Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
“Eretz Asher Tomid Einei Hashem Elokecho Bah Meirashis Hashono Ad Achris Shono”. This Passuk has been proven reliable time and time again.
@slominer. It’s pretty clear to me that the Rebbe did see himself as a POTENTIAL Moshiach. The danger is when you when you start mixing up potential as having Halachik status.
Moshiachchat just convinced me that the rebbe is still speaking, and even when he got the stroke his “dibbur” was not in galus.
Moshiach monster you crazy nutjob. The rebbe ONCE expressed himself during a farbrengen and moment of great yearning for the previous rebbe, with the YIDDISH expression of “er zol gezunt zein”. In the Hebrew they translated it as “shlita” -(sheyichye lyomim tovim amen) a great difference in meaning. Go spew your propaganda in Africa or Uganda. Just make sure your not mushroomizing any shluchim under “Merkoz”.
They came from the underground bunker in 770.
Did he quote the gemara Sanhedrin after gimmel tammuz to prove that the rebbe could still be moshiach, and then you heard the rebbe speak about it the next shabbos?
I ate seven donut 🍩 holes for lunch.
Burntface,Was that a typo when you said that seichel hayashar is basing everything on the premise that the rebbe is moshiach? I’m very curious to know if that was a mistake.
Just something I wanted to share because it was a topic of discussion.
R. Hershel Shachter Mipnenei Harav p75.” The lubavitcher rebbe spoke about the importance of.lighting candles on shabos Eve, even for single women who live in their parents home, and the hassidim made a big controversy over this. When one of the students asked him ( R Joseph B Soloveitchik) for his opinion on the subject, he responded that he does not understand what innovation there is in this matter.THAT Was the practice in Europe, even in (R’Soloveitchiks) town, and that is how ( R Soloveitchik) practiced with his daughters when they were single, they lit their own candles, with a blessing, even when his wife also lit candles with a blessing.”
When joining a specific denomination in Judaism it is inevitable that you will almost certainly adapt a great a fair amount of their hanhogos,regardless of what people claim the lubavitcher rebbe said about keeping your own mesorah.This is true to an even greater extent if you studies in their yeshivos from a relatively young age.with regards the chabad.org website,they answer mainly to non affiliated or observant so they will certainly teach the Judaism in the chabad version. It is more than likely that lighting candles was something specific that the Lubavitcher Rebbe felt very for,regardless of his respect for other mesorahs. As we see very clearly that lighting shabbos candles is something that non observant woman feel very connected to. Keep in mind that if a young Jewish girl is taught from a very age that she has a special mitzvah and connection to shabbos, it is very likely that she will marry a Jewish husband and keep shabbos for ever.Just something to think about.
In no way am I defending moshiach chat but about the rebbe not being known as a gadol btorah like Rav Aharon kotler. You need to first learn the 39 volumes of the lubavitcher rebbes chidushei torah to make such a statement
Sechel hayashar reminds of an Israeli minister being interrogated by BBC, cnn, sky news and all other ymach shemonikin
are you transgressing by having the opinion that all girls should light? You provided a link to a chabad website where they answer according to the chabad hashkafah.
What is wrong if the lubavitcher rebbe’s opinion was that all girls should light shabbos candles? You are certainly entitled to your mesorah but in Judaism there has always differing opinions. Exactly which “
There is no good reason in the world you shouldn’t suspect the previous so called bochur is a fraud if there are people over here willing to write conspiracies about the rebbe taken straight out of Failed Messiah.com
Chapter 2 Tanya says that every Jew is an actual part of God on high and that connection is realized through the connection to a tzaadik. The greatest path to connecting to a tzaadik is by full filling his will. As for the din vcheshbon part, even of you did hear it from a lubavitcher, there is nothing wrong with saying to behave correctly because you don’t want to disappoint grandfather when you get there.
Rso. I would presume that part of “becoming” a lubavitcher is putting on tefillin the way that they do. You have a problem if someone decides to become a lubavitcher?!Shivim
ponim latorah!Rso. You won’t get a source of door hashivii that is not from the lubavitcher rebbe. A rebbe is not a rosh yeshiva to give a shiur in gemara. His main focus was showing the way in avodas hashem as he saw fit. Don’t believe he was a holy man?that’s your business, but the rebbe is a rebbe for lubavitcher chassidim. You asked for her viewpoint and you got it.
Mdd1. Your obviously a hater and an am haaretz in basic fundamentals brought in the Tanya .
Rebyid123, did you leave yet?this is no joke.
Listen Reb yid123. If you are not lying and you are in a yeshiva that believes in heresy then you are probably mechuyav to leave literally without a seconds delay and immediately find yourself a different yeshiva. There is no shortage of excellent litvishe yeshivos for all types.
Mdd1.what beliefs do linavitchers have that dangerously approach christianity.after such an accusation I’m sure you can provide clear evidence
Chabad shlucha. Was mordechai hayehudi great enough to be considered the Moshe of his generation? If he was, was he the potential moshiach? It couldn’t because he was a descendant of
Shaul hamelech not Dovid . Not everything you learn in midrash needs to be taken literally. Dovid hamelech is also considered a moshiach. We say in kedushah ofnshabos davenong ol yeday Dovid moshiach tzodkecho. Moshiach is first and foremost a halachik status but it’s also a generic term.Litvisher chossid . I think the attitude of zilzul that you may detect in some lubavitchers may just be a defense reaction( obviously not justifying it) against certain individuals in the yeshivishe world that are unfortunately lhachris against them. And I think some individual posts in this coffee thread testify to this theory.
Uncle Ben, what does shabtai tzvi have to do with anything?
Big deal. Assuming that the reason given by lubavitchers why the rebbe would hold a handkercheif is correct and assuming that big deal is asking a question seriously, I would say that there is big difference btw klois hanefesh= ecstasy of the SOUL ,that the neshama escapes the body before the proper time (like Nadav and avihu, the Torah says that their bodies remained intact and Rashi says that Moshe said that they were greater than him and aharon), and the actual time that is given for the BODY to pass away.
Was “not”
Achdus?! Perhaps like the commies who all addressed each other as “comrades”. but when it came to a guy that was a card carrying member….oysh. in other words… put down the gun.
They believe he’s moshiach? So what? The gemara brings instances that talmidim argued whose rosh yeshiva is most worthy to be moshiach. But he’s dead? The gemara gives an option for the Messiah to arise from the dead. Crazy? Not so-called mainstream Jewish tradition? Ok… We all agree. They believe that he fits the halachik criteria of rambam and you know 100 percent it’s a perversion of pshat in rambam? So go argue out pshat in Rambam! Is this the first machlokes in Jewish history?! Oh and it seems to me that daas yochid has a gun and just shooting it with his eyes closed. But the thread in general is very stimulating.