by Rabbi Yair Hoffman for the Sfas Tamim Foundation
In late 1998,� Peter Thiel and Max Levchin founded a company called, “PayPal.” (It was originally called Confinity). Venture capital funding allowed it to combine with eBay transaction partnerships, and PayPal quickly shot up to 1 million users after just 15 months.� With Paypal, people can send money to others electronically – through their email addresses.� There are, however, two ways of sending money on PayPal: Friends&Family (F&F) and Goods&Services (G&S).
F&F is intended for paying a friend back for dinner, for example, or giving a relative money. There�s typically no fee involved, but it also drops protections for any issues that may come up, such as refunds or scams.
G&S is intended for purchases, and money sent this way is subject to PayPal fees which are currently 2.99% of the transaction. With G&S, if what you bought was not as described or if it was damaged upon arrival or it never got to the buyer � refunds are much easier.
PayPal makes its own money in two ways. The first is the fees they charge to a payment’s recipients. Though most transactions are free for the average user, many merchants pay that fee on transactions which is the G&S method. PayPal also collects interest on money left in PayPal accounts. All the money held in PayPal accounts is placed into one or more interest-earning bank accounts. Account holders do not receive any of the interest gained on the money while it sits in a PayPal account.
Is it permitted for a business to take payment for goods and services through F&F, even though it is not what they intend?� Can F&F or the term �friend� be defined as any person that you trust?
The question was posed to Rav Yisroel Dovid Harfenes, one of the leading Poskim in the United States.� [Each person, however, should make his or own inquiries to both Paypal and also to one’s own Rav or Posaik].� Rav Harfenes responded that one must ask PayPal if they truly do not care if a business uses F&F instead of G&S.� If they do care then it will be a problem.� When the question was posed to PayPal, however, they did not respond.
When Rav Harfenes was told this, he responded that it would seem from their lack of a response that it does not matter to them, and therefore, there would be no prohibition in utilizing the F&F method.
***Why not subscribe to the weekly Parsha sheet on Emes published by the Sfas Tamim Foundation?� Each week there are four columns all having to do with Everyday Emes.� Send an email to subscribe to the author at [email protected]
Join the official YWN WhatsApp status
4 Responses
PayPal did not respong because their customer service department is non-existant. I have been urgently trying to reach them for over a year and never managed to speak to a person once. Their rating on Better Business Bureau is one out five stars – the lowest possible score. I would assume from that whoch the choice is left up to your discretion that they do not, in fact, actually care.
Rav Harfenes is leading Posek with high credentials – but is not a Fan
for the zionist state –
steinj:
In other words, his credentials are fully intact because he does not condone the idolatry and heresy that is Zionism and its “State”.
I work for Max Levchin and asked him. He said he cares. F&F should not be used for businesses.