pops!?
Why didn’t you drink that nuch last year chicjenibg out? Wat about this year pops!?
Why didn’t you drink that nuch last year chicjenibg out? Wat about this year pops!?
Why didn’t you drink that nuch last year chicjenibg out? Wat about this year pops!?
Why didn’t you drink that nuch last year chicjenibg out? Wat about this year pops!?
Why didn’t you drink that nuch last year chicjenibg out? Wat about this year pops!?
Why didn’t you drink that nuch last year chicjenibg out? Wat about this year pops!?
Why didn’t you drink that nuch last year chicjenibg out? Wat about this year pops!?
Why didn’t you drink that nuch last year chicjenibg out? Wat about this year pops!?
Why didn’t you drink that nuch last year chicjenibg out? Wat about this year pops!?
Way time is mari v??
Lol, Sam.
Actually, the gemara (Megilla, give or take one or two mesechtas 😉 ) says it’s because he was learning less and got involved in politics (s’rara-Rashi).
What Joseph is saying is pretty much straight from Rav Dessler.
According to ??? ????, according to ??? ??????, the ???? of ?? ??? ??? is ??????.
http://www.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=41230&st=&pgnum=95&hilite=
So marbeh and mam’it are referring to sleeping?!!
Interesting Purim Torah! 😉
????? ?????? ??? ?????
This is the bottom line. For some people, this will result in being ?????, and for some, in being ????.
To you too, and refuah sheleimah! 😉
He ruled that as a general rule we cannot rely on the other minority shittos that permit a Jew to not become shikur on Purim.
As I said, my posek paskens strictly in accordance with Shulchan Aruch, Rama and Mishna Brura.
Anyhow, I pasken that b’sha’as had’chak, you may certainly follow the “minority” shittah of the ??”? and ?”?.
If your posek told you that according to the ??”? and ?”? you cannot be ???? by drinking more than usual and sleeping, get a new posek who knows how to read.
My friend says he’s sending out special Purimdik’e pastries, unlike anything I’ve ever seen, for shalach manos. Thing is, he lives in Alaska, so I’m not going to get any. I’m really curious to know what they are, but he won’t tell me (thinks I’ll get jealous or something).
So can anyone here please tell me: what are chuffintashen?
Is this what you’re referring to from R’ Yosef Chaim Zonnenfeld?
http://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=46247&st=&pgnum=260&hilite=
Why don’t you quote R’ Ovadiah in ??”? ???? ???? ??? ?’ ??’ ?”??
So tell me, what percentage of movies are 100% okay by Torah standards, and who could we trust to tell us which?