Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Chaim87Participant
@Always_Ask_Questions
fair crtique. But my point remains Chabad isn’t always “welcoming” to all.
And my other point remains clear, R Shach talmdim saved the chabadska in jail more than Chabad did. So maybe ist time to let go of R Shach grievnacesChaim87ParticipantI still have not received a response from any of the chabad commentators on my point. When push came to shove and one of your own chasdim was locked up for 25 years, which publication was his strongest advocate? Who perosnally used every ounce of his koach to get the tzadik Rubashkin out of jail? The head of R Shach zl newspaper. Pinny Lipschitz. And so maybe its time to let bygones be bygones and just let r Shach be a gadol. Do you know how much tzaras misngahdim caused chasdim? Its in all of the chabad books. Guess who the head of that was. R chaim volzhin. Yet most chasdim learn nefsh hachim (A sefer written to counter chasdim) and certanlly learn torah from his grandchildren in Brisk.
I’ll leave off on another note. There is this myth that chabad will help you wherever you are. Just call chabad. I have been to out of town places where there is a local chabad, mostly on random tuesdays. I have called to ask if there is a minyan? no was the reply. can I at least daven at the chabad center so its not in my hotel room? My reply well we open at 9 and you can’t come earlier. How about kosher food? We don’t really make kosher food for one vistor. So yes its accomodating if it works within the program. So sure go to a popular place on chol hamoed and you bet its accommodating bec there are masses and its fundraiser opportunity. But its not as simiple as you al claim. To be dan lkaf zechus, these are far out places and they aren’t as eqiupped. But just pointing out
Chaim87Participant@Rokcy, It could be this isn’t new. But in 2026 I thought we became more civilized. We as a community are also stronger. We should be standing up to the bullies and demanding they lower prices.
Chaim87ParticipantIts also shameful, when the know that the biggest R shach litfaks like Pinny Lipshitz of the Yated which is a R shach newspaper, was the strongets advocate of Runashkin. He did more than chabad did to help their won. He didn’t say oy very lubvitch and I am R shach. Rubashkin was in the Yated for 8 years nonj stop. he never gave up. And now you in Chabad make a fight again? Do you know how mnay chasidisha shuirm there are in nefesh hchaim? R cahim volzuiner almost put chasdim in cherem and that sefer was written to counter chasdim. Yet many chasdisha rebas learn his sefer. It indeed is shameful
Chaim87ParticipantAn Interesting discussion worth having, in 2026 the celberties and fire is with the podcasters and viral shuirim. Who will aguda put as speakers? Its beautful to have R Malkeil shlita and other gedolim. But sadly anyone under 40 will tune out. Will they fire up the crowd with rabbi Eli and Rabbi Sruly plus Joey haber etc Or just the same olde routine with just abbish brodt singing.
Chaim87ParticipantVery interesting debate/ discussions. I will say, when it pertains to not frum or open orthdoxy, no they should not be invited and definitely not to a torah event. The idea that torah unfies and that there are other paths is only when its observed by its learners. Torah is not just a subject that we pursue for intllectual knowledge. Its something we intake. When one isn’t observant, thats not the kind of torah learning we are part of. Even if one is observant but he is a rabbi for non observant jews and uses his torah learning to tell others to do not like halcha his leraning isn’t what we aspire too and we are not part of that. Thats not called shiva panim ltorah. Now here is where I agree with many, I think today the modern orthodox/YU rabbonim are not doing naything against halcha. Certainlly not Rabbi Shechter. (Its debatble if the ones converting Ivanka Trump are against halcha but not the mainstream MO or center left). Its simply a debate of how yeshivsih or if one can be a rebbe in a yeshiva that allows LGBT clubs in its college. As somone pointed out R Aron worked with Rabbi JB zl even though he vehemently opposed him. They both sat together many times including by chinuch atzmai etc. Thats where its shameful
Chaim87Participant@akuperma Noone denies that american beef prices rose alot. But who says the answer is always to raise prices on the consumer? Maybe the answer is to reduce costs on your end? Maybe the answer is to rethink operations? can I cut out the middle men? Can I be more innovative? In fact mr beef cost8 plush kosher claims he can bring prices down to pre covid era by doing this. So someone has an answer just he was bullied. Furthermore, I think another answer is to work on getting more imported beef. Right now thats often hard to find and only a few select stores have limited selections. Again it means thinking out of the box. Side note, the mitzva on YT is to eat meat and not chicken. For large familes that can cost a few thousand
Chaim87Participant@nevuah
My premise is a fundemntal of frum judaism. Are you asking what if I think reform judiasm is correct? Torah is about the toil and effort vs success like a law school. Thats why we say anu amelim vham amelim. anu amelim umakblim sechar vham amalim venim mkeblim sachar. This means that they work and don’t get paid but we work and do get paid. But one second who works for free? The answer is that when one learns torah they get paid for work. They more you toil in it the more you get paid. But if one works hard at say an IT job you only get paid for the good you deliver . You dont et paid for working hard per say. This is a fundamental of judsiam where its the toil that counts. Torah isn’t a subject measured by examsChaim87Participant@anonymous Jew
Two things, first my point is that people tend to balme the sense of entitlement on learning people whereas working boys are more mature and demand less. My point is that I don’t think thats true. Its more a generational thing where people today feel entitled. Second, learning torah is not like attending law school. Sucess isn’t measured by what you “accomplish”. Torah is about effort and toil. Thats the fundamental of judiasm. if you can’t accpet that as a premise then there isn’t more to discuss. This forum is for frum jews who believe in hashem. This is a fundamental belief whether you are MO, chasdish and or litfish, So yes there isn’t and should not be tests to measure success. thats not how torah works. And the reward one gets for supporting torah is for more reaching then a son in law obtaining a law degree. Now you may mean to suggest that what stops learners from skipping half of seder and taking this as a joke. That’s true and such a son in law should not be supported. However, we are assuming that he is serious about learnig. (sadly the more serious one is, the less materlatsic they are and often the less support they get).September 8, 2026 2:24 pm at 2:24 pm in reply to: Was Rabbi AJ Twerski Right , the core of addiction is low self esteem? #2595640Chaim87ParticipantI confess alot of the comments are too deep for me. But the way I read it, you are all syaing that low self esteem could be a reason or siman why one is addicted. I agree. But I think its way overused. I think we say that because then we feel we have a cure for it, (fix the low self esteem). On the other hand, its very possible a perosn just started it bec it was cool at the time. Their firedns were doing it and it was aw ay to have fun or let loose (smoking is very much that especially in HS). Now they are just addicted to the fix. In other words tavious are addcitive in it of itself and not because of a low self esteem. I think people don’t like saying that because then whats the cure to fix that? We like to think we have a solution to every problem. sadly we don’t
September 3, 2026 9:45 pm at 9:45 pm in reply to: Was Rabbi AJ Twerski Right , the core of addiction is low self esteem? #2593949Chaim87Participant@Zanvil
why can’t the reason for your craving be because it tastes good and its fun? Yes I get used to that fun fix and now I crave it? It has to be because I “need” an escape? I don’t think soChaim87ParticipantI am a graduate from that system and there are a few lost points. Disclaimer, I assume you are focused on the secular high school education as opposed to the broader kollel system vs 50 years ago where the norm was to attend college right after HS and go to work. So this comment is based on the narrow focus of high school secular studies and its impact.
1) I don’t know how much those secular sugjects helped in terms of paransa for those that went to work 10-15 years after they graduated High school. Most of it was nonsense like Shakespare, and global studies etc.
2) There are plenty of college courses today that help kollel guys build careers in accounting, social work etc.
3) Rabbeim today earn more money than many accountants once you take into account free tuition for their child, free food before YT, reducted shitels and clothing, redcued vacations and c moed trips, a rebbe who is a tutor in the evening gets $100 for 45 minutes. So they earn more.
4) Classiic professional careers like we grew up with such as accountants haven’t kept up with the cost of inflation. I work in a highly regarded field that most would say wow. It doesn’t earn nearly as much as a jewish nursing home administratorNow the one thing that irkes me about no secular studies, most boys cannot sit and learn all day. Its just the facts. And we shove this no english down their throats we either have to waste time during the day to keep them busy or place an enormous strain on boys to do what they aren’t cut out to do.
And then there are schools that offer GED classes during super for extra money and so the boys who take it have no recess. Like for real? Let them miss a little learning. Recess is important. Why add pressure? Those are issues. But the paranasa part isn’t a major issueSeptember 2, 2026 1:14 pm at 1:14 pm in reply to: Was Rabbi AJ Twerski Right , the core of addiction is low self esteem? #2593043Chaim87Participant@??coffee addict
I am not debating if someone is addicted or what the means. I agree one can have a food addiction or any addiction. What I am saying is , the root cuase of that addcition need not be a low self esteem. The root cause could just be he like food and has cravings that he can’t control. The same is true for girls drugs or anything else. So we agree on what an addict is. The question is whats the root of it and how we solve it? I am not convinced its all self esteem.September 1, 2026 5:02 pm at 5:02 pm in reply to: Was Rabbi AJ Twerski Right , the core of addiction is low self esteem? #2592553Chaim87Participant??coffee addict
I just still don’t get it. Ever meet someone stuggling with wieght loss who still eats excessivley? I think we all know such people. They know its not healthy and good for them. Yet they eat anyhow. Do they have a low self esteem ? But they are addicted to an unhelathy thing? The answer is it tastes good and they are hungry. So whats the differnece if its fat guy eating thick oily triple schnitzel sandwhich with fires and junk in it or if its an alchohlic drinking or if its a guy hanging out with girls? It simply tastes good and feels good.
Chaim87Participant@zsk, the problem is that it not just a charedi issue. I see working guys making the same high demands. Maybe its still; charedi working vs MO? I suspect not. I think its more just the 2026 spoiled pampered entitlement altitude.
August 31, 2026 8:06 pm at 8:06 pm in reply to: Was Rabbi AJ Twerski Right , the core of addiction is low self esteem? #2591857Chaim87Participant@?coffee addict There are numerous people that are coffee addicts and it has no effects while others need it. Do those that ” need” it have a low self esteem? So now lets get to tavous whether drugs or girls or alchohol Yes those that “need” it are addicted. But who says they need it because they have a low self esteem? They need it because its fun and people are addicted to letting loose and having fun. Once you taste it, you need more and more bec thats what tavious does but not because you feel low about yourself
Chaim87Participant@anonymous Jew, the famous riddle goes like this, who really instituted the large scale kollel life that exists today in the USA? LBJ is the answer. He introduced govt programs8 and imposed a draft with a yeshiva expemption
August 30, 2026 9:38 am at 9:38 am in reply to: Was Rabbi AJ Twerski Right , the core of addiction is low self esteem? #2591028Chaim87ParticipantWhy do you always need to ‘let loose’? And why do you constantly focus on other genders?
I don’t understand your question. I don’t “need” to do this. But its fun and cool to let loose. Do people only have fun because they have a low self esteem?
Every time boys let loose its a low self esteem? Tavous lure people. I disagree with your premise. It could be that sometimes thats the cause. But I don’t buy thats always the cause.Chaim87ParticipantIts important to note, people associate support with being equal to those learning. I have meet plenty of working boys who demand support too. They want the shver to put them thru law school or help them buy a home too. Obviously its more vital when learning and the mitzva is greater. But its not unique to the learning “culture”. Its just an overall demand sadly
August 28, 2026 1:45 pm at 1:45 pm in reply to: Was Rabbi AJ Twerski Right , the core of addiction is low self esteem? #2590961Chaim87Participant@Always_Ask_Questions
My argument isn’t that the achohlic or whatever the addiction is can control themselves. My argument is simply, that I am not convinced they are doing it because of low self esteem or some underlying cause. They start doing it because its fun. Then once its fun it drags a person and can be addictive. Similarly is every OTD child acting out because of a low self esteem? Or simply bec its fun to smoke and hang out? Why can’t we just say its a big world and tavos have a way to drag people? In a very simple manner, say you are on a diet but hanging out by a kiddish with delcious food and you don’t eat before shachris, chances are you’ll eat by that kiddush even though you shouldn’t. Tavous lures youAugust 27, 2026 4:09 pm at 4:09 pm in reply to: Was Rabbi AJ Twerski Right , the core of addiction is low self esteem? #2590560Chaim87ParticipantI always yuawn a little when people associate drinking, or going OTD or doing some other bad thing with low self esteem or trring to escape or some other outlet. Forgive me for not beleiving some of the phsycology stuff. I think its overdone. Often its simply fun to drink and hang out with other genders. Its fun to let loose. And having fun is addcitive to some. its just people letting loose and nothinbg deeper. its more fun than learning a blatt gemara. Why is everything so cimplciated and a symptom of something. Stop being so deep. People like to let loose
Chaim87ParticipantNormal is relative but I think the standard middle class approach is that the shver pays for a basement rental in Lakewood and the couple covers the rest on their own.. That is roughly 1800-2K a month.
Peroanlly while the above is a struggle, I think paying for the weeding is more daunting especially if its litfish who pays for the whole thing A classic middle income family will pay 90-100K at minumium to marry off their dughter. its not just wedding night, but the shabbos 7 brochos, clothing for the kallah, setting up the new aparatment etc,June 29, 2026 3:07 pm at 3:07 pm in reply to: Naming names of one who posts against Gedolim or Kehilos Kodesh of Klal Yisroel #2569042Chaim87ParticipantI don’t know why one has to call out someones name. They can just say bannign vaccines is retzicha without calling out gedolim. (side note I don’t think he banned it in public. Its just his personal belief). My comment above is more about big things. For example, lets say I don’t hold of the system in EY where everbody is learning. And say I believe people could go to the army and stay frum. The fact that you tell me, but all the gedolim say differently. Ill say so what. Yes they are gedolim and holy jews. But maybe that doesn’t mean they can decide every hashkafa issue. They aren’t nevaim. Maybe they all don’t know the metzias and/ or live in a certain envoirenment. Who says a gadol decided hashkafa? That didn’t exist in litfish circles years ago. R Moshe zl barely inserted himself into hashkafa. That doesn’t make gedolim any less helig.
June 28, 2026 5:55 pm at 5:55 pm in reply to: Naming names of one who posts against Gedolim or Kehilos Kodesh of Klal Yisroel #2568357Chaim87ParticipantI think you have to first ask who is a gadol? What makes someone a gadol? Let’s leave that aside and just say anyone is a talmud chacham and yirai shomiam shouldn’t be made fun of. But then you have a broader question, what is called das Torah that I have to follow a gadol. In some chasidish or Hungarian circles that meant everything I do in every hashkfah they are the boss. But in many circles especially litfish a rav or gadol answered shailas in Halacha . Hashkfah was something that each person just used their own judgment and hopefully with the right Torah views they decided correctly. Even in the 1960s and 1970s aside for some chasdim there weren’t so many kol korhas, asifas etc. All thiose kinds of ideas and centralised yeshiva system started after that. R shach zl for example controlled all yeshivas and no decision was made without him. This idea is a newish idea and I don’t think someone who disagrees with a “gadol” is a bad person or should be called out unless he mocks them
Chaim87ParticipantI am not sure if my comment went through and is just in the queue or not. But here is a response to many posts.
First to be clear yet again, I am not belittling the idea of being makpid on chlov yisroel especially when you could get it. Rather the idea of being makpid on a far out chashah that maybe a goy will pour choloiv stam milk into a c yisroel bottle or that maybe you’ll mix up parvee reesses with regular thats where I question things. So Ill clarify it yet again. I think generally one should try to only eat chalav yisroel. But chlov ystam is not chazor or treif.
And there are alot more rabbonim than R Moshe that held this way.
Chaim87Participant@ujm
False R Aron served it. i heard from eyewitnesses. And that was even when C ysiroel existed You think they lied?
Its hard for me to fathom that those who disagree with R moshe believe that a good chunck of klal ysiorel is eating treif? Like eating chazor? Just write off 50% of frum jews in the USA like that?
@HaKatan
Its false R aron served it . I heard form edus.
Now we can debate when R moshe said it. My point is also not to encourage eating cholv stam. But to the point is, even you admit R moshe allowed it for some people. So is it treif? Did R moshe ever allow chazor for some people? To make this far out gezirars by a safek that’s a “vata chahsash” seems ludicrous.
@yakovBA06 I think that’s debatable. But again that points to the fact that its not chazor or an issur dorosa. why would we be gozer on a small sofek?
@eddiee, What are you worried about? what if it gets confused? what will happen? Will they serve resses with meat that you’ll have boser bchalev? Highly unlikley. At most it will get mixed up and you’ll eat chlov stam. Thats not treif.June 15, 2026 11:21 am at 11:21 am in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2561694Chaim87Participant@nevuah
You wrote “But because we can’t control others.” I disgaree . I think we could change other. We meaning the rabbonim (I know the chasidsha masa with the reba rev zisha says otherwise). Just like rabbonim influence our internet use or size of shietlach, they can do this too. It won’t chnage everyone but it will matter. This our fundamental disagreement. I think rabbonim could change others and you think they can’t. So why don’t they change? Because they don’t care enough. The idea of shunning metarlism and having people tone things down is so lost. Its a faundmental of judaissm. It could be its also just easier to talk about the internet and noone wants to shut off the money tree but knocking rich people habaits. But you could chnage others and you could change the rich.
Re those trips, I do say no. Even if its sponsored. I work for a living too and don’t just own nursing homes where I can take off for 2 weeks. Re my rav he is the most humble simple person. he actually did tone down kiddashim by talking to the rich and having them stop. But I still think he could do more such as stop the fancy tripsJune 10, 2026 1:40 pm at 1:40 pm in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2560651Chaim87Participant@nevuah
I know people that made weird weddings and yes people spoke about them and its was embrassing. So I disagree with that point. Leaving that aside though, you have to know your child. You don’t want them crying while wlaking down the chuppah bec its embrassing. Obviously within reason. As a side note, there is also a difference between being gracious and presentable vs being osttentious. For example, I don’t agree with taknos that limit how much food to serve. (I mean like only $500 worth of seasme chicken) Yes It Ok to say you can only serve seasme chicken vs fancy foods. But to limit how much to serve or to not serve that at all, I disagree. People come to a simcha and are hungry. especailly with kvetchy kids and often from out of town. At a simcha you should make sure people are well feed just like when I invite you to my house for a shabbos seuda. Its so not enjoyable when a guest is hungry and his kids are kvetchy. Serve enough and make sure people don’;t have to fight for it. Thats just part of the cost of making a simcha and even if it increase your budget too bad.Now, back to the main point, there are two conversations that we keep on having.
1) what should i as a yachid do? Yes try to tone it down. Bec thats all I could do. yes there is this mussar Idea that if I chnage myself everyone else will change. you & i know thats baloney. Noone is changing bec of me. Sorry I don’t believe that. Neverthless, i need to do whats right even if noone changes but myself. That brings me though tot he next point.
2) what should the community focus on (not the yachid) Who sould the leaders target? Thats where I say target the rich. they matter and impact others.In short your point well taken up to a point. But if you focus on a community effort, ikts gotto be the rich
PS this doesn’t stop at weddings. same is ture for the fancy trips where a “shul” makes a tour to Europe for syuim on makkos and you feel like a loser if you don’t go. The rav can even call you over and nudge you to join the “chizzuk trip”. Its the fancy homes and lavish other parties too. We need to emphasis a desclation in pursuing luxuryJune 9, 2026 9:53 am at 9:53 am in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2559540Chaim87Participant@nevuah
we keep on going in circles. Why can’t I set an example?
1) I don’t set the tone as much as the rich guy and my examples matter much less. I am less influential. I won’t impact society like they do.
2) i am limited in scope by the fact that my lower standards are less far reaching. I can’t all of a sudden make a vort siwth shanps and cake. Because to a certain extent I am subject to society. So yes I can cut down on tomia erev shabbos and only serve home made chulen and kugel vs meat boards or I can put out just seasme chicken by thew shmorg vs peper steak too. Big deal. People won’t even notice. But when the rich guy makes a wedding in a nice hall and yes serves his peper steak etc and makes it nicer, it still makes a statement 100 times more, Lamsa he didn’;t make it at that fancy hotel.
3) As is ay mnay times kids don’t just live at home, They go to yeshiva, camp , shul and friends. if the hock is about the rich making fancy wedding they learn from that. Noone will hock that I didn’t serve a fancy tomao. Even if at home I stress to be simple, kids see whats “cool” out there.All the above point to one common thread, what the rich do matter alot more. They influence both what i can do and what the kids see.
Ill just say one more thing. For a while, there was a fad by the more eidal rich guys in Lakewood where they made weddings at takana halls just a lttile nicer but they refused to go all out and wanted to conform with others. Sadly thats becomng less the norm. but don’t say that we can’t chnage the rich. I think we scared to take them on because we want their money. We are scared that if we call them and say to tone down they will cut their chairty to us. We need a backbone
June 5, 2026 12:29 pm at 12:29 pm in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2558274Chaim87Participant@nevuah
I disagree. I think you can get the rich to change. My rav did it. he asked a very wealthy close to billionare in shul to please make his kiddush locally in shul vs at a hall and then asked a few other rich guys to tone their kiddish. all with kindness, not forecfully or demanding just with a request. Since he is a sincere rav that loves every jew and did it kndly they listened. He never made taknos but once the rich guy made a simpler kiddush so did the others. And so if the RY’s would sit down with the rich and encourgae (not force) more toned down weddings with the right love they’d listen.
Side note, i can easier fargin a anice shabbos 7 brochos at a hotel. Its a more quieter intimate setting and its hard to host at home. If rich guys want to go all out, that can be much more enjoybale than one night and less of a public kind of flaunting. (even that within reason)
@SQUARE_ROOT – wrong thread.June 3, 2026 3:45 pm at 3:45 pm in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2557651Chaim87Participant@Always_Ask_Questions,
move gradually in the opposite direction
Thats exactly my point. Sure I should move gradualy towards that goal. But thew more the rich move the needle the other way the more that gradual moves becomes harder.
@nevuah G-d doesn’t want to to do whats normal. This isn’t a faith thing. Yes to a certain point society needs to dictate. I disagree with your idea of ignoring whats around you. i don’t think that whats hahsem wants.You all miss the point and i feel like I am talking to a wall. We should perhaps have a conversation about mussar and what the middle class can do. But the main conversation is the rich. I don’t go for this answer oh lets work on oursleves and all is fine. Unless the rich stop you’ll never really change much.
Chaim87ParticipantI think calling trump a wimp or TACO is kind of an argument that lacks intellect. At the end of the day the guy has guts and did what no other president was ready to do which is to kill a bunch of leaders of a failry strong country. The man has guts for sure. Now here is the thing. Trump believes in quick wars. He isn’t anti war like people try to qoute him. They misunderstand his campiagn promise of no wars. He means to say no long drawn out stuff that last for years like Iraq with boots on the ground.. But he loves the in and out stuff and never meant to rule that out. Now it’s true that such an idea maybe misguided. Like don’t pick a battle unless you can finish it till the end. But don’t forget, noone has ever succeeded seeing a war to the end in modern history. From Vietnam, Afghanistan Iraq, Israel’s prior wars since 67 etc, even Russia and Ukriane, wars just never end. You can’t really full conquer or defeat unless you nuke an entire population like we did in 1945. So whats your choices in fighting wars? The trump idea is smack them and back down. Like this it weaknes them, its in and out and hopefully overtime it changes them. We can debate that but out of all the crazy trump ideas, this isn’t a crazy one. Granted israel has a different goal but that’s the USA goal
June 2, 2026 10:25 am at 10:25 am in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2556576Chaim87ParticipantAgain this is all very nice mussar but at the end of the day, there are certain things you can’t say no to. You can’t say no to a vort and only have shnaps and cake. We all agree that a balance between conformity and holding back must be struck. Do we disagree that its a balnace or do you think I should revert to shnaps and cake in my house for a vort? Yes or no please.
If we can agree that the answer above is yes then lets stop hocking about the middle class not spending on that l;ttle extra. Lets acknowledge the issue is that the uber rich needs to stop. And there are 5 other reasons why its the tich fancy ones that needs to be the focus aside for the fact that it puts pressure on us. This is just 1 of the 5.
May 29, 2026 11:37 am at 11:37 am in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2554993Chaim87ParticipantOr you can have the faith and stick out and not give a flying flip.
Hashem wants you to do whats right and not do things for others. true. But a perosn has to be normal. The idea of not giving a flying flip is wrong too.8 Myabe if you the chaftez chaim then yes. But your average person has to be normal.
There is a differnece between worrying every minute what yenim will think about you vs not giving a flip. And again this talks to the idea, that the higher the rich raise the bar the higher normal moves too. Yes techncially if I didn’t give a flip id just have shnaps and cake by a vort and finished. But now it cost money and its strain.May 29, 2026 11:37 am at 11:37 am in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2554992Chaim87Participant@nevuah
“I’m saying find a middle path. ” Agree but the “middle” moves when the rich raise the bar. Thats the whole point. You hit it. This is why its the rich we need to focus on more than the middle classMay 28, 2026 6:34 pm at 6:34 pm in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2554728Chaim87Participant@ashergg
1) We don’t live in a cave. Kids see and hear things. No matter how “torahdik” and simple we are, often kids will want more. You can try to impress whatever you want on them but society moves. Kids go to school and have friends. The nature of a person is to want more. Its not just the home in isolation. So when your kids see its cool because that6 rich guy had freid at a pool side BBQ (with a syuim of course) or that a rich guy made a fancy wedding, you can be torahdik and simple and say oh thats not what we aspire for. But the lure is still there. You can’t stop it. There are so many torahdik homes I know of whose kids are the biggest pursuers of gahsmyus. Some are very famous and wealthy. You think there fathers didn’t try to teach them better? Its abig world out there with a big lure. The home can’t fight society. But the society as a whole could chnage form the top down.
2) Yes as parents we have yetzer haras too. You can’t demand or expect we be perfect. yes we are mature bnut deep inside the allure of fancy things is cool by us too. Sure we should work on it but its a temptation that we must work in.
3) Yes you can’t deprive your child of whats social norms. If the bar is raised that high, too bad ytou can’t just dop things like they did in the 1980’s. Its not what hashem wnats and your kids will be mifits. Thats the hard facts.So this all points to that yes no matter how torahdik tone you set, there are extreme limtations. And the more the world moves higher in gashmyuis the more your limited in that. I don’t buy the arguemnt that if you just work on it at home, then all is good. The point is no we need to work on it as a society while also working on it at home. Without the society chnages your impact will be very limited.
Chaim87Participant@lakewhut
what about Oorah? Thats litfish. they send boys to yeshivas and have camps. Not knocking chabad but both could be true. I will also say that chabad has a challange because many never become frum and/ or just use it for a year or twoMay 28, 2026 3:27 pm at 3:27 pm in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2554548Chaim87Participant@nevuah
I dsiagree with your premise. Hashem does not want you to stick out like a saw thumb. And its also bad for your children to be a misfit. An exmaple I sue all the time is a vort. It would be much cheaper to just serve shanps and cake in your home. But its just weird. Like I keep on sayiing, there is a gray area . To a certain extent, yes we need to hold back and not run to to everything everyone else does but within normal standards still. Thats just life. The more the rich push the standards the more it becomes to normal to ignore. The hostess package thing is another point. Yes I can just send homemade chocolate chip cookies as a thnaks for hosting my guests but its a weird thing to do. And your neighbor may nit host for you next time aside for just stikcing outChaim87ParticipantIll just differentiate between YU as an institution vs its graduates. Also I mean the yeshiva and not the college. I as a charedi can attest to working with some of those graduates. They are often more ehrlich and bali halacha than the yeshiva guys. Much more emes people too. I worked with one who only davened mincha in the office when he knew he wouldn’t make it home on time. Otherwise of course you daven in shul. He also woke up 5Am avery day and learned till 7. This guy as a VP and sadly was nifter young. As ehrlich as they come.
Chaim87ParticipantJust to quantify a bit. I get that things change. I always thought mesora in todays days refers to doing this like our grandfathers did in Europe pre war. Like thats the key. Freezing things at that time. Because we can’t trust the USA as much and its less kehila based plus the generrations went down and the gedolim aren’t the same. So obviulsy chasdim isn’t rich mesora for 1000 years but the idea is withold what your zeida did. However, i think thats mistaken. Most of us don’t do what our zeidas did before the war either. And so the whole thing becomes fuzzy then.
May 27, 2026 1:56 am at 1:56 am in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2553755Chaim87Participant@nevuah
1) Re stop conforming, here is where I disagree. A person needs to conform. You have to be normal. Sorry. And if we can’t afford it then we need to borrow thats life. We can’t be a weirdo or socially off. So if everyone makes a vort, we need to as well. We can’t be weird and only serve shnaps and cake. Now there is a balance . And we don’t need to do whatever the rich guy does bec thats what we call normal. Obvioulsy, there is no flat line as to what everyone considers normal and we could always down that standard via pushing it to the lower end. But the vort is a good exmaple whereby you can’t get around that without being weird. And whether you make a fancy vort for 10K or simple one for 5K it still costs. Likewise the dress and make up etc. Your girls can’t show up in weekday cloths and no make up. Its just socially off. Well for a family of girls, getting the hair done , make up and an outfit still cost even if its a cheaper person who does it. And so my point remains that the more the rich push, even if you tone it down, your normal standrad without being a social misfit will just go up. Thats just whats “done today”.
2) My other points still remain. Its the rich fancy affairs that glazmoirize gashmyuis which has a bad hashpa on the young generation who see it as “cool”. Yes as parents we can preach its all sheker but kids go to schools where thats the hock and play with freinds etc. We don’t live in a bubble. We are an interactive society.
3) the rich themselves are pursuing gashmyuis and not focusing on the right things. When i as middle class make a simcha and splurge on an extra tray of pepper steak, thats not really pursuing gashymuis even though So Yes i can skip it and “tone it down” but i wouldn’t call that a pursuit of luxury.. Its very different than a destination wedding simcha. The actual pursut of luxury is against judiasmThis is points to one thing. The converstaion has to focus on the rich. of course middle class should do what they can to tone it down, but thats the wrong focus. the rich is by far the big problem.
Chaim87Participant@johnnysmith
why a zero sum game? Just shut down any new chat about zionism. There should be one chat where they can go to and freely debate. But they shouldn’t be allowed to highjack the other chats and should be blocked from posting anyhting about zionsim. Everyone just stick to their own chat. It not a reaosn to close the whole coffee room downMay 20, 2026 11:28 am at 11:28 am in reply to: What Would You Do In Shul With Loud Hatzalah Radio? #2551943Chaim87ParticipantIn 2026 there are so many noises whether from vehichles outside or cell phones left on. Its part of the background already. Let it be and get used to our enviornement. Yes the guys that shishkar the 80 year old who left his cell phone ringer on disturb me and most people more than the cell phone
May 18, 2026 7:16 pm at 7:16 pm in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2550872Chaim87Participant@nevuah
We agree that there is a medium. And of course the point is each of us tone down just a little bit but within what’s still societal norms. However, my point is, that as the rich push the standard higher and higher, the societal norms slowly move the needle. And then even what we tone down still becomes a mountain bec of how high the norm becomes. Furthermore but similar, most people won’t tone it down and so even if we do because we are nei aliyiah, it doesn’t move the standards. And the higher the rich push the higher we all have to go. There is also simply the fact that yes we do like kovod and get jealous. We are human. And the higher the rich go, the harder your challange becomes on a perosnal level to disregard it. This all leads to one direction. What the rich matters alot more than what I do.
Side note, Perosnally I don’t agree with the fundamental that making a simcha is about me. Rather its about the child., Sometimes, a child needs a nicer band or flowers and some children are Ok with lessChaim87Participant@ashergg
I get you, but I just struggle with , how those “small” things even mean mesora? It seems to not have a connection to the “past”. Its more like what wroks now by latching onto someone else who did that in the past but its not our pastMay 17, 2026 8:07 pm at 8:07 pm in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2550261Chaim87Participant@nevuah /@user176
A person can’t be socially off and weird. As an extreme example, you shouldn’t make a wedding in shul with shnaps and cake even though that’s all you can afford. And that’s what they did in DP camps. That’s just weird and off. It’s likely that your child will highly resent that. Similarly, a vort can’t just be in your friends making chocolate chips cookies in your tiny dinning room. It’s weird. Now where the line between weird and just lowering your standard is, is very gray . But the point is, as the rich push the standard up that gray line moves naturally just like it did for vorts
Just to reiterate, the issue of pushing up the standard for everyone is only one of many reasons that Rich shouldn’t make lavish weddings . There are 5 more reasons and it’s our business to tell themMay 15, 2026 4:31 pm at 4:31 pm in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2549607Chaim87Participant@nevuah
Fair point and I am ready to move two inches not just one inch. But the problem won’t be solved unless the rich guys stop. Just telling me to move that one inch won’t help. Furthermore, the needle is moving so much, that me moving one inch is still 5 inches more than what used to be because the norms are so high.
Ill repeat that yes we are gald to tone it down but you can’t ruin your childrens lives and you don’t want them to cry to oyu by their simcha if its nebachdik. Its not fair to them. And so yes a little lower but up to a point and when the neddle is so far ahead thats hard. As an example, its now very rude and inconsiderate not to give hostess gifts when a neighbor hosts for you. It would be socially off to send bubbys cholcolate chip cookies as a gift. This is the new norm. This is just one of many.
My main point is, that its the rich guys that need to stop and we need to talk about them. Don”t white wash it by saying just talk about usChaim87Participant@ashergg
so what about our pesach mingahim, what we daven, lag bomer fires, how we conduct weddings , Mitzva tanz etc. Is that mesora and whose mesora is that? Our fathers , our rebas? who? I get that there is mesorah like in the gemaras times (yesh am lemsora) and those things are unversial that never change. But I mean stuff like a minahg of a chasduis or yeshivsih.May 14, 2026 3:45 pm at 3:45 pm in reply to: Matzav Inbox: What Is Going On With These Weddings? #2549530Chaim87ParticipantSadly they basically do sing Yamin when the rich guy walks in. The idea that torah and being lavish don’t mix together, is almost completely lost in yeshivas. And the idea that as ling as we teach people to be torahdil that naturally falls in place is misguided. Furthermore, the yeshivas themelves compete who can have a fancier building. And then when a shul makes a syuim on Makkos in Lublin, touring Europe foe a week in luxury what does that teach? I get it kovod hatroah and we should be proud that we are making a syuim. Its also better than touring the bahams. But lets get real. This is where your idea that torah doesn’t go with being lavish is gone. Yeshivas and rabbonim need to start a movement like they did with the internet to put an end to this
-
AuthorPosts