Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
aaq- just making sure you realize that when you say “the authors of these letters” you are referring to the gedolei hador
hakatan-one can always wave off daas torah by saying the gadol was lied to, have an open mind
hakatan- you cant argue with yeshivaman if what hes saying is true, he says spoke to r’ fuerst and r’ shmuel’s gabbai personally, your only argument would to claim hes making it all up. (or be machria between the gedolim, if your ego is big enough)
simcha- no but im saying spiritual survival is just as if not more important than physical survival
simcha- r’ akiva answered your question to turnus rufus with the fish mashal
yb- you’re not getting them cuz there arent any, move on with your life
square root- yes and btw did you ask your rebbi before you took such a step? (this is of course assuming you have one, which based on your other posts i highly doubt)
yankel berel- go do something with your life
probably not shtark and definitely not relatable
i guess she got the wrong prescription
aaq- my point was just if lu yitzur he came to you and told you to do xyz
741- whyd you have to do him like that
a good tziyur for what im saying is if lets say the ben ish chai told you personally to do xyz, you would have to listen unless…
and my point about listening to gedolim was that beetzem you have to listen/accept/follow to anything that comes out of the mouth of a gadol. UNLESS you have a mesora/gadol saying otherwise. square root said “Since Jews who are not Sephardic totally ignore Sephardic Rabbis, Jews who are not Satmar should totally ignore the Satmar Rebbes” the idea of totally ignoring a gadol is very twisted
and “כל הפוסל במומו פוסל” is an extremely specific klal that only applies very narrowly. this is blatantly obvious since otherwise anyone who calls reform kefira would be a kofer. in fact i have seen it being explained as the daas torah version of the psychological concept of projection which would only apply to subconcious middos
zsk and others- first of all, i dont have a side in this argument and i never called anyone a kofer (look at my post, i was asking how someone who was calling you a kofer would be one as you indicate through “כל הפוסל במומו פוסל”) my point was you cant say that about the satmar rebbe. and you did not show how you used the klal correctly
i come from a system that learns both extremely slow and fast with plenty of mesora (guess which one)
ZSK- who are you to call a gadols shitah “a really weak argument” and completely misusing klalim from the gemara doesnt help you, דברי תורה מדברי קבלה לא ילפינן means you cant learn a d’oraisa from navi but if you actually learned gemara you would know the gemara brings sources from nach all the time, and which ikar emunah does someone violate by calling you a kofer?
while i dont usually get involved in this squareroots comment abou the satmar rebbe disturbed me- the satmar rebbe was an extremly great man who was accepted by all the gedolim, yes you are obligated to listen to the satmar rebbe, you may have another gadol whom you follow but you still have to listen to the satmar rebbe, thats like saying i dont have to listen to r’ ovadia yosef since im not sefardi
rocky- can YOU define mesora? and are you feeling ok? the gedolim run these yeshivos
wheres the mesora for this derech?
maybe CS finally refilled her prescription
why wasnt my thread on ywns attack on ami allowed through?
are you guys just trying to bury the whole thing?????
yechiell- are you defending transgenderism?
is blatant kefira allowed to be posted?
cs- im sure this question has been asked many times befor but as i am new to the coffee room i havent heard an answer. how does chabad explain the famous quote of the undisputed gadol hador rav shach about chabad?
cs- you said the gaon had a mesora against chabad, so does everybody, and to pick, then why are you telling everyone they must believe in the rebbe
its not exactly gaavah, its that you think youre already a someone because you wear a white shirt and more is not necessary, again its disputed even in cc and some branches require them
and my point about modox was not an aspersion on their torah but an assumption that most people on this platform do not hold of their hashkafos, the same way quoting a chabad rabbi about the rebbe would be pointless
yechiell- its fine, you dont have to believe in daas torah, gehenom gots plenty of room
jmn- this is a terrible place to ask a question like that, there are many, many people on this platform with extremely twisted hashkafas, find a real real rebbi and get a real answer
and you didnt answer your self contradiction
daasyochid- its complicated and not even such a shtark hashkafa even within cc but the basic idea is it causes complacency among other reasons
cs- it is threatening when people try to spread their twisted views to the masses, but i guess no one is actually conviced so i really shouldnt be worried
cs- did the rambam learn chasidus and if not how will he understand moshiachs torah?
“That’s his mesora. Choose your pick”- so do all the people on this platform. why are you trying to missionize?
how does colored shirts affect the person negatively? actually the reason cc wears colored shirts is to not be affected by a white shirt
it is quite clear from his writings etc. that the rambam did not learn chasidus and chabad of course holds of the rambam
and they werent actually hitmen, they were just scamming him, so of course the targets would deny it
actually the judge took into account the hitmen during sentencing
im not joking
ujm- they do a goral hagra (sorry if that name causes trauma) with the letters of the rebbe
CS- what does chabad think about the vilna gaon?
coffee addict- thats why i added the every single other gadol part
by the way the three days are long over