CATSKILLS: U.S. Department of Justice Reaffirms Support for Orthodox Jews in Forestburgh Zoning Dispute


The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) has filed its third Statement of Interest in state court, once again backing Orthodox Jewish developers in their battle against discriminatory zoning practices in the Town of Forestburgh.

The latest filing, submitted by the DOJ’s Civil Rights Division under Harmeet Dhillon and the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York under Jay Clayton, asserts that Forestburgh’s actions violate federal civil rights protections. The DOJ warned that “allowing a state law to undermine a federal civil rights claim would ‘transmute a basic guarantee into an illusory promise.’”

The Town of Forestburgh has been under growing scrutiny for its refusal to allow the previously approved Lost Lake residential project to move forward—allegedly out of fear that it would attract Orthodox Jewish residents. Despite prior intervention from the DOJ and two formal warnings from New York State Attorney General Letitia James, the town has refused to reverse course.

Emails uncovered during litigation have further fueled accusations of religious discrimination. In one exchange, a prominent town official and resident referred to religious Jews as a “sect” and “locusts,” and accused them of “misogyny” and “child abuse.” Another official wrote of the “Hasidic threat,” boasting, “We have the cash to fight and make their lives miserable.”

These statements are now part of the federal civil rights lawsuit, which alleges that the town is intentionally blocking Orthodox Jewish families from settling in Forestburgh. Civil rights advocates argue the town’s actions are part of a larger pattern of zoning-based exclusion targeting religious communities.

Adding to the controversy, shortly after the lawsuit was filed, Forestburgh enacted a new zoning law that imposes severe restrictions on places of worship. The law requires a minimum of five acres to construct a house of worship—far more than is required for comparable secular buildings. Critics have described the change as a transparent attempt to block synagogues and deter Orthodox Jewish settlement.

Attorney General Letitia James, in a letter to the town, warned that the zoning law likely violates both federal and state civil rights laws. Nevertheless, the town has stood by its new regulations, deepening concerns among Orthodox Jewish residents and civil rights watchdogs.

Orthodox Jewish leaders have made numerous efforts to engage with Forestburgh officials. At a town board meeting last year, Chaskel Bennett, a senior official with Agudath Israel of America, delivered passionate remarks opposing the five-acre requirement.

“In my travels visiting countless synagogues across this country,” Bennett said, “nowhere have I seen a five-acre demand for a house of worship. This restrictive requirement appears not as a measure of genuine need or good governance, but as a barrier designed to exclude religious Jews from Forestburgh.”

He continued, “At a time of alarming and unprecedented antisemitism, many observers can only conclude that the law is being weaponized to discriminate against a community that has faced this kind of government-sanctioned exclusion before. We know discrimination when we see it.”

Other prominent advocates who have addressed the Town Board include Rabbis Avi Schnall, Yeruchim Silber, Shragi Greenbaum, Abe Rutner of the Sullivan County JCC, and others—each calling on Forestburgh to reverse its discriminatory policies.

Despite mounting legal pressure, media attention, and moral appeals from religious leaders, the town has yet to take meaningful steps toward resolution. The federal government’s latest filing makes clear that it sees the issue not merely as a local dispute, but as a serious violation of civil rights under federal law.

(YWN World Headquarters – NYC)



2 Responses

  1. I cant understand why Orthodox people fight so hard to retain Jewish presence outside of Eretz Yisroel. If everything is from Shamayim then maybe we need to stop and ask ourselves what is the message that Hashem is sending us? Maybe HE wants to build up EY and not plush, comfortable, lucrative America. What will be written in the history books 50 years from now? That Hashem’s Shchinah left the diaspora and returned to Tzion but Orthodox Jews fought this tooth and nail? Instead of heeding the call of קול דודי דופק they advocated for prolonging our sojourn in the diaspora???? That sounds very embarrassing. Noone is so much the fool as someone who doesn’t learn from our historic mistakes!! Orthodox Askanim – the time has come to put your efforts into creating foundations in EY for mass Aliyah that is going to happen מרצון or chas vesholom out of no choice. Lets fix history and do it right.
    Its your achrayus to build the foundations so that Aliyah will be much easier and stop wasting your time angering Hashem by prolonging our sojurn על אדמת ניכר. Israel isn’t perfect because you guys haven’t yet come to do your part.

Leave a Reply


Popular Posts