Redleg

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 50 posts - 201 through 250 (of 514 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Tznius Problem? #1364242
    Redleg
    Participant

    Slonimer, exactly! Your community standards apply to you. You are entitled to disapprove of other standards but as long as those standards have some reasonable rabbinic support, even a das yachid, they are still within the daled amos of Torah.
    For instance, it is well known that many frum married women in Lite did not cover their hair which would, in our communities, constitute erva. The limud sechus on them was that in general practice, married women routinely went without hair covering so uncovered hair no longer constituted erva.

    in reply to: Tznius Problem? #1363683
    Redleg
    Participant

    randOm3X
    1. That particular pasuk in Micah is often quoted as source text for the subject discussed in this thread. “Tznius” I.E. female modesty.
    2. The Halachah is contextual as well. In the community described, it may very well be assur to daven in front of a woman with an exposed forearm. Likewise, in a community where women only cover the shoulder and top of the upper arm it would appear to be muttar to daven if front of a women so attired.

    in reply to: The Casualties of Yiddish in Litvishe Chadorim #1362748
    Redleg
    Participant

    I grew up in a home where Yiddish was spoken as well as English so I did not encounter much difficulty in understanding Taitch. The problem these days is that most American born Rebbis (except those in Chassidishe communities) don’t really speak Yiddish very well so most of what they teach in is “Yinglish” (sometimes called Yeshivish). I maintain that Instruction should be in English. English has, by far, the largest and most nuanced vocabulary of any language, enabling precise translation of the most complicated concepts. Of course, the problem with that is that most American born Rebbis don’t speak English very well either.

    P.S. RMF maintained that all Ashkenazi Jews should learn Yiddish as a Minhag Kadosh.

    in reply to: Inappropriate intermingling at Chasunas 💃🍸🍷🕺 #1362768
    Redleg
    Participant

    Not dressed to kill. Only dressed to wound.
    as I’ve posted on another thread, men looking or not is a halbe tzureh, at best a shvus. An immodestly dressed woman is oiver an issur D’Oraisah of lifnei iver regardless of whether or not men look or have, C”S, improper thoughts.

    in reply to: Tznius Problem? #1362711
    Redleg
    Participant

    Some random thoughts on tznius:
    1. When the Navi says,”…hatzneiah leches im Elokechah.” He isn’t talking about women’s hemlines. For that matter, he isn’t talking to women. He is telling all of Klal Yisroel to eschew arrogance and ostentation in their service of HaShem (“look how frum I am”) and in their daily lives.
    2. What constitutes ervah is, at least in part, determined by community standards. For instance, in a community where women wear sleeves to the wrist, a bare forearm might very well be ervah. Whereas those communities that only require the arm and elbow be covered would be perfectly okay with bare forearms.
    3. The prohibition that a women violates when immodestly dressed is Lifnei Iver. The thing to remember about Lifne i Iver is that the issur is not causing someone to stumble but placing the michshol itself. Therefore telling men not to look or to control their thoughts is meaningless. The fact is that the overwhelming majority of men can and do control themselves. That doesn’t mitigate the issur in the least.

    in reply to: Let’s just agree to mythologize American history #1348945
    Redleg
    Participant

    Sorry, Joe. I intended those as two separate thoughts. I did not mean to conflate the denim of avdus with mythology. But as far as mythology goes, we certainly have, and continue to, mythologize our history. A trivial example of which is the Artschroll Gedolim series. I’ve always felt that if Abaye and Rava could, somehow, be transported to present-day Lakewood, they would not recognize the Judaism being practiced. Well, they might recognize the Beis Medrash and that the bachurim were doing something resembling learning. But much of the current practice would be unknown to them.

    in reply to: Let’s just agree to mythologize American history #1348562
    Redleg
    Participant

    “Let’s all agree to mythologize American history”
    Why not? We’ve done a pretty good job of mythologizing our own history.

    Re Slavery: Two types of slavery were practiced in the Colonies (later States).One type was Indenture, in which an individual was sold (or sold himself) to serve a master for a fixed period of time. to learn a trade or pay off a debt or any other cause of need, the terms of which roughly correspondto those of an eved Ivri.
    The second type, and the type of slavery usually referred to, is chattel slavery in which the master actually owns the physical person of the slave, much as one may own a horse or a cow, the terms of which pretty much correspond to those of eved K’nanni.

    in reply to: The Marine Corps Mystery #1335740
    Redleg
    Participant

    The U.S. Marine Corps is, in fact, part of the U.S. Navy and does not have a separate Secretariat as does the Army, Air Force and Navy, the Marine Corps being under the latter.

    in reply to: Calling cops on frum neighbor #1335728
    Redleg
    Participant

    If the rav said that “he would take care of it”, It seems reasonable for the OP to follow up in the issue, I.E. ask what, if anything, the Rav found out and what, if anything, he “took care of”.

    in reply to: Switching to the metric system is a bad idea #1302913
    Redleg
    Participant

    Meno, some engineering protocols do, in fact, use decimal inches which works very well but, again, one needs to be familiar with it to us it naturally. What size open end wrench would you need for a nut that measures 0.3125″ across the flats?

    in reply to: Switching to the metric system is a bad idea #1302603
    Redleg
    Participant

    Any measuring system works when one is sufficiently familiar with it so as to be able to visualize the measurement and think in those units. For instance, If I tell you that someone is 6 feet tall, you probably have a good mental picture of about how tall that is, but if I say that he’s 1.8 meters tall you generally have no mental image at all. Likewise, If I tell you that it’s 21 degrees Celsius out side, you don’t know how to dress but if I say that it’s 70 degrees F you know instantly what to wear.

    Besides the fact that it takes some getting used to, there are, in my opinion, two significant deficiencies in the metric system.
    1. There is no metric equivalent for the the imperial foot. The existing metric units are either too big or too small for convenient use.
    2. While this doesn’t actually effect every day use, Metric countries also generate electricity at 50 cycles instead of the 60 cycles we’re used to. This is completely silly because. even in the metric system there are 60 minutes in an hour, not 50, and 24 hours in a day. A circle still has 360 degrees not 300. back in the days of analog electric clocks, it was physically impossible to make an accurate one on 50 cycle current. It would run either too fast or too slow.

    in reply to: 18 tons of seized cocaine in San Diego #1300548
    Redleg
    Participant

    They usually burn it in a high temperature furnace

    in reply to: If a chosson is blind, is unveiling his kallah enough? #1295076
    Redleg
    Participant

    The unveiling of the Kallah is not only for the Choson. The Eidei Kiddushin must also get a good look at the Kallah or their eidus is not valid. How can they be mayid that Plonis bas Ploni is married to Chaim Yankle Plonawitz if they don’t know what Plonis looks like?

    in reply to: Who as here [Israel] first Jews or the Palestinians? #1295072
    Redleg
    Participant

    It is also possible that many of today’s Palestinians are descendants of Jews who had been living in the Land since Bayis Sheini and were forcibly converted to Islam during the Arab Conquest.

    in reply to: ???? ???? ???? Extreme Chumros #1252401
    Redleg
    Participant

    My family did not eat milchigs on Pesach. Also, my Zeidies only drank white wine at the Seder because of the blood libels. I personally do not follow that custom as it was done out of fear of the Goyim at that time and place.

    in reply to: Forcing chumrot on others #1252249
    Redleg
    Participant

    “So apparently someone does not believe In hashgocha pratis…”

    Nisht, I never worried about a “bullet with my name on it”. It was the ones addressed to “Current Resident” that I worried about.

    in reply to: Forcing chumrot on others #1252138
    Redleg
    Participant

    There is a kuntres by the Chofetz Chaim, ZTL, called, if I remember correctly, Machaneh Yrhudah which covers how one should conduct himself when drafted into the Army. He was referring to the Russian or German armies. I read it when I was drafted into the U.S. Army and found it very helpful as it did point out leniencies that one could use in such circumstances.

    in reply to: War on Kitnyos #1252056
    Redleg
    Participant

    It seems to me that corn being considered kitnios is due to language confusion. In Yiddish (and German), KORN is the word for rye (or a generic word for grain) which is one of the 5 minim (Kornbroit is made from rye flour). While corn meal can be and is used to make baked goods, one can easily distinguish American corn bread from regular bread made from wheat or a corn tortilla from a flour tortilla.
    Re legumes. Bad translation. Legumes are a class of plants that add nitrogen to the soil. The class includes most bean varieties including those that cannot possibly ground to flour like string beans and others (if you grind up peanuts, all you get is peanut butter) and some varieties that no one considers kitnios. For instance. corn, which is generally considered kitnios, is not a legume while alfalfa sprouts, which is, in fact, a legume is not kitnios.

    in reply to: Kitniyos Expansion #1251040
    Redleg
    Participant

    Based on the reasons quoted above and others, can someone explain why potato starch ISN’T kitnios?

    in reply to: need kiruv advice #1247981
    Redleg
    Participant

    Just a note To Nechama about Klal Yisroel at Har Sinai. The 600,000 were just the men between the ages of 20 and 60. R’ Moshe ZATZAL, estimated that the actual number of witnesses was around 2,500,500.

    in reply to: Being Yotzei Daled Kossos with sleeping #1243355
    Redleg
    Participant

    What does Ad d’lo yodah have to do with Pesach. The mitzvah of Pesach is zechira which clearly requires the Seder participant to be awake and cogent. The daled cosos, as every one knows, are keneged the four lashonos of geulah and are part of the the zechira. Those individuals who cannot drink four reviis size servings of normal wine over the course of a several hour period without nodding off have a couple of eitzehs:

    1. Low alcohol content wine. Normal wine is 12-13% alcohol. Low alcohol wine, very much like “new wine” which was drunk in antiquity, is about 5% alcohol and modern pasteurized grape juice has, of course no alcohol. Note that many poskim hold that using grape juice is a b’dieved at best.

    2. While the largest shiur of reviis that I know of is 5.3 fl oz per the Chazon Ish (N.B. 5 oz is a normal serving of wine in the U.S.) there are recognized poskim who hold that s reviis is considerably smaller. One man d’amar, I forget who, holds that a reviis is only 3 fl oz. While it is, of course, preferable to be yotzei all shitos, it might be wise to use a smaller reviis in order to stay awake and and be mekiyaim the main mitzvah of the seder, zechira.

    in reply to: What would you do? #1229194
    Redleg
    Participant

    Some of the previous posters are demonstrating my points about

    misunderstanding, miss-information and obsession. PS Joey, you are just repeating my advice. The SA is not advising not to speak to women in gantzen. There is no question that sichah letachlis is permitted. So many people simply don’t understand the concepts of what is to be avoided.

    Hey, Mods. How’s that for a circumlocution (Am I allowed to say that?)

    🙂

    in reply to: What would you do? #1229177
    Redleg
    Participant

    Sichah for tachlis perfectly OK. Just keep it short and to the point.

    in reply to: Big Gedalya Gumber #1222685
    Redleg
    Participant

    This belongs on the “Heroes” thread

    in reply to: Do We Believe in Heroes? #1222010
    Redleg
    Participant

    LB, there seems to be some confusion over a definition of heroism. Some previous respondents want to conflate heroism with being a good role model. While there is, of course, considerable overlap, not all legitimate heroes are suitable role models. Likewise, many truly excellent role models may not be particularly heroic.

    Not believe in heroes, LB? Preposterous! Thank G-d there have been heroes in Yisrael who arose in time of need and did great things. There are heroes among us now who are moser nefesh for Torah and Klal Yisrael and G-d willing, new heroes will arise when we need them. You could be one of them.

    in reply to: Is the grass greener on the other side? #1220823
    Redleg
    Participant

    Vide Irma Bombeck “The Grass is Always Greener Over the Septic Tank”

    in reply to: I'm flattered #1220504
    Redleg
    Participant

    in reply to: Hamsa hand #1213086
    Redleg
    Participant

    The Hamsa seems to be a general middle east/arab symbol that has been adopted by Jews. I don’t know what, if any Kabalistic significance it has.

    P.S. The hamsa is a flower, a lily, not a hand with two thumbs.

    in reply to: Who was the worst President of your lifetime? #1197230
    Redleg
    Participant

    Which brings us to my candidate for Worst President in my Lifetime, I give you the man who cured me of voting Democratic, James Earl Carter. He helped create and presided over what was thought to be an economic impossibility, double digit inflation with double digit unemployment. 1n 1979, he single-handedly created a gasoline shortage where none actually existed. His foreign policy made America the laughingstock of the international community not to mention a punching bag for every two bit dictator and mullah who wanted to show off their toughness by beating up on the U.S. Add to that the fact that he was a not so closet antisemite and you have the absolute quinella of Presidential rottenness

    Nice to hear from you!

    in reply to: Who was the worst President of your lifetime? #1197229
    Redleg
    Participant

    CT Law, I was born during FDR’s Presidency but the first President I actually remember was Truman who turned out to be a pretty good President. thought Eisenhower was a good President as well. He was active and decisive when he needed to be and he followed Lord Northcote’s dictum,” When it is not necessary to do something, it is necessary NOT to do something”. I recall, at the time, the Democrats made light of Ike’s supposed intellectual limitations. They must have missed the part where he led the larges army of western allies ever assembled, to victory over Nazi Germany while holding that alliance of rivals together long enough to do it. F rom 1952 to 1960, Eisenhower presided over eight years of peace and prosperity (of course the fact that the U.S. had the only industrial plant that hadn’t been bombed to rubble may have had something to do wit that). We may recall it as folly now but the threat of attack by the Soviet Union, particularly while Stalin was alive, was quite real and terrifying. Ike’s actions at the time have to be viewed with his very real concern in avoiding nuclear holocaust.

    Eisenhower achieved an armistice if the Korean war. Your statement attributing the beginning of the Vietnam involvement to Ike is absurd. Under the terms of the negotiated peace treaty between France and the Viet Minh (yes it was abrogated by the US) Ike sent some 430 military advisors to South Vietnam. The same number of advisors were there when Kennedy became President in 1961.

    Kennedy and his SECDEF, McNamara, are the true authors of the debacle in Vietnam (N.B. McNamara continued to serve in that capacity under Johnson). It took another Republican, Richard Nixon, to end that war. P.S. If Kennedy hadn’t stolen the election in 1960 we probably would never have gone to war Vietnam

    The First President I voted for was LBJ who rewarded me by sending me to aforementioned South East Asia war games. Notwithstanding the fact that he was a dirtbag, Nixon was a pretty good (albeit liberal) President. Besides extracting the U.S. from the disaster in Vietnam, he also signed off on the major environmental laws in force to this day as well as, wait for it…Affirmative Action!

    in reply to: What quantity of moderate drinking is healthiest? #1184512
    Redleg
    Participant

    According to the Dept. of Nutrition, Harvard School of Public Health, review of Moderate Alcohol Consumption, moderate alcohol consumption has been observed to beneficially modulate several diseases including cardio-vascular disease, Type 2 diabetes among others.

    “Moderate alcohol consumption” is defined as: Two 1 1/2 oz shots of 80 proof spirits, or two 5oz glasses of wine or two 12oz servings of beer daily for women the amount listed for men is halved, I.E. one shot, one glass, one serving daily

    in reply to: Because you're keeping it that way #1183914
    Redleg
    Participant

    Every time you don’t do something simply because others don’t.”

    Or vice versa.

    in reply to: Mochel Loch… time to forgive and be forgiven! #1184965
    Redleg
    Participant

    While you all are busy forgiving all the people you may have wronged, don’t for get to forgive yourself as well. S’shteit “b’tzedek tishpote amisecha.” you are also “amisecha” so judge yourself favorably as well.

    in reply to: Parody in Halacha #1184329
    Redleg
    Participant

    Have any of you guys ever watched or participated in a Purim Shpiel?

    in reply to: Take the TV out of the Restaurant or we will shut you down #1181054
    Redleg
    Participant

    Joey, peaceful picketing is, of course, legal. However, If patrons are aggressively accosted and harassed, not to mention if the establishment is vandalized, the action rises to the level of criminal activity. This is what the the owners wanted to avert by reaching an agreement with the Kanoim. The point is that a simple boycott by people who wouldn’t have gone to place anyway would not have been intimidating enough to the owners to force a concession from them.

    in reply to: Take the TV out of the Restaurant or we will shut you down #1181049
    Redleg
    Participant

    Boycott wasn’t exactly what was threatened. Heck, there are plenty of businesses in Monsey that I refuse to patronize for one reason or another. What was being threatened was aggressive picketing and (perhaps) vandalism. The “accommodation” that was reached was a pay off. The protection racket is still alive and well.

    in reply to: Can you comfort me #1183818
    Redleg
    Participant

    You know, I sometimes think that, rather than offering chizuk and mussar to the CR, MA is really subtly mocking the feelings and ideas he offers with such seeming sincerity and, by extension, the other members of the CR that do, in fact, actually hold those views and attitudes.

    in reply to: The Hishtadlus of Voting #1179749
    Redleg
    Participant

    Hey, MA! Maybe we should just vote for the Satan. Why settle for the lesser evil?

    in reply to: Is Hillary too weak and fragile to survive the rigors of the presidency? #1190269
    Redleg
    Participant

    The fact is that Hillary getting sick on the campaign trail is not much of an issue. Nu, folks get sick once in a while and it’s not such a big deal. The big deal is Hillary’s propensity for obfuscation and her obsession with privacy that verges on paranoia. In any situation, it appears that her first instinct is to lie. She lies automatically. She lies when the truth would be to her advantage…

    I’m sorry but I can’t continue. I’m feeling overheated and dehydrated.

    in reply to: Ladies First – Is it respectful or not? #1178595
    Redleg
    Participant

    Joey, with regard to the Titanic and similar situations, “Women and children first” makes good. biologic sense. Women and children, after all, represent the continuation of the (human) race. Men on the other hand, are expendable as one man can have many wives. Incidentally, that’s where Pharaoh messed up. If he wanted to destroy Klal Yisroel, he should have been goizer on the daughters.

    in reply to: halacha thread by Sparkly #1180537
    Redleg
    Participant

    RE: horseback riding. What ever happened to women’s riding skirts? They were actually pants with very full pleated legs so when a woman was standing it looked like she was wearing a full, mid-calf length skirt but since they were actually trousers it allowed her to ride astride. Actually, in some circles it was considered immodest for a woman to ride astride even in a modest riding skirt. A woman’s side saddle allowed a woman to ride while dressed in modest feminine attire.

    in reply to: Friday of Chukas Attack #1159463
    Redleg
    Participant

    Here’s a question for you, Joey. What constitutes Golus? Is it the lack of the Beis Hamiqdash? Were the Jews who returned to E’Y from Bavel still in golus until the B’H was built? Or is is it the in gathering of the Jewish People to E’Y? Note that Bayis Sheini did not require overt Divine intervention to build and that during the entire period of Bayis Sheini, the majority of Jews still lived in Ch’L. Is it Jewish independent rule? After centuries of vassalege successively to the New Babylonian, Persian and Selucid empires, the successful Maccabean revolt left Israel an Independent, self-governing nation. Were the Jews still in Golus? Even though the Hasmoneans were not the halachic rulers of Israel and weren’t exactly “frum” either (Alexander Yanai, arguably the most successful Hasmonian king, was famously opposed to rabbinic tradition)?

    I submit that a case can be made that, even though the B’H is yet to be built, and even though the current government of the Medina is no more halachic than the Hasmoneans, the rise of an independent Jewish State on the historical, G-d given, land of Israel constitutes, at least, the prerequisites for the end of golus, may it be complete bemeirah beyameinu.

    in reply to: Friday of Chukas Attack #1159461
    Redleg
    Participant

    Wrong again, Joey!

    in reply to: Controversy In Israel – Woman says Sheva Brachos #1180875
    Redleg
    Participant

    The problem I see is so much halachic. It’s more a metaphysical issue. Can a person bless him (or her) self? The purpose of saying the sheva berachos is for the mevorchim to invoke berachah on the choson/kalah. By doing themselves, the choson/kalah in this case are losing the benefit of birchas hedyot (and not so hedyot).

    in reply to: Reading vs Audiobook #1143665
    Redleg
    Participant

    Learning with an audio tape or CD still requires one to follow along inside. Audiobooks, novels or non-fiction, are great for long drives. I much prefer them to music CDs or listening to the radio.

    Redleg
    Participant

    Mazel Tov, CT! The untereste shura (bottom line) is that it’s your money, your daughter’s simcha, your plan is just fine and some people are gonna be offended no matter what you do.

    in reply to: Who's Worse – Trump or Clinton? #1190332
    Redleg
    Participant

    This is what politics in the U.S. has come to: A bloviating bully or a female Richard Nixon. The evil of two lessers. I have voted in every general election since 1964, either in person of by absentee ballot, but I think I may sit this one out.

    in reply to: Different havaras #1100622
    Redleg
    Participant

    Google “Gefilte Fish Line”

    in reply to: Is it wrong to secretly not want moshiach to come #1132548
    Redleg
    Participant

    My guess is that the OP’s concern is based on his (or her) belief in what the Messianic Age will be like. There are, of course, many opinions on that issue. I, myself, think that the RAMBAM’s description is the most mistabra but I’d bet that I and everyone else, whatever shita we hold, will be surprised when the Day comes, b’meheirah b’yomeinu.

    in reply to: It is d�j� vu all over again #1100609
    Redleg
    Participant

    Not all Yogi-isms are really from Yogi.

Viewing 50 posts - 201 through 250 (of 514 total)