Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
@yankel berel what normative halachik practices, according to that we shouldn’t follow Mishna Brura ect.
The Rebbe Shlita deliberately didn’t have haskamos like many other great Rebbes, like the Baal HaTanya, Reb Tzaddok HaKohen, Reb Nachman of Breslov ect.
The same way that smartphones aren’t discussed by the mechaber ect. the state isn’t either, it wasn’t a problem then as zionism was only established in the late 1800’s
It isn’t baseless if you want to know the Rebbe’s arguments learn the sefer
It may be a very weighty subject, that’s why there are seforim on it
What intimidation tactics, don’t throw accusations at talmidei chachomim without proof
It is a halachik sefer because that is what it was written as
The Brisker Rov, The Chofetz Chaim ect. agreed with this psak
It’s ok to have a halachik agreement between torah giants, that doesn’t meen a psak is wrong
If the Rebbe wrote it as a halachah sefer you can’t just decide it’s not
Don’t insult a shita you have no idea about@ZSK it was written as halachah l’maaser, and according to you every rov should have his own psak that his community follow
@yankel berel Over 1/4 of religious jews hold of v’yoel moshe as halochoh l’maaser, which is what it was written as by the Heiliger rebbe, as well as his later sefer Al HaGeulah VeAl HaTemurah which expands on this Halachik problem. As well as this when the state was set up almost all religious people were anti it, including the Brisker Rov, The Chofetz Chaim, The Satmar Rebbe ect.
@SQUARE_ROOT before Israel was made there were shuls, yeshivos ect.
@SQUARE_ROOT your comment about Reb Shraga Feivel proves my point, he says zionists are tinokos shenish’bu showing how he felt that the shita of zionists was wrong but that the community was like reform who don’t know better
(But chalilah to curse or hate them.
They are tinokos shenish’bu
(people who never received a Jewish education and so were led astray).”SOURCE: Reb Shraga Feivel: the life and times of Rabbi Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz,
the architect of Torah in America
(chapter 16, page 228) by Yonoson Rosenblum for Artscroll / Mesorah,
year 2001 CE, based on Aharon Sorasky’s Shelucha DeRachmana,
ISBNs: 157819797X, 9781578197972, 1578197961, 9781578197965)@SQUARE_ROOT Your words are chaval, a disgrace to the Torah and to derech eretz. How dare you publicly defame one of the greatest gedolei Yisrael of our generation, the heiliger Satmar Rebbe zt”l, who devoted his life to preserving Torah and Yiddishkeit in the most difficult of circumstances? Your attack on him is not only an attack on Satmar, but an attack on Torah leadership itself. He is well known to have been one of the biggest Ohavei Yisroel of his generation and loved every jew regardless on their personal beliefs.
It is disgusting to call any talmid chacham “over-rated” or “insignificant.” The Satmar Rav was a nasi for his generation, whose leadership and influence extended far beyond his own community, and whose principles on Torah and kedushah are still respected by thousands. If you fail to recognize this, it reveals your own spiritual devastation and a complete misunderstanding of what true Torah leadership is
Mocking the Satmar community, or any frum community, as “mentally ill” or “worse than animals” is not just motzi shem ra — it is chilul Hashem on an unforgivable scale. The Satmar community, like every other community of Torah observant Jews, is built on kedushah, avodas Hashem, and yiras shamayim. To slander them in this manner is a violation of the Torah’s fundamental commandments of ve’ahavta le’reacha kamocha and lo sa’aseh rachil.
And as for your vile comments about welfare — you’re implying that one’s parnassah or material standing reflects their spiritual worth. Is that what you truly believe? Then, according to you, the greatest talmidei chachamim who dedicated their lives to Torah and avodah should be looked down upon. How utterly misguided and dangerous that perspective is. As well as this many sattmar chassidim are involved in businesses, reflected by their trade show this month, Satmark, which is one of the biggest jesih trade shows in the world.
As well as this over a 1/4 of frum jews are anti zioist and follow the heiliger rebbe zt”l shita
I urge you to think this over and ask mechilah to the rabbonim you have publicly defamed
How did this thread ever die?
Mazel tov, hope you are enjoying the safrus
toonaphish if you dont want the coffee room just don’t go on it same with comments