Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
June 16, 2025 7:46 pm at 7:46 pm in reply to: circa 1900: Letter from Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Heresy of “Religious” Zionism #2412940ujmParticipant
Yaakov Yosef A: Perhaps you shouldn’t assume that we don’t already do exactly that and always have been doing exactly that.
June 15, 2025 8:01 pm at 8:01 pm in reply to: circa 1900: Letter from Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Heresy of “Religious” Zionism #2412085ujmParticipantZSK — Not only is it my business, but it is the business of every Jew. Kol Yisroel Areivim Zeh L’Zeh includes the spiritual beings of every other Jew; not just their physical beings.
June 15, 2025 8:01 pm at 8:01 pm in reply to: Gedolei Poskim in EY Again: All Jews Are Forever Forbidden From IDF. Why? #2412080ujmParticipant“Charedi Gedolim” is redundant; there are no other Gedolim.
And, yes, religious Jews, who never asked for the State that triggered a century of violence, shouldn’t serve it.
And they aren’t needed.
They are needed in defending Kal Yisroel with their Limud Torah and being Shomer Torah U’Mitzvos; things the secular neglect and refuse to sacrifice for.
June 15, 2025 9:55 am at 9:55 am in reply to: circa 1900: Letter from Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Heresy of “Religious” Zionism #2411760ujmParticipantYaakov Yosef: It most certainly is every Jews business. Mrs. Bennett is a public Sabbath desecrater and a public Kashrus desecrater and a public desecrater of everything holy and obligatory.
Public activity is every Jew’s business.
June 15, 2025 9:55 am at 9:55 am in reply to: How Should Israel Thank the United States for American Military and Economic Aid #2411757ujmParticipantThe United States is once again defending Israel with American military personnel operating US military hardware in and around Israel to defend Israel from Iran.
June 14, 2025 11:59 pm at 11:59 pm in reply to: Gedolei Poskim in EY Again: All Jews Are Forever Forbidden From IDF. Why? #2411439ujmParticipantNon Political: There are, also, examples of Sefardi, Litvish, and Chasidish Poskim who have instructed people to eat treif food.
Or to kill someone. Or to drive on Shabbos. Or to r’l amputate a limb. Or to eat chometz on Pesach.
Sometimes it is permitted or required.
June 13, 2025 4:13 pm at 4:13 pm in reply to: circa 1900: Letter from Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Heresy of “Religious” Zionism #2411163ujmParticipantYaakov Yosef: You would, seriously, take Naftali Bennett, married to an open and proud mechallel Shabbos and lack of taharas hamispacha woman, even b’dieved, as an Eid?
ujmParticipantYWN doesn’t represent anyone other than the owner of the website.
June 12, 2025 3:52 pm at 3:52 pm in reply to: circa 1900: Letter from Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Heresy of “Religious” Zionism #2410364ujmParticipantThe Gemora is correct. Albert Einstein, in his Theory of Relatively, proved that saying the sun resolves around the earth and saying that the earth revolves around the sun, are functionally equivalent and effectively saying the same thing.
June 11, 2025 9:37 am at 9:37 am in reply to: Gedolei Poskim in EY Again: All Jews Are Forever Forbidden From IDF. Why? #2410013ujmParticipantThe only difference between Satmar and most of the other Gedolim was how to deal with and interact with the State post facto. Most said you can vote and take money, whereas Satmar holds you cannot vote and cannot accept Israeli government funding.
Otherwise, Brisk, Agudas Yisroel, the Litvish and the other Chasidish all held and hold the same as Satmar vis-a-vis Zionism.
The difference is very minor. On virtually all the significant questions they all hold the same.
June 10, 2025 11:27 pm at 11:27 pm in reply to: circa 1900: Letter from Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Heresy of “Religious” Zionism #2409862ujmParticipantThose uninterested in what some rabbis said 125 years ago or 80 years ago, should burn their Talmuds.
ujmParticipantubiq: Yes, very much poorly; especially after you deduct the EHK’s 16,000 fraudulent votes that the WZO is now invalidating and removing.
But at the end of the day it might not even matter, altogether, since the WZO is considering disqualifying the entire EHK slate entirely, as per the recommendation of its Area Election Committee (AEC), based on the fraud that was uncovered.
ujmParticipantAAQ: There’s absolutely nothing reductio ad absurdum about either including both OO and MO (or excluding OO and MO).
What would be reductio ad absurdum is to advocate to include only one, but exclude the other, between OO and MO.
June 8, 2025 9:05 pm at 9:05 pm in reply to: circa 1900: Letter from Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Heresy of “Religious” Zionism #2407913ujmParticipantSquare: Lubavitch is still anti-Zionist today.
The only difference with the past is that they don’t talk much about it anymore.
ujmParticipantOnly third place? The Reform did double as well as the fake-religious so-called “Eretz Hakodesh”. Baruch Hashem the EHK fakers did so poorly.
But even more than that, the WZO has found that the so-called “Eretz Hakodesh” engaged in widespread fraud. 16,000 votes are suspicious and will be invalidated by the WZO Area Election Committee (AEC). This will reduce EHK even further down. The fraud included reusing the same Gmail addresses with periods and plus signs, in order to sign up and vote multiple times for the same email user. As well as paying with prepaid credit card numbers in order to evade signing up multiple times.
Figures that the unscrupulous, unprincipled and deceitful EHK, which tried to encourage true Torah Jews to vote in a heretical election by using falsehoods, would engage in such fraud.
The above was just in the US elections. In the UK election, the WZO postponed the election to a month later due to fraudulent activity where “Eretz Hakodesh” distributed a flyer encouraging husbands to register their wives and children, in what has been determined by the WZO to be a clear incitement to break the rules regarding personal registration only.
Based on this, the AEC recommended that the full Eretz Hakodesh slate be disqualified altogether from the election.
The EHK has made WZO founder Theodor Herzl proud.
June 8, 2025 5:40 pm at 5:40 pm in reply to: circa 1900: Letter from Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Heresy of “Religious” Zionism #2407839ujmParticipantLubavitch has always been strongly anti-Zionist. In fact, the Lubavitcher Rebbes have traditionally been from the most vocal anti-Zionists; Lubavitch is as much anti-Zionist as Satmar and Brisk.
ujmParticipantAAQ: Don’t forget to include in your “Joint Siyum” the “shitot” of Yeshivat Chovevei Torah, Yeshivat Maharat, the International Rabbinic Fellowship, and the Hebrew Institute of Riverdale.
Some of the prominent “Talmidei Chachamim” you might invite include Rabbi Avi Weiss, Rabbi Asher Lopatin, Rabbi Shmuel Herzfeld, Rabbi Ysoscher Katz, Rabbi Daniel Sperber, Rabbi Zev Farber, Rabba Sara Hurwitz and Maharat Ruth Friedman.
Thank you for you non-partisanship!
ujmParticipantIt is the same top notch Yeshiva it has always been.
ujmParticipantAnd Rav Pinchos Scheinberg zt’l learnt in the Beis Medrash LeRabonim yeshiva, in New Haven, famous for being Torah-only — with zero secular studies.
ujmParticipantDaMoshe: It has nothing to do with the Scots or Scotsmen. Theoretically, perhaps, YU could have produced a godol; if not for its krum hashkafas that are kneged HaTorah. But given that YU is what it is, it had about as much chance of producing a godol as the Princeton Theological Seminary has.
Square: Rav Pinchas Scheinberg zt’l was a talmid in Mir (in Poland) and in Kaminetz (also in Poland, at the time.) That’s how he became a godol. Not because went to NYC public school and YU (both of which he passed through).
ujmParticipantDaMoshe: You have a different bar for who you call a godol.
ujmParticipantanon1m0us: YU never produced a single godol in all its history. Some godol’s may have taken a job there as a rebbi to try to be mekarev some of the students there, in the early years when that may have still been possible. But they were not products, themselves, of YU.
May 31, 2025 10:20 pm at 10:20 pm in reply to: Chanyana Weissman and the modern State of Israel #2405408ujmParticipantMr. Weissman had posted on YWN about 10 or so years ago.
ujmParticipantRav Ahron Kotler refused to enter the YU building even when one of his students levaya was inside. Instead, he stood outside.
May 28, 2025 6:51 pm at 6:51 pm in reply to: Christian-Israeli Diplomat and his American Fiancé Killed in Embassy Event #2404167ujmParticipantsomejewiknow: Absolutely.
AAQ: One is permitted al pi halacha to extra-judiciously kill both him and her, the Jew and the gentile, when they engage in intimacy (whether “married” or not).
May 28, 2025 6:51 pm at 6:51 pm in reply to: Jewish critics of the State of Israel, where do they reside? #2404164ujmParticipantsomejewiknow: Excellent point. Yasher Koach.
May 28, 2025 6:51 pm at 6:51 pm in reply to: Rabbi Moshe Sherer and the modern State of Israel #2404162ujmParticipantHaKatan: That is powerful statements you shared from Rav Elchonon hy’d and from the Brisker Rov ztvk’l. Everyone should pay heed to them.
Yasher Koach
ujmParticipantHagaon Harav Elchonon Wasserman hy’d already wrote (the Ksav Yad is available), as far back as in 1940, that it is better to physically die at the hands of the Nazis ym’s rather than be saved from physical death by Yeshiva University and then be spiritually murdered by YU.
May 26, 2025 5:13 pm at 5:13 pm in reply to: Christian-Israeli Diplomat and his American Fiancé Killed in Embassy Event #2403319ujmParticipantMarrying a gentile is one of the things that cuts one off from the Jewish People.
It is one of the type of actions (another is converting to another religion) that Jews traditionally sit Shiva over a person r”l, even before they physically die.
May 26, 2025 5:13 pm at 5:13 pm in reply to: Christian-Israeli Diplomat and his American Fiancé Killed in Embassy Event #2403282ujmParticipantThe Messianic congregation Yaron Lischinsky belonged to seeks to recruit Jews to Yushke worship.
This is who Israel gives visas to immigrate.
ujmParticipantAside from the fact that the high likelihood was that the crime was committed by an intruder into the building, hypothetically if a Yid (including any who dormed there at the time it occurred) had a “hunch” or assumption or theory or suspicion, he would be prohibited to share it with any nochri or authority due to mesira. Especially as there’s no ongoing threat to safety.
May 26, 2025 5:13 pm at 5:13 pm in reply to: Rabbi Moshe Sherer and the modern State of Israel #2403278ujmParticipantSupporting its security from Arab terrorism and war is not support for Zionism or the State. Far from it.
May 25, 2025 4:31 pm at 4:31 pm in reply to: Jewish critics of the State of Israel, where do they reside? #2403211ujmParticipantJews in London, New York and Los Angeles have all the same rights to voice their opinion about Eretz Yisroel, as Jews in Tel Aviv and Haifa. And if someone doesn’t like that, that’s just too bad.
In fact, Torah observant Jews in Jews in London, New York and Los Angeles have *more* right to strongly express their opinions than non-observant Jews in Tel Aviv and Haifa.
ujmParticipantWhy was the maintenance worker not questioned again?
May 23, 2025 2:20 pm at 2:20 pm in reply to: Christian-Israeli Diplomat and his American Fiancé Killed in Embassy Event #2402671ujmParticipantAt the Israeli embassy in Washington, Miss Milgrim was assigned to work with homosexual groups and women’s organizations, and she was in charge of outreach to progressive and social justice-oriented groups.
May 23, 2025 2:20 pm at 2:20 pm in reply to: Rabbi Yaakov Kamenetsky and the modern State of Israel #2402587ujmParticipantKastner was killed by a fellow Zionist in revenge for Kastner being a Nazi collaborator, who worked hand in hand with Adolf Eichmann to murder over half a million of his fellow Hungarian Jews.
Kastner was even found guilty of Nazi collaboration by a Zionist court, Judge Halevi.
May 23, 2025 2:19 pm at 2:19 pm in reply to: The Peaceful Dismantlement of the State of “Israel” #2402583ujmParticipantaheimisherenglisher: That’s true. And even after the Zionists violently seized control of the Holy Land, all the Torah, Yeshivas, Chesed, etc that came about, came despite the best efforts of the Zionists to stop it and impede it; certainly not because of them.
May 23, 2025 2:19 pm at 2:19 pm in reply to: Christian-Israeli Diplomat and his American Fiancé Killed in Embassy Event #2402581ujmParticipantMiss Milgrim was a member of the local Reform Temple in her hometown in Kansas.
ujmParticipantRubio is 100% correct.
ujmParticipantThe janitor let his local accomplice in.
ujmParticipantThe Chareidi parties do NOT take a position on how to conduct the war or when to end it (or not the it).
False narrative.
May 12, 2025 5:03 pm at 5:03 pm in reply to: The Peaceful Dismantlement of the State of “Israel” #2397711ujmParticipantWe should all sing together the song that HaGaon HaRav Sholom Ber Sorotzkin shlit”a sang at his son’s chasuna a few weeks ago in Eretz Yisroel, together with the entire Yeshivas Ateres Shlomo and thousands of other attendees at the Chasuna:
<b>G-d is our King,
We are his servants
The holy Torah is our Law
We are loyal to it.
We do not recognize the Heretic Zionist Regime
Its laws do not apply to us
We walk in the ways of the Torah
In fire and water
We walk in the ways of the Torah
To Sanctify the Name of Heaven</b>
ujmParticipantubiq/Yankel: All three of them are better than the so-called EHK. At least they openly admit to being in the company of kofrim.
And the more of the openly kofrim that win, the less there will be of Jews who wear a yarmulka and publicly and proudly associate and collude with kofrim, thereby possibly confusing true Jews.
ujmParticipantNu, did the so-called Eretz Hakodesh party crash and burn?
May 7, 2025 10:44 am at 10:44 am in reply to: Divide among Torah Schools of Thought: YU/RIETS vs The Greater Yeshiva World #2395937ujmParticipantThe greater Yeshiva world has always been anti-Zionist. From when we were still in Europe before the war.
ujmParticipantNow that voting has closed by the Kefira WZO, how long will it take to confirm how badly the EHK lost?
ujmParticipantGoogle Chat and Hangouts lack an audience.
ujmParticipantHashem is here, Hashem is there, Hashem is truly everywhere.
ujmParticipantAAQ: Karaites are heretical Jews. Kusin/Samaritans are Safek Jews, also heretical.
A Bnei Noach is a righteous gentile.
ujmParticipantYes. Absolutely, someone who hid in Budapest is a Holocaust survivor.
This was never a question and isn’t one now.
-
AuthorPosts