- This topic has 300 replies, 21 voices, and was last updated 1 hour, 31 minutes ago by .
-
Posts
-
@UJM:
Although the deceased Satmar Rav may have rejected some of the tactics of the Neturei Kapos, the current Satmars are not obeying the directives of the deceased Satmar Rav.
It appears that a fake distinction between Satmars and Neturei Kapos has been manufactured to protect Satmar business interests.
Your pathetic fake slander of Netanyahu is obvious – he is not “Chazer-Fressing”, the Knesset does not serve chazer.
Netanyahu is constantly responsible for protecting Jewish lives in Eretz Yisrael, so he cannot really keep Shabbos.
Is Netanyahu a pious frum Jew? Definitely not.
But I’m pretty sure he has more of an olam habah than NYC Satmar/Neturei Kapos who aid and abet enemies of the Jews.yankel> the main point he was making is – that one cannot trade
> trade – meaning gaining one thing for the benefit of anotherThanks for the clarification. If this were a real equal trade-off – maybe you can rely on shev ve lo taase. For example, if you are under Nazis in Poland, maybe not worth running towards being under communists in Poland. Or, if you are under communists in Poland, no reason to run towards Nazis in Poland … but in this case, I don’t think there was a symmetry – there was no magic frum oilam left somewhere protected that would have been better than matzav in EY. Small yerushalmi kahal, as important as it was, could not stand on it’s own.
Yankel Berel, thank you for your valuable quote from the Penei Yehoshua ZTL ZYA.
I wish you a happy Chanukah and a safe and warm winter.
its not my ‘“Satmarism replacement theology”
it definitely is authentic torah
penei yehoshua is standard ‘authentic torah’
this is basic to any beginner torah student …
.
.re your quote of rambam — rambam himself conditions kapara with teshuva , al derech hapnei yehoshua — cf rambam hilhot tshuva
without tshuva there is nowadays no kapara at all
also clear to any serious student of rambams writings
.
.equally clear that rambam when he says ‘amru hahamim’ — rambam is referring to the gemara in ketuvot which is the subject of the PN’Y
which I quoted
so again —- according to the torah as we received it from the previous generations —- not sure who should really be weeping here ….
.
.
.rightjew :
Your pathetic fake slander of Netanyahu is obvious – he is not “Chazer-Fressing”, the Knesset does not serve chazer.
Netanyahu is constantly responsible for protecting Jewish lives in Eretz Yisrael, so he cannot really keep Shabbos.
———————–
total rubbish.
because knesset is not serving chazzer , is that proof that bibi doesn’t privately eat chazzer ???
where is elementary logic ???
because bibi is responsible for lives in EY , is that an excuse for bibi’s documented unrelated hilul shabbat ???
reasoning and methodology used — reminds me of somejew and katan …..
.
.@AAQ
the whole idea from rav mibrisk was that no trade off is permitted —- at all .
equal or unequal .
nothing .
.
.ujm should not use the word gestapo when describing israeli police tactics even when they are unjustified
there is no comparison whatsoever between gestapo tactics and israeli police tactics
any objective researcher of the holocaust will concur
usage of totally inapropriate language , besides being factually incorrect and undermining ujm’s credibility …
… also supports the villains who are waiting to spill our own and ujm’s brothers innocent blood
.
.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.