Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
JosephParticipant
ZG, I’ve been on any avenue in the neighborhood more often than you ever dreamed of those streets. Your so-called “connections” aren’t 1/100th as good as my eyes.
JosephParticipantZG, you know nothing of which you speak. You invent “facts” as you go along. What I stated earlier is a very accurate estimation at men in the 90%s driving.
That’s aside from places like MS, KJ and NS where men are virtually 100%.
JosephParticipantGaon, Rav Vozner among other poskim have written teshuvos that women are prohibited from driving. You can read them to see the halachic objections. And there certainly are kehilos and places (some mentioned above) that follow these psakim.
Regarding sheitels, there are places today that follow the Psak that wearing a sheitel-only is assur.
February 15, 2018 11:43 am at 11:43 am in reply to: when to tell parents that you are expecting #1469905JosephParticipantWhen should husbands tell their father about the pregnancy? Before the mother-in-law is told?
February 15, 2018 10:20 am at 10:20 am in reply to: when to tell parents that you are expecting #1469789JosephParticipantI’m shocked that you’re telling this to all of us here before you told your own parents!
February 15, 2018 9:02 am at 9:02 am in reply to: Is it permissible to have a goy in a sukkah? #1469719JosephParticipantWhile Muslims are non-idolatrous, the Christians (see the Rambam) and virtually every other goyishe religion is idolatrous.
JosephParticipantDo you actually think a woman from Flatbush is halachicly permitted to drive through Kiryas Yoel or New Square for an errand despite 1) publicly trampling the minhag hamakom as well as 2) the tznius issue of sticking out as a rare eyesore as the only woman on the road driving a vehicle?
February 15, 2018 8:55 am at 8:55 am in reply to: The requirement for everyone to give Tochachah #1469695JosephParticipantFrom laskern:
The Rambam’s view Hilchos Daios (6,8) is that by Ben Adam Lamokam, if one does not listen when admonished privately , can be ashamed publicly. The son of the Shlah follows this ruling when it comes to talking in shul.
JosephParticipantakuperma, why are you using American school children to compare to Yiddishe adults? We are adult Yidden and they are minor goyim. Two very major differences.
Working stiffs don’t get three months of vacation a year, so why would adult students?
JosephParticipantRegarding the Sheitlach mentioned by 613. She is most likely quoting from a Chabad posek. In Chabad they are makpid to go with a wig and not with a tichel. They hold a wig is more efficient (and so did Rav Moshe) then covering with a tichel.
Chabad is the only place I know that has a halachic preference for wigs. An interesting question is what to do if a Chabad woman goes to a place where they pasken that wigs are halachicly prohibited (and no woman there wears only a wig in public.)
JosephParticipantWhat it does do is that if the custom (it used to be in Israel at one point) that only a man drives then it becomes somewhat of a לא תלבש issue. The same way you understand that a woman should not be driving an 18 Wheeler, although there is no specific issur..
This is correct. But there are additional halachic issues as well. There are sh”ut written about three psakim prohibiting women from driving. There are multiple issues. They were cited in the previous women driving threads here.
JosephParticipantGamanit:
In fact it has become less and less common over the past several decades as Boro Park has become far more Chasidic than it used to be. BP used to be a real mix of Litvish, Chasidish, Yeshivish, and even MO but now Boro Park is 90+% Chasidic. And Boro Park women who drive are a small minority.
In any event, no one disputes that the frum in Williamsburg, KJ, NS, Meah Shearim and all the Chareidi areas of Eretz Yisroel have a virtually absolute Minhag Hamakom that women are not permitted to drive. So while you can nitpick about Boro Park, no one will deny there are Yiddishe Kehilos and neighborhoods where this issue does apply. So this is a relevant point and discussion regardless.
JosephParticipantPhil, even on 13th Avenue, which has a higher visitor rate than other streets, is over 90% men drivers. Goyim and non-frum people don’t count towards considering a Minhag Hamakom in any event. And just because some people who are frum do something, doesn’t make it right.
JosephParticipantPhil, 95% of the drivers in Boro Park are men. And of the 5% women, a good portion are coming from outside the neighborhood or are not frum, goyim, etc. Only a very small minority of Boro Park women drive. In Williamsburg it is virtually non-existent among the frum. Same in Kiryas Yoel, New Square, Meah Shearim and other Chareidi places in Eretz Yisroel.
JosephParticipantWhat’s the difference vice versa. The point is when in PUBLIC one cannot trample the minhag hamakom of where they are.
The shawl example is meaningless for the reason I explained earlier. Wearing it violates no minhag.
JosephParticipantA yid who is visiting eretz yisroel for yom tov still keeps two days of yom tov due to the minhag hamakom of where he lives.
In private. In public someone from Eretz Yisroel visiting chutz la’aretz cannot violate the second day of Yom Tov.
A woman from Meah Shearim visiting Brooklyn continues to wear her shawl even though it is not the minhag there.
There’s no minhag against wearing a shawl in Brooklyn.
JosephParticipantmethinks twisted simply doesn’t like or agree with the halachos of minhag hamakom and would rather do away with it all.
JosephParticipantYou probably misunderstood him. Or he wasn’t talking about when in public in another kehila.
JosephParticipantShopping613: The Halacha clearly is that if you visit another community, while in public there you must follow their minhag hamakom.
(There’s no “minhag up wear sheitels” davka, rather than a tichel. Additionally, many rabbonim hold it is halachicly forbidden to even wear a sheitel.)
JosephParticipantThe societal norm of men not using mirrors is still the case in many or most frum communities.
JosephParticipantPeople who are bentching and don’t have their hat available will often place their sleeved arm over their head while they’re bentching.
JosephParticipant“If someone didn’t have a hat for davening, would the Mishna Berura hold that he should put on another yarmulke? Or cover his head with his shirt sleeve?”
Yes.
JosephParticipantAttention Defecit Disorder and the “long” time to bentch.
JosephParticipantCurious1000: The reporter is Yechiel Spira. It used to have his byline but for a while now there’s been no byline on his stories here.
JosephParticipantWhen visiting another place generally you should follow the minhag hamakom when in public in that place.
As such, for example, should frum women visiting Williamsburg, Boro Park, Meah Shearim and really any Yeshivish neighborhoods in Yerushalayim, refrain from driving in there as per the minhag hamakom?
JosephParticipantWhy does “the velt” that generally follows Reb Moshe’s psakim disregard Reb Moshe when it comes to air conditioners on a Shabbos clock?
JosephParticipantThe main Israel reporter on this site is daati leumi.
February 13, 2018 3:12 pm at 3:12 pm in reply to: Unhealthy lifestyle in the Frum community. #1467959JosephParticipantWho said it is unhealthy?
JosephParticipantMishna Berura 91:12, Aruch Hashulchan, OC 91:6.
JosephParticipantRav Avigdor Miller on Daas Torah
Q: In the story where Yoshiyahu Hamelech did not allow Paroh Nechoh to pass through Eretz Yisroel and as a result, it led to his death, what wrong did Yoshiyahu commit by not consulting Yirmiyahu, if he used his own judgement to make his decision?
A: To come to a decision in Torah or a decision in public policy, you must use all the facilities at your disposal. Suppose a person is lost. He’s sitting in his car. He’s lost. So, the common sense procedure is, the first gas station or the first policeman he meets, he asks directions. To ignore such a simple expedient means that this man is reckless – he may wander lost the whole day!
Now, in Torah matters it’s common sense that the great Torah authorities are the ones most competent to guide the people. But here we have to add, not only in Torah matters, but in all matters of public policy, the gedolei yisroel are the ones most fitted for this function.
People don’t understand that. The gedolei yisroel are the ones who should make public policy! People think, let’s say, that Rav Kamenetzky in Monsey or Rav Moshe Feinstein on the East Side, they are good for asking them a question in halacha, especially when you want a kulah, a leniency. You call them up and he says yes, so now you can say “Rav Moshe Feinstein said it’s muttar.” That’s all you need. But to ask him about a matter of public policy? Not necessary, you think, because my head is as good as his head.
But that’s a fallacy! Because these people have have tens of thousands of precedents that they are studying. The Torah is full of precedents, the Gemara is full of precedents. Each precedent teaches a lesson. Now, even if they don’t think of the source; let’s say you ask Rav Yaakov Kamenetzky, “Should the State of Israel do this or that?” so even though he doesn’t think of the blatt gemara, or the chapter that it is, but he has patterns in his mind. The Gadol has patterns in his mind, established according to the precedents he studies. So, automatically, when he advises, he’s following the patterns in his mind, Torah patterns. And the Torah is the ultimate source of wisdom.
Of course, if you want to ask how you can repair your leaking radiator, don’t go to him. But if you have questions relating to matters of public policy, of behaviors of communities, or of how to deal with people, there are so many precedents in the Torah, that a Gadol automatically knows what to do. But if you ignore the opportunities, it means you are reckless, because it means that you disregard the Torah as the real source of advice. By disregarding the Torah as the true source of advice and relying merely on your own inferior abilities, that’s considered a refusal to listen. Because listening means to listen to the ones who are most competent.
Tape # 24 (May 1974)
JosephParticipantThe Chofetz Chaim psakens that you need two head coverings when davening and bentching.
JosephParticipantHundreds of thousands of Jews were murdered during Tach V’Tat, the Tosfos Yom Tov says, as a result of the widespread talking in shul.
JosephParticipantHow do you homeschool the Limudei Kodesh/Gemorah?
JosephParticipantUS law at the time automatically conferred citizenship upon any woman who married an American. The children were automatically citizens by birth, even if born overseas.
JosephParticipantReporting requirements don’t make something illegal.
JosephParticipant“One should also note that large payments in cash can be illegal in some places”
Not in the United States.
JosephParticipantHas anyone yet explained why the vast majority of Gedolim and rabbonim basically stick to white shirts? Isn’t it silly of all of those leaders to avoid non-white shirts?
February 12, 2018 6:16 am at 6:16 am in reply to: Separate thread for ad hominems and fighting #1467102JosephParticipantIt would be an optional feature any user could choose to utilize or not.
February 11, 2018 6:15 pm at 6:15 pm in reply to: Separate thread for ad hominems and fighting #1466951JosephParticipantA technical feature in the CR where any user can create a list of users he doesn’t want to see the comments of.
February 11, 2018 2:51 pm at 2:51 pm in reply to: Separate thread for ad hominems and fighting #1466904JosephParticipantThe CR needs an “ignore” list option.
February 11, 2018 2:51 pm at 2:51 pm in reply to: Where is the conversation regarding the current immigration situation in israel? #1466905JosephParticipantWhat a waste of money. They should send them away without paying them off.
JosephParticipantBarter. That’s what I always do.
JosephParticipantAnyone who intermarries or shmads to another religion cuts himself off from the Jewish people and his family r”l sits shiva for him.
JosephParticipant“Joseph can you explain exactly what a bal nefesh is?”
Someone who cares about his neshoma.
JosephParticipantChaimss,
It was nice reading the Mishpacha December article about you and a handful of other frum service members. Even though I still have the halachic objections I raised with you ten years ago, the profile fit exactly as I always imagined you.
JosephParticipantThe teshuva that says bshas hadchak is in the Igros Moshe.
JosephParticipantmdd, I too was outraged that the prutzas b’davka came like that into a frum neighborhood. I commented as such on the original story as well.
JosephParticipantA Ben Torah isn’t only a Ben Torah when in Yeshiva.
Could you imagine Rav Moshe or Rav Chaim in a blue shirt?
JosephParticipant“By the way, the post “branching” Beis Medrash and Kollel guys tend to wear white shirts anyway, so what’s the big deal here?”
Why? Why don’t they regularly wear colored shirts?
JosephParticipantRav Moshe says a Baal Nefesh should not use Cholov Stam. And even a non-Baal Nefesh can only use it bshas hadchak.
-
AuthorPosts