Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
DovidBTParticipant
Five down, eight to go.
DovidBTParticipantIf you could go back to 5th grade (or similar), would you want to keep your present memory and knowledge? That would be weird. You’d either have to act like a child of that age, which would be challenging, or you’d be considered a freak and possibly dangerous.
DovidBTParticipantGematria does not work with english, only Lashon Kodesh
In addition, isn’t it only valid when based on a teaching that goes back to Sinai?
In all fairness the internet was invented in the early 1800, and in its first version involved operators communicating by tappping a binary code (dots and dashes). Many people immedciately and accurately saw the mischief that would lead to.
I recall reading in the Talmud that the Sanhedrin experimented with using signal fires on hilltops to more rapidly notify the distant communities of the occurrence of a new month. But the system was misused, so they reverted to the system of messengers and word-of-mouth transmission.
DovidBTParticipantAdults, though, I think they go off because of the internet.
The internet is a neutral resource. The internet was my primary tool for becoming observant.
DovidBTParticipantEighth grade is approximately the time when one becomes responsible for observing the mitzvos.
DovidBTParticipantWithout the Coffee Room there is no Joseph. Without Joseph there is no Coffee Room.
DovidBTParticipantThat would depend on his subtitle.
DovidBTParticipantHowever, since Mordechai ignored him and did not contend with him, Hashem reversed the fortunes and Mordechai and Klal Yisroel were saved.
I get the point that a wicked person may prevail over us because that’s what Hashem has decided.
What I’m trying to understand is what we’re supposed to do when we’re in a situation where a wicked person is attacking us. For example, a wicked person is using the legal system against you.
Do you just resign yourself to the fact that he’s going to win, and do nothing but pray and hope for the best?
August 22, 2018 11:51 pm at 11:51 pm in reply to: President Donald Trump, Oheiv Yisroel Par Excellence #1578984DovidBTParticipanthe supports a state that beats up religious jews
You’re referring to the U.S.?
DovidBTParticipantBut many pious people achieve success in this world, and many wicked people suffer misfortune.
Anyway, I don’t see how that answers my questions regarding “contending with the wicked.”
August 22, 2018 6:00 pm at 6:00 pm in reply to: Halachic question regarding bal tashchis and tza’ar baalei chayim #1578954DovidBTParticipantTo declaw cat you are eliminating its means of protection.
Declawing a cat also involves chopping off the first joint of the cat’s fingers, which is not very nice. If the choice is declawing or euthanizing, at least leave the rear feet intact, which leaves the cat some protection, and helps it escape from a predator.
DovidBTParticipantYou guys are the kings of festering.
What would be the Hebrew word or phrase for “king of festering”?
August 21, 2018 7:00 pm at 7:00 pm in reply to: Halachic question regarding bal tashchis and tza’ar baalei chayim #1578473DovidBTParticipantWhy use coins? Unless you’re planning on retrieving them, it’s poisoning the vegetation and wasting money that could be used for tzedakah.
There’s a recent post at asknoah DOT org SLASH forum, titled “Traps for harmful insects”, on this subject.
DovidBTParticipantYes, yes and yes
In that case, a possible solution is to have an objective way of ensuring that the proportion of secular to Torah studies remains constrained. For example, a comprehensive annual exam, or series of exams, both written and oral, that’s 10% secular and 90% Torah.
DovidBTParticipantBut they arenât integrating, and that’s precisely the problem.
Instead of integrating, they are killing the messenger and cutting it out entirely.What’s the reason? Is it thought that a minimum of secular education will be a slippery slope to increased secular education, inadequate Torah education, and assimilation?
DovidBTParticipantDovidBT, The yeshiva can set up a curriculum of study.
Exactly. That’s why there should be no issue with integrating a Torah and secular education.
DovidBTParticipantThe more time spent on secular studies the less time there is available for Limud Torah, which is far more important. It is impossible to give a âpublic school equivalent educationâ PLUS a full Torah/Jewish education. There arenât enough waking hours in a day for a child to have two such full curriculums.
The problem is that secular education has gone way beyond teaching the basics. It’s been perverted into a means of indoctrinating political and social viewpoints. Teaching the essentials of communication and quantitative skills, with a bit of history and geography, wouldn’t take that much time.
DovidBTParticipantA virtual parade does not have the same effect as a real parade
It could have the same effect, if it’s handled appropriately. It depends on what effect is desired. If the effect depends on media coverage, I suppose that could be an issue. But considering that the media is the sewer pipe that leads to your head, depending on media coverage is a mixed bag.
August 17, 2018 11:17 am at 11:17 am in reply to: The military parade scheduled for November #1576025DovidBTParticipantWith today’s technology, a virtual parade could be done for a few thousand dollars. There’s no need to have all the personnel and equipment physically in the same place at the same time.
DovidBTParticipantThere is a difference between Halacha and Hashkafa
The OP appears to be asking about halachah (“Is it muttar?”).
August 16, 2018 7:18 pm at 7:18 pm in reply to: Parklands school safety why our schools not protected the same?? #1575793DovidBTParticipantThe Parkland shooter was a very disturbed kid with a long history of problems and “red flags” that were ignored. The authorities had many opportunites to take preventative action but failed to do so.
If there’s a dangerous bull in your village, you don’t turn the village into a fortress. You confine the bull so that he can’t hurt anyone.
DovidBTParticipantIn summary, this thread has proven that you can go on vacation to a place where there is no minyan, provided that said place has beautiful natural scenery that brings you closer to Hashem.
Is that accurate?
DovidBTParticipantOne might ask why would the Ebeshter have created these locations if his yidden were foreclosed from seeing the wonders of his creations?
That line of argument could easily be used to rationalize transgressions. đ
August 14, 2018 5:53 pm at 5:53 pm in reply to: If a pig was genetically modified to chew its cud, would it be kosher? #1574211DovidBTParticipantIf you want a kosher pig, it might be easier to genetically modify …
What about modifying the pig to have fins and scales, and to live in the sea? That would have the advantage of not requiring shechitah.
DovidBTParticipantWhat if YWN was blocked from Facebook and Youtube?
It could happen. A lot of people consider certain Torah precepts to be “hate speech”.
DovidBTParticipantMost of these places are open for tours.
Are the tours conducted by robots or by humans?
August 9, 2018 8:59 pm at 8:59 pm in reply to: Why don’t airlines compensate for mechanical delays #1571670DovidBTParticipantAirlines used to offer compensation for this, and planes didnât crash that much more often, so that doesnât sound right.
Maybe it’s harder for them to make money now.
I know that commercial flying used to be a lot more pleasant. There was hardly any hassle about security; you could wander freely in and out of the boarding area. There were no fees for baggage unless it was excessive. Free meals and snacks were served, even in coach class.
DovidBTParticipantDoes anyone have a source for the halachic obligation (not just the importance which can be seen in brachot 6 â 8,) to pray with ten men?
Another source for the importance, not halachic, seems to be Psalms 82:1: “… G-d stands in the Divine assembly …”
August 8, 2018 7:49 pm at 7:49 pm in reply to: Why don’t airlines compensate for mechanical delays #1571117DovidBTParticipantThey said because its not their fault
The airline told you they don’t have to compensate you because the mechanical problem is not their fault?
In a sense, that’s true. If it weren’t for the passengers, they could keep the aircraft parked in hangers. It’s all the flying that causes stress to the planes and causes the parts to fail. So it’s really your fault.
August 8, 2018 11:19 am at 11:19 am in reply to: Why don’t airlines compensate for mechanical delays #1570770DovidBTParticipantThe rationale is probably it would compromise safety. The airline might operate an aircraft with a known mechanical problem, to avoid having to compensate the passengers for the delay in fixing the problem.
August 7, 2018 7:12 pm at 7:12 pm in reply to: Different Circles Of Yidden Can Experience Great Unity – Achdus #1570522DovidBTParticipantThanks for answering my question. đ
August 7, 2018 10:39 am at 10:39 am in reply to: The military parade scheduled for November #1570180DovidBTParticipant@CTLAWYER
You made it clear from that post and others, that your criterion for U.S. President is the effect on your own bank account. I suppose that’s a legimate criterion for a person to use, as long as he’s honest about it and doesn’t pretend that he’s interested in what’s best for the country as a whole..August 7, 2018 1:20 am at 1:20 am in reply to: Different Circles Of Yidden Can Experience Great Unity – Achdus #1569854DovidBTParticipantknaidlach:
So specifically how would the Rabbi respond to the invitation(s)? Would he say, “No!!! Your food does not meet my standards!”? And, “No, I cannot attend a religious service at your fake synagogue!!!”?
DovidBTParticipantRe: U.S. military pay and benefits
Even with cuts, military members still receive considerable subsidies, including free or cheap housing, free medical care, free or discounted meals, discounted prices at commissaries, educational benefits.
And they’re volunteers, not draftees. They chose to be in the military.
I’m a veteran. I speak from personal experience.
August 5, 2018 10:21 pm at 10:21 pm in reply to: The military parade scheduled for November #1569346DovidBTParticipantDovid BT feel free to open a thread about the relative vacation expenses of our 44th and 45th presidents.
It’s easier to use your thread. đ
The President needs the support of the military and veterans, so he has to throw money at them.
DovidBTParticipantOur former President took $5 million dollar vacations, and is still probably costing us millions of dollars a year by traveling with Secret Service protection.
The cost of the military parade is a drop in the bucket compared to all the money wasted by government spending.
DovidBTParticipantAn irony here is that it’s a machine that’s administering the âprove your humanityâ test.
DovidBTParticipantSince everything happens for a reason, and is caused by Hashem, wouldn’t this also apply to suicide? Maybe the person who commits suicide is being punished for a sin. Or maybe he’s being rewarded. Or maybe the person no longer “fits” in this world, and has been removed, for reasons that are beyond our understanding.
DovidBTParticipantIf youâre learning tosafos on your own, you should know how to read it.
I assume you mean read it in its original, untranslated form. I wish I could do that. Perhaps Artscroll should refocus their efforts and provide a series of self-study books that teach one how to do that.
DovidBTParticipantI saw this in a shul last week.
That Artscroll DOT com page says that the expected publication date is Aug 21, 2018. Are there copies of it available now?
August 2, 2018 10:04 am at 10:04 am in reply to: To eat or not eat food and candy made in chna #1568406DovidBTParticipantWhen the government is your automatic 50% partner, factory owners and manager look for ways to make their own fortunes.
I don’t understand. Could you explain that?
August 1, 2018 7:36 pm at 7:36 pm in reply to: Different Circles Of Yidden Can Experience Great Unity – Achdus #1568137DovidBTParticipantChabadshlucha:
This topic reminds of a question I have. If a local member of the community and a regular visitor to the Chabad House, who happens to be a non-observant Jew, invites a Chabad Rabbi and his wife to dinner at the community member’s house, what does the Rabbi do?
A related quesiion would concern inviting the Chabad Rabbi to attend a Shabbos service at a local Reform temple, at which the non-observant Jew’s son is celebrating becoming a Bar Mitzvah. How would the Chabad Rabbi respond?
DovidBTParticipantI have a red cabbage.
DovidBTParticipantPutin/Netanyahu
DovidBTParticipantHow about, so we donât stand still during the Zionist siren.
How about kneeling on one knee, maybe with a raised fist? đ
(Just in case it’s not clear, I’m not serious in suggesting active protests against the sirens.)
DovidBTParticipantAt that time I was an owner of a sewing factory in Waterbury, CT.
@CTLAWYER
How did you manage to get through law school and have the time to practice law, while operating the businesses you’ve mentioned in this post and previous ones? No offense meant, just honest curiosity.DovidBTParticipantIn their usual inclusive manner, Chabad DOT org takes an interesting appproach to this. There’s no “Yom HaShoah” on their calendar. But they make a point of including a Holocaust-themed article among their headlined articles on that occasion.
DovidBTParticipantwhich only makes your comparison that much more ridiculous.
You have your logic, I have mine. If you find mine ridiculous, then laugh at it and move on. đ
DovidBTParticipantDovidBT- Just to understand, youâre comparing celebrating Jesus with commemorating the Holocaust?
No, I’m making an analogy by using another example of abandoning halachah for the sake of “achdus with our fellow Jews “.
-
AuthorPosts