Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
the Rasha is not FRUM, he is a RASHA.
When you commit a terrrible averiah and then commit a terrible chilul hashem you are no longer frum
The Chilul Hashem is not that this rasha exists and commmited terrible crimes, the chilul hashem is the coverup and the defense of this Rasha
Old Man make a great point people are too concerned about small things and miss the bigger picture
There is at least one other victim of this man who did not originally press charges for fear of retribution. They may now press charges against him
This man name NEEDS to be published, you NEED to explain to your kids (In proper language and age appropriate) who are bad people and not to let people touch them in bad ways.
You train your kids what to eat and what not to eat due to Kashrus, train your kids not to let adults behave inappropiratly around them and if someone does have them tell you.
If you want to defend to torah, A Rasha must be exposed for being a Rasha
WIY +1
last year people were saying the YBC were committing a Chilul Hashem for being on TV and their video.
There are plenty of frum people who for some reason never get married both men and women.
An insult to the jewish people is people defending this guilty party.
He was not found guilty because of Anti-Semitism , He was found guilty because its likely he committed a crime
I think the ban comment went over peoples head, when you ban something , then everyone wants to see it.
Look at making of a gadol, It was banned so everyone wants to read it, the only reason most havent is its hard to get. The song and video have been released on the internet, there is no way to put the cat back in the bag
Iced…
What moral person takes a 15 year old girl on a road trip???
The road trip was never denied by anyone
And whatever you do, don’t ban it.
Great Advice…
And How many other times has a rebbe given a slap or a potch when it wasnt warrented
When Rav Yaakov Kaminsky was a boy, he was walking to school and an older man asked him to do a Mitzvah for him.
Because he helped, he was lake for Chedar and when he got there , his Rebbe thought he stopped to look at a construction sight and slapped him across the face hard , without even asking why he was late
He never forgave him.
On what bases do you have that info?
The evidence was provided , ample oportunity was given to refute the evidence and a jury of 6 men and 6 women convicted based on the evidence provided.
He might have even admitted to another crime on the stand (embezzlement) Non-Profits have monetary rules that have to be followed to keep that status
He has been found GUILTY of all Charges..
It is not an averirah to not want to follow the laws of Satmar.
And what punishment does contemporary Beis Din implment for such an offense other than montary compensation.
This is not a capital case, If convicted he is going to Jail. Beis Din cannot implement Jail sentences
In Chassidic communmities there is a Beshow unmarried people never go on a date.
If a kid isnt as smart as the rest of the kids and cant learn as well as the rest. Should he get potched because he has some sort of learning disability or ADD?
Plenty of kids have Dyslexia or similar stuff. And sometimes it takes years to figure it out.
Many if not most of the teachers are not prepared for such students and cannot identify them so they potch them
Since when is Wikipedia the authoritative source on anything
And there are states where paddling is legal, but ny isnt one of them
The defends have not answered about the 15 Hour road trip upstate
This was admitted by the defendant on the Witness stand so its not a “Tablod Lie”
What possible Halacha allows a road trip with an unmarried girl above the age of 12?
I honestly know I would not take a 14 year old girl who is not my offspring anywhere.
Iced Where does it say in the Torah to use Corporal Punishment?
WIY
Good to know the rebbe got fired, in most cases not only would the rebbe not get fired, its likely the parents would also smack the kid and in most cases the abuse is over a minor offense (Like Daydreaming in class)
I’m sure you know, 147 76, that Kislev 5 has even more significance than pearl harbor
Had the Japanese not attacked Pearl Habor and the Nazis declaring war on the USA, The Nazis would not have been defeated when they were.
There was significant anti-war sentiment in the USA prior to pearl Habor and only a direct attack on the US was able to end most of that sentiment
While Chanuka occured after the Canonization, Chazal were not to fond of the Hasmoneam.
While the original Maccabees were Tzadikkim, the later ones were not. Not only did they usurp the kingship they also killed many Rabbanim
I only know the case from the Media reports. I dont have any inside information.
I belive her story more than his story, Too many holes in his story and what he has said on the stand did not convince me he was a victims of an angry teen
Since when did it become assur to say the word “Catholic”
Sl
I know you are out of town, but there is a major case in the courts in Brooklyn. So its sort of a hot topic now
There was a thread recently about opposite gender therapists. Many people were saying it was assur, And now suddenly its permitted?
Except in a yerusha case, then I guess its permitted
SL
I dont think Rebbes should touch kids in any way shape or form positive or negative.
DY
This is a moderated forum and you only see the posts that go through, although I have tried to limit what I say because I know the rules.
If this was not a moderated forum, I would certainly post more information why i feel a certain way.
Usually when a defendent is on trial they do not take the stand for fear of incriminating themselves of the crime or other crimes. The defendent in this case should have taken this advice. Read the newspapers even if you think they are biased, They have retold his time on the stand fairly accurate.
Sometime I wonder if some people dont really get the difference between Haman and Mordechai
In the real world denying conversions is a problem
Its easy to say no, and think thats the best solution, but what happens is In Israel you have the Russians whom about 1/3 arent Jewish. They will meet jewish people, fall in love and get married and you will have a problem there. Unless you keep them out.
You also have the issue of saying no and then the people go to a reform or conservative and they will convert them and then the people (and their offspring) think they are jewish and then create many non-jewish , jewish children.
In a small Shtlel, Saying no does work, but in a larger context there must be a way to solve the problem
ZK
Modern day Charedism is not the way judaism was practiced 300 years ago
Yeshivish Judaism as practiced today comes from the Vilna Gaon and the Chatam Sofer
Chassdic Judaism comes from the Baal Shem tov and his disciples
Its a huge averiah because it causes others to sin.
Eating Lobster , is your sin, its rare anyway else would sin because of it. However victims of abuse go OTD and sin for the rest of their lives because some sicko wasnt dealt with and was even praised as a “Tzzadik”
It is a shame that so many here can quote psak after psak and dont seem to know what abuse is and what a terrible thing it is.
I know someone when he was in Chedar, The rebbe said it was important to keep your finger on the place on the Daf.
If for some reason you took your finger off the place and the rebbe saw it, He would take out his ruler and slap your hand with it.
Do you think this person developed a love of learning because of this rebbe? What do you think he thought of Gemorah, knowing everytime he moved his hand he would get slapped.
Read the stories of Rev Levi Yitzchak, Its clear he wasnt going for the elites
It is NOT Legal in NY for ANY teacher to hit a student public or private school in NY
If the people inside had gotten rid of them before the general public found out, there wouldnt be this mess.
It isnt the crime thats so bad, I dont blame the community for having such a person. I blame them for covering it up and raising money
And RN
When the court convicts
Will you still maintain innocence?
Yes, Its called Osteoperosis
Dear R”SO
Would it be such a crime if I had a small fortune
Tevye
I know the mods dont usually allow advertising for event, but Chabad usually has a huge menorah lighting ceremony at the entrance of Central Park at 5th Ave and 59th St. They use a Cherry Picker and a Blow Torch to light the Menorah and its pretty cool. They also give out Latkes and sing some Chanukah Songs
I was pass the area a few weeks ago and did not see the Menorah, I am sure they are just cleaning it up.
Perhaps a train or Bus ride to NY on Sunday. Spending the Day in NYC and seeing the Menorah Lighting which would be between 5-6pm and you could be home by about 9pm