Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Al pi nistar, cheesecake is a segulah for Hatzlachah in various inyanim.
You’re telling me to support Starbucks which has no hechsher rather than someplace with a hechsher?
If there was an open package of meat with a Kosher label, would you buy it there?
To be fair, we are more machmir on d’rabbonons than on d’Oraisa.
http://beta.hebrewbooks.org/tursa.aspx?a=yd_x4376
Still, I think there’s a reasonable enough chashash that it might be switched for financial and/or logistic reasons that it would be a problem.
I don’t think the fear of getting caught in this situation is comparable to the seal required by the Shulchan Aruch.
if you see a open bottle Chulev Yisroel and there is NO other bottle in the fridge
No other bottles of which type?
Either way, CY is more expensive, so why aren’t they nechshad anyhow?
At one of the gas stations on the way to the Catskills, I saw sealed small containers of CY milk for sale.
No, it’s about listening to the Imahos.
‘?????? ?”? ??
I wonder how much he weighs?
Probably more than he did at Starbucks.
What did the Avos do?
Almost anyone could become a talmid chochom if he applies himself.
???? ???? ?? ??? ???????? ??? ???? ????”? ??? ???? ????”? ??? ?????? ?????? ?????? ?????? ?????? ??????
Note that he says ??????.
1. I was referring to Rambam’s statements regarding a milchemet mitzva.
You were responding to me and I was not talking about milchemes mitzvah.
The Kesef Mishna only says that a rav who teaches others may receive payment.
No he doesn’t.
????? ?? ???? ????? ??????? ???????? ????? ?? ??? ?????? ????? ????? ?????
Here’s a ???? ??? which says that once the milking was supervised, the ??? becomes a regular ??? that it was switched, but not the more strict ???? of ??? ???”?. (It’s actually ???? in ????”? ??”?).
Yeah.
Also, check back on the Starbucks thread soon.
1. Yes we do pasken that Rambam.
I’m not sure if you’re being disingenuous or ignorant, but we certainly don’t..
Here is the ??? ???? refuting the ???”?. As was mentioned, the ??”? and ?”? pasken against the ???”?, and in fact the ?”? quotes the conclusion of the ??? ???? verbatim. (I’ll be happy to provide a link for that as well if you need.)
http://beta.hebrewbooks.org/tursa.aspx?a=yd_x4521
He says to put with meat. I think to eat with meat would be the same; to eat after would not be the same. (R’ Akiva Eiger agrees; Radvaz argues.)
This is all l’chatchilah; if someone did it thinking it was 100% pareve, it would be bittul b’taos and muttar to drink.
Your first example is not inherently true, but we do follow that approach in our weak dor.
We do check the lungs on a shected animal. It depends on how common issur is.
Vegetables, for example, depend on the min, locale, and season as to whether they require checking or not.
The pure rule l’halachah is kol hamarbeh livdok harei zeh m’shubach, but practically, it’s sometimes not advised.
Mixing it in your mouth is okay?
It would probably fall under the category of ein m’vatlin issur l’chatchilah (depending on what you mean by l’chatchilah).
Can you eat a hamburger on a Thomas’ English Muffin?
I agree with Sam, if it’s a shul in which people learn b’chavrusa. Also, check out night kollelim.
Anochi is understood to be a mitzvah to have emunah, and the rest are obviously commandments, so other than semantics, is there a nafka mina?
Nobody is complaining about the Seperate hours at the Y’s in Borough park and Kings Bay.
Yet.
The Waitress replied OH ITS KOSHER
But was it, and how do you know?
PoF label
That could stand for Pigs or Ferds.
If the bottle isn’t opened in front of you, you are relying on the word of people who have no halachic ne’emanus.
If they had open packages of meat, you wouldn’t eat it, so the issue is how seriously you take cholov Yisroel.
If you take it seriously, you won’t rely on them. If you think it’s a nice chumra, but it doesn’t really bother you if it’s cholov stam, I suppose it’s better than if you knew for sure that it was CS.
So does the municipal pool in Williamsburg.
Or while eating his roast beef sandwich.
I like cheesecake. It has cheese.
They definitely have a milchig ingredient.
Here’s the ingredients list for International Delight French Vanilla Coffee Creamer:
NON-DAIRY PRODUCT INGREDIENTS: WATER, CANE SUGAR, PALM OIL, CONTAINS 2% OR LESS OF EACH OF THE FOLLOWING: SODIUM CASEINATE* (A MILK DERIVATIVE), DIPOTASSIUM PHOSPHATE, NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL FLAVORS, MONO AND DIGLYCERIDES, SODIUM STEAROYL LACTYLATE, POLYSORBATE 60, CARRAGEENAN, SALT.
*SODIUM CASEINATE IS NOT A SOURCE OF LACTOSE.
How could it be that there’s a government regulation that it must say non-dairy in big letters if most don’t? (I believe the words “non-dairy” only appear with the ingredients, which clearly show a milchig ingredient.) I suspect that it’s a bubbe maisah.
48.
Whether there are the corresponding number of posts depends on whether you’re logged in and posted on this thread.
??? ???? and ???? ????? both mention the minhag in ??”? ???”?.
http://beta.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=14166&st=&pgnum=7
The whole point of CY is not to rely on those types of svaras.
I disagree. The point of keeping CY is to not rely on one specific sevara, (and to be frummer and better than everyone else), not to reject the idea of sevaros.
they could go to the local supermarket and get it if need be.
The treif ones might be closer, and what’s stopping the worker from refilling the CY container with CS milk?
?”? ??”? ??”? ?.
I think this is relevant to our shailah.
ZD, I think you bring up a good point that a large store has more to lose than a small one, but those who don’t drink cholov Stam don’t differentiate between large dairies and small ones.
I think if you’re contemplating how likely Starbucks is to switch the milk, think about how awkward it would be for Starbucks to tell all their customers that they’re out of milk, which is more likely to happen if they’re committed to only use one relatively small, independent brand.
Ben Melech, if it’s a sealed container, that would work.
MA, akuperma, from the article ZD posted:
ZD, thank you for bringing this to our attention. I’m not shooting the messenger, just the message.
How can one rely on them only using CY if there’s no hechsher?
Which ones? The ones I’ve seen do not say non-dairy on them.
You did it again!
47
And considering how little they cared when the mislabeled something pareve that was actually milchigs…
Just read the ingredients.
You are so machmir, popa. I bet you’re the type of guy who not only checks his own lettuce with a lighbox, but you also have someone else looking over your shoulder to make sure you are doing it correctly.
Date: Wed, Dec 24, 2014 at 11:57 AM
So that information is not timely, considering their own disclaimer that things can change without notice.
Or the dashboard could have a large sign “take Shpritzy out of the car”.
Then you’re less likely to lose your shoe.
Very unlikely to happen.
This has nothing to do with alternative lifestyles.
Who says it wasn’t? If we have no record why assume anything?
Sam, partially depends on what the zilusa is. There certainly aren’t enough grounds to change the din.
You answered Charlie well.