Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
“and you may not refuse to eat in their houses, even from their fleishige keilim!”
Milhouse: Are you making this assertion even if that very piece of what you know with certainty is chazer, but the other Rov ruled to be kosher meat, was used on those very fleishige keilim?!
Chabadshlucha: I didn’t address this comment to you, nor in the past have they been addressed to you despite your consistent sticking your two-cents into discussions way above your head. This was addressed to Philosopher, so you needn’t feel a need to pipe in or announce that you won’t address. In the past when you’ve purported to supposedly challenge the multitude of direct and explicit Torah sources I cited and sourced (that anyone can lookup themselves rather than relying on me), you’ve never been able to do so and instead stumbled and hemmed and hawed with vague non-answers based on your personal feelings and what you openly admitted were your personal reinterpretations of sources that you said you have no source other than your own feelings for.
Gutten Moed and Gutten Erev Shabbos.
Queens is not much smaller than Brooklyn in either geographic size or in population.
Philosopher: Please identify which, if any, of the following are from medieval Christian or Islamic religions:
Bereishis 3:16, Bereishis 18:12
Tehilim 45:11-12, which the Menoras Hame’or 2:176 says teaches us that a wife should not view her husband as an equal but rather as her master.
Shulchan Aruch, Y.D. 240:17, which explicitly states wives are subservient to their husband.
Ben Yehoyada, Menachos 43b, which says so as well.
Rambam, Hilchos Ishus 15:20, which states a wife must do all her deeds according to what her husband says, she should fear him and he should be in her eyes as a ruler or king.
אגרות משה אורח חיים חלק ד סימן עה
As far as listening, Bava Metzia 59a says a husband who listens to his wife on matters of religion/ruchniyos issues will end up in gehenom.
iac: Where do you see Rav Moshe ever write that Queens is any different than Brooklyn, insofar as the Halacha l’maaisa on eiruven are concerned?
ZD: What if a legitimate posek mistakenly paskens that a piece of chazer is kosher meat, can/will you eat it?
laskern: Dr. Pepper is the Coffee Room’s longtime in-house mathematician and expert. He’s been a member here as long as the Coffee Room has existed. And though his last post was a few days short of six months ago, he hasn’t been very active for the last number of years.
Dr. Pepper, say it ain’t so,
We truly don’t want to see you go.
Please come back and stay,
And have a decaf to brighten up your day.
April the First isn’t the only time,
That we want to read your pearls of wisdom in a day.Shimen: Rav Moshe writes that you can’t use Shabbos clocks for an air conditioner.
laskern: You should’ve met our old friend in the CR, Dr. Pepper.
Last week Mr. Shmully Yanklowitz of YCT, who claims to have an Orthodox conversion despite his heretical beliefs, posted online that just as shelo asani isha is sexist so too shelo asani goy is “xenophobic Jewish exceptionalism”. And that both blessings need to equally be replaced.
There’s nothing wrong with subservience. People are subservient to Hashem. Avodim are subservient to their master. Rabbonim are subservient to Gedolim. The hamon hoam are subservient to Rabbonim. Yisroelim are subservient to Kohanim. And women are subservient to men.
There’s nothing different about the last mentioned subservience than with any of the previous ones. Whereas no one has problems with all the previous exemples of subservience, the only reason the latter example raises any hackles is due to the influence of the gentile world that unfortunately surrounds us and has influenced too many of us into sharing their corrupt values. And the latter example is something that the gentile world over the last hundred years has changed to promoting egalitarianism that was never a societal value, even by them, beforehand.
Gaon, how are you certain they never saw it?
Reuven: “The sky is red.”
Shimon: “No, the sky is blue.”
Anonymous Jew: “Shimon, What’s your source that the sky is blue? I have no question on what Reuven said.”AJ: As I knew and you’ve again proven, you have no respect for the truth or care to find it.
I’m not compelled to address your disingenuous queries. If it weren’t disingenuous you’d have first asked as I suggested.
Schumer is a far bigger liar than Trump ever was. And that’s just one example.
Casquettes? That’s like a baseball or racing cap.
DY: Do you have an example of a Choson watch available for $500?
Skype video chat?
Wasn’t their some story about a disagreement between the Rebbetzin of the Frierdika regarding her son-in-law becoming Rebbe that led to the hat change?
DovidBT: Brace yourself for the “AYLOR and don’t post to the CR” type answers. (Calling: apushatayid.)
Or do they only make those Ask Your Local Orthodox Rabbi demands when they’re uncomfortable with the question/discussion. (In which case this thread will be okay for them.)
CTLawyer: How’d my daughter behave over yuntif?
If you’ll recall, in your early days in the CR you were trying to effectively post who you are, by giving very detailed activities and locations about yourself, but the mods had to restrain you by redacting pertinent details in your posts even though you said you were okay with anyone knowing who you are.
Redleg, was it really necessary to give an entire megilla saying what I already said in seven words?
Pino’s Apple Orchards.
CTLawyer: What are the titles?
MNC Contractors.
iac: Where does Rav Moshe ever make that distinction that you’ve just described?
Moshe Rabbeinu and Aharon HaKohen
Avi: Do you blame today’s Arabs for Chevron ’29 or Entebee?
This is an old halachic shaila long addressed in the sh”ut.
The President cannot change or make laws.
You’re thinking of dictators.
iac/thinker: The US Census updates its figures periodically more than its full enumeration decennial count. Every couple years or so they provide an updated count to account for the changes since the last full census. These counts also include both legal residents and illegal aliens.
Even without considering the Census’ ACS mid-decade updates, you can look at both the 1970 and 1980 decennial census’ to see if the estimates numbers align with those from the office census (which includes all residents, including illegals.)
Furthermore, regarding changes to Brooklyn’s population from 1980 through today in 2018, wouldn’t those population changes potentially affect the psak since the psak is determined based on population?
Of all people in the whole wild world, Froggie, methinks you have never said anything remotely controversial. Unlike, cough, someone else on this thread.
iac: The US Census includes illegal aliens in their population figures for any area. Does your response indicate that the psak added a figure in its population assumption above the US Census figure? Because the Census figure already included all residents, legal or not. Thus adding an assumption above the Census would result in an inaccurate over-estimate.
A kaporas chicken usually cost about $9 each. (If you also do shechita it’s usually about an additional $4 each.) Most people with the minhag get separate chickens for each spouse and child.
There’s no particularly set amount of money required for those that have the minhag to use money for kaporas.
iac: The US Census issues very accurate population figures for Brooklyn and every individual zip code within Brooklyn. Were the estimates used for the psak in line with the US Census figures?
And would a changing population figure over the years for Brooklyn effectively change what the psak holds whether an eiruv is permitted?
Amil, everything you described is how to treat animals like animals. No contradictions.
Ubiq: Look at the shoresh of the word. It shows that goythink is to treat animals like pseudo-humans.
“how did this get ressurrected?”
By someone posting to this thread.
Animals should be treated like animals, not humanely.
ghadora clearly has no objections with welfare dependency by certain minority groups, who he does not demand to be forced off of government entitlement programs.
Do you view government welfare as the equivalent to the Jewish concept of tzedaka, including its obligations for the non-poor and its entitlements to the poor?
squeak, who still prefers to not reveal which famous personage he is, has been posting on YWN for over a decade.
Dennis Prager has posted here in the Coffee Room.
Rabbi Yitzchok Adlerstein has also posted here in the past.
A Rov/posek in Eretz Yisroel frequently posted in the Coffee Room for years.
Dr. Prof. Charlie Hall from YU has been a frequent poster here for many years.
Met and had a conversation with — or saw at a gathering?